Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
125,020 Literary Works • 672,732 Reviews
Good job, overall. It needs polishing, I think, but if it's part of a novel, then you've definitely got a long way to go without worrying about polishing.
"It was as if she was invincible as waves were split in two by the sheer power of the bow."
Grammatically it should be: "It was as if she WERE invincible..." and since you use the "were" again a few words down, you might consider reworking the sentence. Something like: "invincible; the waves being split in two by the sheer power of the bow." I think the first part of the sentence (to invincible) is strong enough to stand on its own.
"Lieutenant Robert Shaw stood nonchalantly on the stern of the vessel, using a golden telescope with confidence and staring at the trail the ship had made through the ocean."
"...and staring" is a little awkward. Something like: "...using a golden telescope with confidence to stare at..." sounds better.
" “That she likes to spread her wings, sir,” the boy replied on cue, with a huge grin on his face."
I love this. But I think that's the general agreement.
"Maybe it’s just idle paranoia. You’ve been expecting the worse ever since … the Lieutenant shook himself from his mind to find that the boy was looking at him in a curious manner. “Is something the matter, sir?” "
Great element of suspense. I think you need to split this up, though. "Is something the matter, sire?" needs to be a new paragraph.
"Someone else was flying with the Pegasus."
Great ending.
-Sarah
I'll be looking forward too it, hon. Can't resist a good historical fiction...
"topgallant" is indeed a spiffy word...
- If you are going to cut down on this sentence as Sam suggested, here is my suggestion: Her mainmast topgallant pierced the merging rain clouds, while her bowsprit pointed defiantly towards her destination, close to the last setting rays of the sun. - I suppose the description of the 'topgallant' and 'bowsprit' mean more to those who are ship savvy, I'd leave those in, they make a very clear description.
CL
Thanks guys!
CL - Cheers! I'll like you to lok out for the rest of this and my novel 'cos I know you like this sort of thing and you read Hornblower so you can lend a critical eye. Tell me if it's actually enjoyable or not!
Sam - You said "It sounded like you were trying to show off how much you knew about the different official names of parts of the ship... I don't know. Maybe if I read it a few times it'll sound better to me." Hehe. I love the phrase "mainmast topgallant" mainly because "topgallant" is such a cool word. I could cut it out though to avoid just what you said. It does seem a bit wordy and needless. And yeh, Midshipman is a title.
Seems both of you liked the interaction between the characters, so that's a positive thing.
Well, Jack, when I read in your blog that you had a short story about ships, I just HAD to check it out. I was not disappointed. Most of the descriptions were good, and the dialogue was natural. However, I caught a few things... Hope you don't mind if I'm picky, it just means I liked the piece.
While the word "keen" makes this description slightly different, the phrase is still a bit cliche. But keep it if you want - people will know what you're talking about.
I loved this description! Very nice.
The last sentence in this paragraph was good, and I liked the imagery. However, the first sentence was too wordy to me. It sounded like you were trying to show off how much you knew about the different official names of parts of the ship... I don't know. Maybe if I read it a few times it'll sound better to me.
Good. Nice way to introduce the main character. It reminds me of Captain Jack's entrance in Pirates of the Caribbean, actually, except without the humor. Mix Pirates of the Caribbean with Master and Commander, and I think that's the effect I'm getting here.
I'm assuming "Midshipman" is a title, correct? Okay. Just making sure. Also, I had to laugh at the name "Fawcett", both because it's the name of a kitchen appliance and the centerpiece of an inside joke.
I love this interaction between Shaw and Fawcett!
Good. I like how you mention the boy's tendency to worry - that really came through to me in the intro of his character.
Like CL said, his thoughts should be italicized.
I think "Maybe it's just idle paranoia" should be italicized as well. Also, I just learned in my Creative Writing class that the actions of one character should be separate from the dialogue of another character. In this case, Fawcett's question should be on a new line. I was a bit confused until I read back and realized the boy was speaking there.
Robert smiled. “No, David, I’m fine.”
I absolutely love this ending! The first paragraph there is soothing, and then it begins to erupt into chaos. I think my favorite line is the one starting with "Robert's telescope". Very nice. And the last line sums it up perfectly.
This was a really good piece, Jack, and I enjoyed reading it. If your novel is anything like this short story, you can expect many more critiques from me! Whether I have time or not, I love this subject and I'll MAKE time to read it!
Lovely description Jack, you've got my attention.
Loved those lines... using dialogue to develop relationships between characters, which I am so abyssmal at.
The only thing I caught was this Shouldn't the 'Maybe it's nothing' be italicized? - since it is his thoughts.
Nice cliffhanger as well. I'll be watching for updates on this, and for your new novel.
Ta, CL