*This Creepypasta fanfic chapter is underneath my folder titled “Creepypasta stuff”. This is my interpretation/AU of Nina the Killer’s backstory. Jeff the Killer (this version, anyway) was created by GameFuelTV. Nina the Killer was created by Alegotic-Twevel. Laughing Jack was created by Snuffbomb. Alyssa is my OC, so is Kevin, Zoe, and Sienna. (Claudia was apart of Nina’s original story and is not my OC). Gacha Club character designs are under my forum titled “My character designs<33[2]”. Enjoy!*

The day had passed on late into the afternoon, the time for everyone to go home. Nina and Alyssa were walking over to Nina’s house, as they always did after school. Alyssa was going on about some rag doll that she got from her Grandma, but Nina couldn’t quite focus. She was too busy thinking over Claudia’s words, thinking over how she’d talk to Alyssa, how-

“Did you ever try summoning any Creepypastas when you were younger? Because I have.” Alyssa suddenly said.

Oh, that was perfect! She could talk to Alyssa about what she was thinking about without it sounding awkward or accusatory! Perfect!

“I mean, yes, I attempted to summon Jeff the Killer a year ago, but he didn’t come. Were you ever lucky?” Nina asked.

Right after she mentioned Jeff the Killer, she thought about how her friends, Zoe and Sienna, were there with her when she tried to summon them, how they were still alive, and then, the news report that morning about the burned houses, the empty void of text messages that would never be answered, the innocent girly-girl movies she used to watch with them back when they were younger a symbol of everything lost, everything gone, something dismal and liminal and-

“I’m sorry that Jeff didn’t come to you, but Laughing Jack came to me! I just didn’t do what the summoning told me to do. That’s a rookie mistake, to do what the summoning says. If you want to summon a Creepypasta, blood has to be shed. This was common sense for me and-“

Alyssa stopped herself, as though she were beginning to regret what she was saying. Nina didn’t care about that, though. She had to get her thoughts out and she had to let them out before she forgot.

“Claudia told me today at gym that you sliced her arm in third grade to try and summon Laughing Jack. Is that true?” Nina asked.

Alyssa’s face set into a glare, something that took Nina aback, because normally, Alyssa was always in a smiley mood. Alyssa’s lips curled into a snarl and then:

“Of course it’s true, but Claudia ran away before I could complete it! She made Laughing Jack mad and then he took Kevin away! If it weren’t for her then Kevin would still be here and-and…”

Alyssa stopped, her voice choked with tears. But Nina was left even more confused than before. Who was Kevin and why was she talking about him being “taken away”? How did she know to use blood for summonings? Alyssa was interesting and Nina didn’t mind talking to her, but seriously, did she have a life outside of Creepypasta? Did she really want to talk to Alyssa anymore?

The both of them got up to Nina’s house, but she wasn’t quite ready for Alyssa to go yet, so she turned around and-

Alyssa was gone.