Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
140,237 Literary Works • 673,049 Reviews
who are you lol? all your poems are interesting
Jack--
It's too long. You lost momentum after the third stanza and concluded by succumbing to repetitive images and meaningless phraseology. That is not to say, however, that there are not redemptive qualities in the last few lines, nay, the last stanza, in particular. I'd like to see the last stanza woven into the poem.
What you've done, here, is what beginning poets do with emotions: description. You gave us a description of a girl, albeit vividly and with bravado, still, it is only a description. You need an idea in the background that plays off of the images in order for us to leave it thinking 'Wow', which is where the last stanza comes in. While the last stanza is trite, love can not be written on enough, and you've carefully worded it to make a monologue between the reader and yourself. Focus on making the images of the girl reverberate off of the last stanza. The third stanza, for instance, beautifully and artistically captures the last stanza without explicitly saying, 'This is the point, look at me!'.
The repetition of, 'a girl' can be tastefully done, which it is, the first three times, but otherwise it becomes clunky and makes me want to stop reading. It, ultimately, becomes filler. The fourth and fifth stanzas are bathetic. Your words are ordinary: they convey nothing but adolescent navel gazing.
This could be much better if you reworked and revised it.
Regards,
brad
In general, I liked this.
I love those lines.. The entire beginning of this poem makes it good. Those are great descriptions.
After that, however, I feel as if the descriptions and way things are worded don't quite match up to the beginning. They're 'good' - but the beginning was 'great'.
"I know a girl" is a really vivid poem. The descriptions are brilliant, you can really imagine this girl. Th best thing about the poem is that the character is so believable. Even though there are a lot of people like this girl the poem still describes her as being a person on her on, not just one of the clones or sheep that I know. You approach this topic and make people see it in a new light. I actually love this poem.
great poem, very descriptive and good imagery. I quite like the use of 'cherry lipstick' in the first stanza, as cherry sounds innocent and sweet, but it is also a shade of red, which can also represent danger.
The last line is a good twist, although, i would give subtle hints throughout the poem, to make it more powerful, and also to give some sort of reason for your final comment, or else it's too random.
Wow, beautiful. I love how I can read your poems and understand everything and yet find this layer of mystery. Your stuff is very easy to read, and addictive. Gorgeous imagery. Well done.
for me this was too simple, too easily written. the thoughts seemed cliché, i felt like i'd read all this before. the last verse, for me, was too....i think i'll steal mesh's word here and say "clunky". it didn't flow well, and i felt you over-explained the poem. there was a kind of bitterness in the poem too which i felt took away from it rather then added. i thought the image of "cherry lipstick" has been done a thousand times, i feel like every girl in every poem has a cherry something (and i'm probably guilty of that as well).
i did like the idea of it and i can really see what you're going for. some of the images were good (the second to last verse was really great and you know, about 2 weeks ago i was sitting in a leather armchair in a classy bar drinking an alcopop waiting for all the italians to look at me....so for a second i was like "HAS JACK BEEN WATCHING ME?"! oh and also liked the second verse muchly as well) but overall this poem just didn't flow for me.
anyhoops, i'd say i've rambled on enough. not my favourite of yours but not the worst thing i've seen in my life either
like a horror movie with less screaming
but even more hollywood fakes.
hehe, YES! Very good, me thinks.
she's the sort of girl who looks at you briefly,
before searching the room for a better customer
and less complications.
first two lines are fine, but the last one.. I can't decide if it works or not.. reading it one way it sounds good, another way it just sounds a bit awkward.. maybe its the line break where it is, and if read with the line break its a little off, but without it works fine (hehe, long explination)
i know a girl who likes to feign romance
for the sake of image, because she likes to humanise
"for the sake of image" sounds clunky.. and the rest of the stanza feels just a bit wordy to me.
she's the sort of girl i used to ridicule,
laugh at the sheep that dogged her footsteps,
she's the sort of girl i used to hate
but now she lives at the forefront of my mind.
hmm.. last line. Idea works, but not the presentation as much for me. Just playing with ideas here (aka thinking aloud again), but if you just omit the last line, or any variation, I rather like the effect, but it also the rhythem then feels off.. without the "she" it sound good.. but this is all speculation on my part.
Overall, pretty good, not my favourite of yours, but that's all perspective (er, maybe it is now that I've ripped into it). I do agree with Ari the "I know a girl" seems cliche, but I think you pulled it off quite nicely. Some very vivid images, such as "cherry lipstick" "hollywood fakes" "handbag full of boys" and the fifth stanza.
Wow Jack... You're amazing with images! I totally agree with everything 'Reida said. Great job!
Hmm... very interesting. The whole "i know a girl" seems to be kind of cliched, but you still did a good job with it (no duh). I love how you always turn your poems upside down and made the reader look at them differently. The last stanza was great, and I loved the lipstick thing with the pretentious messages. Awesomeness.