z
  • Home

Young Writers Society



​Picturesque

by fatherfig


My mind is the

perfect tapestry for an orchard or a farm

inside a sunlit meadow

neatly trimmed hedges

that shape around a tiny little log cabin worlds away

overlapping shingles and goldplated doorknobs

evergreen pines for tea and perineal flowers

heaped leaves from the autumn before in the backdrop

relative paradise unparalleled

the perfect place

to write my story


Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
146 Reviews

Points: 2489
Reviews: 146

Donate
Fri Sep 04, 2020 6:33 pm
View Likes
looseleaf wrote a review...



**My Thoughts**

Hey Gem, LZ here with a review! I liked this one a lot. It was a bit hard to read, but I think it was wonderful none the less.

**Grammar, Capitalization, Punctuation, You Know The Drill**

OK! This poem was great. I see you made some corrections based on the past reviews, so I'm pretty sure that there's nothing wrong with your spelling and grammar.

Mage covered this before, but it sort of seemed rushed and that you didn't read over it? Sorry if I'm wrong. The beginning is broken up weirdly; it goes short line, long line, more short lines. Maybe you could break the longer lines in half. It would make the poem look longer, but it would be neater and (in my opinion) easier to read.

I think maybe a bit of punctuation would help you as well. Some commas (maybe not periods, except at the end) would definitely make it look neater and read better.

**Just Stuff (Don't Know What To Call This)**

I really like how you compare your mind to a little, cozy cottage. My mind is always running, and could be compared to a factory or something else that's busy and working, but I wish I could be compare my mind to a cottage! I also love the detail you put into it, like "goldplated doorknobs" and "neatly trimmed hedges."

**The End**

Overall, I liked this poem a lot! It was (relatively) short and sweet, but also had a ton of detail. I think you can work a bit on making it easier to read, but other than that, this is a really good poem! I will definitely be reviewing more of your poems as Review Month progresses. Have a great day, Gem, and keep on writing! Now, enjoy this banner from @whatchamacallit!Image




fatherfig says...


Thank you! Lovely banner by the way!



User avatar
590 Reviews

Points: 1234
Reviews: 590

Donate
Tue Sep 01, 2020 5:51 pm
View Likes
Mageheart wrote a review...



Hey there, Gem! I'm not sure if I've ever read your poems before, so I thought #RevMo would be the perfect time to start.

I'm actually sitting outside as I write this review, so I'm definitely a fan of the nature imagery you invoke throughout this poem. I love the suggestion that your mind is like a natural wonderland. It makes writing feel cozy, rather than a chore or an impulse. I'd definitely take a break there to do some writing!

My first thought when I was reading your poem was how you broke apart each stanza. Each stanza perfectly captures a specific aspect of your mind, but the abrupt endings can accidentally come across as jarring in the process. It's an issue that I always have with my own poems, so I couldn't help but notice it. :P

The best way to see if that would be a problem is to read through your poem and pause at the end of each line. If it feels awkward and you just want to get to the next line, chances are you need to change how the phrases are split apart! Here's an example of how you can change the first few stanzas so they flow better:

My mind is the perfect tapestry
for an orchard or a farm,
inside a sunlit meadow
neatly trimmed hedges


(If the lines ever get too long after you rework them, you can always switch to centering the poem instead of aligning it to the left side of the screen - it's a good way to make longer stanzas seem natural!)

If you want to make this poem even better than it already is, you can try incorporating other senses into your description of the meadow. My creative writing teacher always had us include all five senses in our poems. I'm not sure that always works - taste is especially hard to throw into some poems - but I think that some extra senses might be a good way to ground the reader into your mind.

For example, instead of just describing the meadow as sunlit, you can describe the warmth of the sunlight that hits the meadow. If it's an orchard for a specific kind of fruit, you can mention the smell of the flowers. There's a lot of fun ways you can explore your setting, so don't be afraid to go for it!

I hope my review makes sense! Let me know if you have any questions about it - I'd be happy to clarify anything you need more of an explanation on. :)

Image




fatherfig says...


THank you!



Mageheart says...


You're welcome! :)



User avatar
278 Reviews

Points: 18564
Reviews: 278

Donate
Tue Sep 01, 2020 4:07 pm
View Likes
LittleLee wrote a review...



Hey, Gem, it's great to see you've had a great rush of poetic inspiration! Lots of stuff in the Green Room, hehe. Let's get this one out.

I recall you telling me once or twice before to fire away all my criticisms, so here I go.

The lack of punctuation makes the poem slightly dreamy, granted, but I'd like to point out that this poem is technically one very long sentence.

My mind is the

perfect tapestry for an orchard or a farm

inside a sunlit meadow

neatly trimmed hedges

I'm assuming the third and fourth lines in this excerpt carry on a different train of thought. If this is the case, there should preferably be a fullstop after "farm." If not, then this is grammatically incorrect, because the fourth line is completely disconnected.

neatly trimmed hedges

that shape around a tiny little log cabin worlds away

I'm not a grammatical genius, but I think if you say add "that" to a subject (in this case, the hedges) with the intention of describing something about it, it also needs an action afterwards. So, this sentence could be "Neatly trimmed hedges that shape around a tiny little log cabin worlds away stand in vermilion rows," or something like that. I hope you understand what I mean, I get confused reading some bits of my own reviews at times.

overlapping shingle....

I think you're describing the cabin here, so can we begin this sentence with a "with?" xD

You misspelled perennial as perineal.

That's all I have to say with criticises your poem.

Let me spew my thoughts now.

My English teacher once made the whole class write about their perfect imaginary "bridges" to whatever we wanted. These bridges were our mental spaces, spaces were we imagined everything we liked. Mine was a long winding path that led to a deep well with a house in it or something, but I feel like this picturesque little cottage could be one of your bridges. That said, you've done a lovely job describing the little sights you see. It seems like a partly reflective, partly descriptive poem, which makes it all the better.

But jeez, I'd love to write in a place like that.

- Lee out.




fatherfig says...


Thanks Lee. <3



User avatar
91 Reviews

Points: 0
Reviews: 91

Donate
Tue Sep 01, 2020 9:15 am
View Likes
MoonIris wrote a review...



Hi LadyGemstone,
it's me again with another review. :) This poem made me feel very calm and from the description, I felt like a little part of me traveled into the poem. I also think that the first two lines are a beautiful way to describe your imagination.
I didn't found any grammar mistakes but I'd like to remind you about punctuation again.

This is a lovely poem and I don't have a lot to say about it. I hope my review helped you and didn't offend you in any way,
MoonIris.




fatherfig says...


Thank you




Moo.
— Cow