*This fanfic is under my folder titled “Creepypasta stuff”. Jeff the Killer is a Creepypasta character created by GameFuelTV (the one I’m mentioning here, anyway. There are two version of him). Nina the Killer is a Creepypasta character created by Alegotic-Twevel. Zoe and Sienna are my OCs. Wattpad is a popular writing site, with Creepypasta summonings that will not actually work because the characters don’t exist. Supposedly what Nina is about to do is how one summons Jeff. Anyway, this is a little dark but also a little humorous (I hope). Gacha Club character designs are under my forum titled “My character designs<33[2]”. Enjoy!*

*Phone calls begins*

“Hi Sienna! How are you?”

“I’m good, Nina. You?”

“I’m good too. Come over to my house, we’re going to summon Jeff the killer.”

“…”

“Sienna?”

“I don’t think that’s a good idea.”

“Why not? Zoe is coming over too! We’re going to do it together. It’ll be fun!”

“But what if he kills us?”

“He won’t. He only goes after people who don’t get it. I get it, so we’re good. Jeff is going to be my boyfriend.”

“Really?”

“Really.”

“Okay. I’ll come over, if you insist.”

*Phone call ends*

……………………………………………………………………………………………..

Nina knew that the way to summon Jeff would require only one person, but she wanted Sienna to be around to record her and Zoe to be the one narrating. It was going to be a real documentation of THE Jeff the killer!

So, Nina did exactly what the people in Wattpad said and was lying in her bed at midnight, holding a butter knife (it didn’t say that she needed a specific kind of knife, so she chose the one that was the least likely to permanently scar her face if she slipped up) to her heart, her blanket draped over her whole body. She was excited to hear him, a little scared that he would kill her, but most of all, she did not want to be made a fool. Sienna had her phone out and was prepared to record Nina, Zoe was getting ready to narrate every little moment like a nature documentary. Nina already knew that she looked pretty ridiculous, lying in bed with a butter knife to her heart, waiting for a creature that may not come, but she held on to hope that he would grace her presence, that he would be there to bless her with his glorious goriness.

Besides, he was an attractive anime boy and had a tragic backstory that she could connect with, so he shouldn’t have any reason to hurt her, because she was not like other girls.

“Nina, this is the kind of thing people do in horror movies. This is the kind of thing that gets them killed. Again, do you really want to do this? This is a school night, we should probably all be in bed right now. You don’t want us to fail-“

“This is more important than any stupid test in the world, Sienna! I have to talk to Jeff, I need to get him to be my boyfriend! He’s the only one who will truly get me and so I must not chicken out!” Nina cried out, trying to push back any lingering fears. She must not be afraid when she saw his beautifully handsome face, she must not!

“Nina, go on ahead and do this. If this one thing will get you to stop talking about Jeff, I don’t care. He’s not real and he never will be. Might I add that you look incredibly stupid right now? I mean, really, you should see yourself. And come on. You’re gonna believe some crusty, unemployed, brainrotted twelve year old on Wattpad saying that you could “die” or “go insane” from this? You should know that middle schoolers barely know anything, so what they say doesn’t matter! But you still want to do this?”

Nina felt herself burn with anger at Zoe’s words. How could she go about saying those horrible things? Jeff was out there, she could sense it, and she was going to prove to them that he’d appear!

“You don’t know if the person was twelve or not! They could have been older and saw some pretty spooky stuff and are now relaying their tales to Wattpad! You don’t know anything! Sienna, turn the camera on, I’m ready!” Nina cried out, prepared to let the killer out.

Nina let a few seconds go by before she saw Zoe look over at Sienna’s phone to check to see if she was recording, then Zoe said:

“Our friend, Nina, shall attempt to summon the notorious emo teenager with a knife, Jeff the Killer! You, dear viewers, even though you cannot see her, mayfind it strange that she is holding a butter knife underneath the blanket, but the internet did not specify what kind of knife to use, so technically, any knife can work, even a plastic one! But that’s too cringe, so she grabbed a butter knife instead! Come now, Nina! Recite ye spell!”

Nina rolled her eyes at Zoe’s corniness, then said “Jeff the Killer” three times, just like the Wattpad person instructed, and waited.

And waited.

And waited some more.

Wasn’t Jeff supposed to instantly come and say “Shh. Go to sleep.”? Wasn’t that supposed to happen? Why were they all still waiting? She didn’t want to hold the knife any longer and she was getting quite hot under the blanket! Why wasn’t he there yet? Why-

“And there you have it! Jeff the Killer is not real! Children, do not believe the stuff you read from Creepypasta fans, because the fandom itself is populated by idiotic edgelord teens. Focus instead on not failing school. Zoe, out!”

Nina pushed back the covers, enraged that Zoe was leaving. Not only that, she could see that Sienna stopped recording and was leaving with Zoe!

“Come back! What if Jeff is here? What if he’s hiding in the shadows! What if-“

“I don’t want to talk about this anymore. It’s late and you should be lucky your parents and Chris didn’t find out. Your parents would ground you and Chris would tease you. Just go to sleep.” Sienna said.

Nina supposed that going to sleep would be the best choice for her to make, but still, she was upset that Jeff hadn’t come.

Either it didn’t work or she should have been alone. No matter what, she wouldn’t give up!