Young Writers Society

So, I'm sorry but I didn't particularly like this comic that much. I chuckled a bit though, which is one thing I always look for in a book. I can tell that you're a beginner, so I am encouraging you to stick with the app you got and improve your skills. However, I think the story line could've used a little more thought. I didn't really understand what was going on.

Also, I don't really think your comic really fits in with everything else on YWS. Of course I'm kind of new here, but I have been here long enough to understand what this place kind of stands for. I think it would be great if you posted your works on other websites so it wouldn't be so out of place. If that makes any sense at all.

I hope you keep on making comics though!

Hey there Eros.

I don't think this was the right fit for YWS or at least not the right fit for a publishing center work. There's very little about this that I would consider to be a literary work because there's almost no dialogue and then the artwork isn't really your own either. You might have picked the backgrounds and the body, but it's not your own drawings, so maybe give more credit to the program.

This would work much better as an art thread if you chose to continue working on it, which I'm sort of assuming you're going to do. I think you should consider a continuation on this because at the moment, there's not much going on. You have some dialogue in the very beginning but by the very end, it's just one stick figure and we don't have any further details about the character's actions. Comic strips function on having some sort of tag around an action. That doesn't exist here and neither does my interest.

One of the few lines of dialogue contains swearing so you are going to have to bump the rating on this to a 16+. More dialogue would be rather easy and even though I've already recommended it before, I'm just going to keep recommending it to you. I'm still not sure what's going on with your plot line, if it can really even be called that.

Go back.
Do some editing and put in some actual work.
Then try your project in a different forum on YWS.

Any questions? Just ask.
- Lizz

I loved this comic! So creative. Dialogues were awesome. Especially, PIG'S SHIT?! LOL.

ANd the twist you give where another pig appears. I liked this very much. So, its comics too for Eros. Keep it up!

Thanks for sharing your work. Looking forward to more of your works