But was it so bad?

by creeperfeverdreams

Published September 13, 2026

16+ Violence

In Creepypasta stuff

Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for violence.

*This fanfic is under my folder “Creepypasta stuff”. Gacha Club character designs are under this forum: https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic/117842-my-character-designs-lt-33-3?start=210. Laughing Jack is a Creepypasta character that can be googled, Alyssa is my OC. Enjoy!*

The boys in Alyssa’s school were nothing like the boys in the movies she watched in childhood. They were filthy, they didn’t care about feelings, and they made fun of what girls had to say. Especially girls like her.

Was it a crime to love monsters? Was it such a bad thing to want to bleed in pain, if it were for someone worthy?

Alyssa didn’t think so. As she lay on the dirt ground in Laughing Jack’s circus tent, blood spewing out of her right arm, she smiled to herself. He filled the wound up with candies, to make it sweeter. Yes, he would bite her arm.

But it was alright, because she was helping someone who cared for her. Someone who would do anything for her.

 

It was only fair that she helped Laughing Jack.

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
gofast
Review
gofast wrote a review Review · Sep 13

The boys in Alyssa’s school were nothing like the boys in the movies she watched in childhood. They were filthy, they didn’t care about feelings, and they made fun of what girls had to say. Especially girls like her.


oof, that hit home. boys are a real work of art in that department. nailed it.

Was it a crime to love monsters? Was it such a bad thing to want to bleed in pain, if it were for someone worthy?


“is it a crime to die for someone?” how romantic. nod nod.

Alyssa didn’t think so. As she lay on the dirt ground in Laughing Jack’s circus tent, blood spewing out of her right arm, she smiled to herself. He filled the wound up with candies, to make it sweeter. Yes, he would bite her arm.


i do love a little cannibalism as a metaphor for over-consuming love. smacks lips.

But it was alright, because she was helping someone who cared for her. Someone who would do anything for her.



It was only fair that she helped Laughing Jack.


genuinely so intrigued to read more; it feels like alyssa may be taking on more than she can chew, or looking at this relationship with rose tinted glasses.

yes, she sees in rose-tinted glasses for sure.

User avatar
4revgreen
Review
4revgreen wrote a review Review · Sep 13

Hi Creeper!

This was... short and sweet, we'll say. I think you could go a little more into her head and how she thinks about the school because it's interesting to me. But like, why the hell is she in a human school because I CAN'T BLAME THEM FOR NOT LIKING HER , LOL!! Another goood chapter :)

Observations Whilst Reading:

The boys in Alyssa’s school were nothing like the boys in the movies she watched in childhood


Ohh ain't this true XD

They were filthy, they didn’t care about feelings, and they made fun of what girls had to say. Especially girls like her.


Alyssa, I am with you here. A part from a few good ones, most boys in my school were like this haha

Was it a crime to love monsters? Was it such a bad thing to want to bleed in pain, if it were for someone worthy?


Does this mean, Alyssa wants to bleed in pain? Or she wants to make someone else bleed in pain? Am a little confused here!

Alyssa didn’t think so. As she lay on the dirt ground in Laughing Jack’s circus tent, blood spewing out of her right arm, she smiled to herself. He filled the wound up with candies, to make it sweeter. Yes, he would bite her arm.


OH OKAY SO IT IS HERSELF, MY BAD. JESUS ALYSSA YOU REALLY THREW ME IN HERE. I AM SCARED.

But it was alright, because she was helping someone who cared for her. Someone who would do anything for her.


This world is sooo twisted Creeper, how do you even come up with this stuff!

It was only fair that she helped Laughing Jack.


I wonder what on EARTH she is going to help him with. Because i am SCAREDDD

thx for reading/advice! glad you liked it!

User avatar
yuuki
Review
yuuki wrote a review Review · Sep 13

HIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHI I will review for cookies

The boys in Alyssa’s school were nothing like the boys in the movies she watched in childhood. They were filthy, they didn’t care about feelings, and they made fun of what girls had to say.


hmm, this sounds like my school to be honest. Boys are interesting, to say the least. But alas, boys will be bugs.

I think this is a great short story, and the story in itself is so suspenseful despite being short. It's not your average short story. It's really great in my opinion, I needed something dark to read lol.

But it was alright, because she was helping someone who cared for her. Someone who would do anything for her.


I feel like not many people have this mindset, which is interesting to think about because it's very easy to start thinking this way.

Anyway thank you for the lovely story!!!!

Arigato!!
Yuuki

I’m glad you like it! I have more fanfics about this character if you’re interested! ^v^



#longlivebigbrother
— alliyah