That fine fall morning! (Part Two)

*This fanfic is underneath my folder titled “Creepypasta stuff”. Gacha Club character designs are under my forum titled “My character designs<33[2]”. All of the characters in this story, except for Janice, have been created by other people for the Creepypasta fandom. Janice is my OC. This is also a fanfic that ships Jeff the Killer with Laughing Jack and Janice is their ship child. Now, this fanfic is told in three different perspectives: Jeff: 🩸🔪🫀, LJ: 🍭🎪🖤, and Janice: 🦄✨🪱. The different emojis will let you know whose POV it is. Now…I hope you enjoy and Happy Spooky Season!*

🩸🔪🫀

Jeff stabbed his knife deep into the dining room table, trying to direct his violence towards something that couldn’t feel, couldn’t think.

Laughing Jack stood next to his chair, gripping the top of it as if he too were restraining himself. Perhaps he was, because they both hated what they were about to show.

Across from them was Jeff’s twin brother, Liu, and Liu’s husband, Eyeless Jack. They both stared at them (Eyeless Jack didn’t actually stare, as he had no eyes), waiting for whatever terrible news would be told.

The Rake was crawling around the house, as it was not content to stay still. Slenderman and Zalgo were supposed to come, but as soon as Slenderman and Zalgo saw each other, they started to fight and then they teleported into another dimension.

So it was just the five of them in Jeff and Laughing Jack’s old, broken house, with something even worst…

“Me and Jack were shopping at Spirit Halloween, getting decorations and a costume for Janice, when we saw this.” Jeff said, tossing the plastic bag carrying the poorly designed costume of himself onto the table.

“What? What is this? I can’t even see it.”

“It’s a low budget costume of my brother. Here, I’ll take it out for you so you can get a feel of it.” Liu said, opening up the package and handing the costume to Eyeless Jack.

As Eyeless Jack was opening up the costume, Liu turned to Jeff with a suspicious smile on his face and said:

“I don’t know why you’re complaining, Jeff. That costume looks exactly like you! They got all the details right! The coarse hair, the ugly face-“

“I’m not the ugly one. The only thing that makes you look scary are those stitches on your face, the rest of you looks like an attempt to be human. I bet you haven’t even killed a lot of people! You probably killed only five people. You’re too scared to-“

“Scared? I grew up with you as a brother, what do I have to be scared of? And just because I don’t go around killing people every five seconds doesn’t mean-“

“But you call yourself “homicidal”. You have to live up to the name.” Jeff said, springing out of his chair and pointing his knife at Liu.

In that moment, all Jeff could see was Liu and all he could hear was the night that he ran away from home, the night that he tried to kill Liu, but somehow wasn’t successful. Nothing else mattered to him in that moment but doing what he failed at when he was thirteen years old. Why did Liu survive? He stabbed him multiple times, he got Liu’s heart…or did he miss?

The thought of him actually missing a spot in a murder made Jeff want to puke his decaying heart out.

“I kill whoever I think deserves it. Put that knife down and talk to me like an adult. That’s what you are, right?”

That did it. Liu, his younger twin brother, could not talk to him like that. Ever.

So in that moment, Eyeless Jack was getting ready to leave, The Rake and Smile Dog were fighting, and Laughing Jack was trying to stop Liu and Jeff from fighting with his magic. But the Woods brothers wouldn’t stop, for every second that the clown Magic pulled them apart, they just got back to fighting, again and again and-

“You guys think that you have it so bad. They made a costume of me on Amazon and called me Alice the Psycho. That’s NOT my name! Alice is dead. How could they have the nerve to confuse me with her? I bet the girls dressing up as this costume don’t even know who I am!” A woman’s enraged voice cried out.

Jeff, who was in the middle of stabbing Liu, turned to look towards the voice.

The woman was pale, as was her hair. She wore clothes of black and white and had a stitches smile, like a Jack Skellington grin. She held a sledgehammer as easily as if it were a purse and…and Jeff still had no idea who she was.

“Who the hell are you and why are you in my house? GET OUT!” Jeff screeched, jumping away from Liu and headed towards-

“While I admire your quick-thinking to jump into violence, please don’t get rid of her. I’ll break her apart, because Zero is clearly copying me. You know how you have that psycho fangirl, Nina? Well, this is Zero with me, except she doesn’t want to admit that she’s my fangirl.” Laughing Jack said, his claw around Jeff’s shirt collar.

Laughing Jack had a crazy fangirl? Jeff never heard about them before, but it was nice to know that he wasn’t the only one who had to deal with an insane copycat.

“Fangirl?! Fangirl? You’re absolutely disgusting, I would never-“

“Oh really? You think that you’re original? You were an imaginary friend of a girl named Alice who was brought to life, then brutally murdered her when she forgot about you. You’re black and white and like gore. That thing you had with Alice sounds like me and Isaac. The way you look and what you like is just me, except you’re not a clown who can do amazing feats of magic. You’re just…Zero. Zero fits you, because like zero, you are nothing.” Laughing Jack seethed, letting go of Jeff and grinning at her, black smoke slinking out of his body.

Nothing really scared Jeff, but the way Laughing Jack hissed, just the note of it sent chills down his spine.

“You do not get to say that to me.” Zero said, raising her sledgehammer towards Laughing Jack, one of her eyes twitching, a smile on her face that matched Jeff’s when he was thirteen: Forced.

Zero and Laughing Jack were fighting, Jeff and Liu were fighting, The Rake and Smile Dog were fighting, everybody was trying to kill each other except Eyeless Jack, who was too annoyed with how they were all acting to do anything about it and just watched. Well, he watched as well as he could for somebody who had no eyes.

Jeff would deal with Zero later, but first, he had to show Liu that he was in the wrong, that he deserved to get scarred, that-

“What the heck is going on here?”

Jeff froze. So did everyone else. He knew that vaguely childish, mostly raspy voice because he had lived with it throughout his adult life, but there was no way…

He looked up from Liu and saw…Janice?! Seriously?!

“You’re supposed to be in school. Go to school now before I get a call from the principal!” Jeff shouted, his throat throbbing from all of the yelling and his head burning with irritation.

Why did everyone want to make him mad?