Why did she love him at all?

by creeperfeverdreams

Published July 24, 2026

12+

In Creepypasta stuff

*This fanfic is underneath my folder titled “Creepypasta stuff”. Gacha Club character designs are under this forum: https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic/117842-my-character-designs-lt-33-3?start=120. Laughing Jack is a Creepypasta character who can be googled, Alyssa is my OC. Anyway, enjoy!*

There should have been no reason for Alyssa Marie Stevins to love or even like Laughing Jack and yet, there she was, caring for him with every ounce of her being.

Laughing Jack’s existence had only begun being recorded in 2013, but he existed longer than that. Her Grandma had met him and he was there to console her when all of her friends died. Sure, the gory murders were suspiciously akin to how Laughing Jack’s kills were, but that didn’t mean that he killed them. Humans were also capable of such atrocities.

And when Alyssa herself met him, he had shown nothing but kindness towards her. He cared about helping her find Kevin, he wanted to keep her safe from her parents, from the world, he wanted to make her smile…

His stories were full of blood and gore, but he was so, so, so much more than that, she could sense it. The stories didn’t do him any justice, she needed to write more about him, to show the world just how truly amazing and caring he was, he deserved to be known for all the love and compassion he had, she just needed to do him justice.

Alyssa wouldn’t fail him.

Comments & reviews · 3
User avatar
4revgreen
Review
4revgreen wrote a review Review · Aug 1

More Laughing Jack - oh no, I am ready to be freaked out!

There should have been no reason for Alyssa Marie Stevins to love or even like Laughing Jack and yet, there she was, caring for him with every ounce of her being.


Umm yeah Alyssa, there is no reason you should feel like that about LJ! I’m only joking, but it makes for an interesting start to Alyssa's character. Is she just very sympathetic or is there a deeper reason? I’m intrigued to find out.

Laughing Jack’s existence had only begun being recorded in 2013, but he existed longer than that.


This sentence reads a little but clumsy. I think something my like “Though Laughing Jack’s first recorded appearance was in 2013, he had existed long before that.” Is a little more concise.

Humans were also capable of such atrocities.


This is a good line! I like the way Alyssa is trying to defend him

And when Alyssa herself met him, he had shown nothing but kindness towards her. He cared about helping her find Kevin, he wanted to keep her safe from her parents, from the world, he wanted to make her smile…


Ohhh so this is why she likes him! He showed her kindness! I wonder why he cared for her? It makes such an interesting dynamic, you always have such a way with your plots like this!

Alyssa wouldn’t fail him.


Why am I getting the feeling this isn’t going to stay true XD

Another great extract from you.

I’m glad you like it! I linked other fanfics that connect to this in the comment above yours, but this particular one goes more into depth on why she likes him: You will never understand him like I do.

Thx for reading!

User avatar
Tikaya
Review
Tikaya wrote a review Review · Jul 26

And yay more LJ! You are starting to win me over on him btw (I generally do not like murderous ppl, be they clowns or no xd)

Oh is this the same Alyssa as from the Nina story or a different universe Alyssa?
I love the info that her grandma was already involved with LJ!

I like how you point this out:

Humans were also capable of such atrocities.
Even tho the entire thing was very suspicious. Now I wonder if Alyssa is maybe a grandchild of LJ…

I also really love how you portray her enthusiasm about him and how ready she is to ignore all the stories. They might as well be fabrications in THIS universe after all. There are quite a few versions of the character, even in YOUR portfolio… so maybe this is one of the good ones? Or maybe Alyssa is only deluding herself. Love the ambiguity!

Fantastic little snippet :3

Image
Join the fight! Write more reviews!

Yes, it is the same Alyssa. I’m writing a part two of the story you’re reading with Nina which is about her. It isn’t on this site but it will be when I’m finished.

And don’t worry, Nina will eventually kill people!

Thx for reading/advice.



The last of the human freedoms is to choose one's attitudes.
— Viktor Frankl