z
  • Home

Young Writers Society


E - Everyone

Earth and Space

by illy7896


Curse the skies above

For do they make my heart throb

And all the rivers and grass and mountains

And dewdrops so sweet

For do they make me cry

OnĀ  the eve of creative dreams

Does the choir of birds

Make me ache

And the perched branches and trees

Envious of the heavens

But do they make me smile

And grow my lips

To be sweet with sugary songs of love

Make me walk the extra mileĀ 

Just to see the stars


Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
465 Reviews

Points: 29825
Reviews: 465

Donate
Mon Feb 08, 2021 12:19 am
starlitmind wrote a review...



HELLO THERE! <3 I am obsessed with celestial imagery, so your title prompted me to check this out! c: and welcome to YWS! I hope you have a lovely time here :)

I love all of the images this piece mentions. Dewdrops and skies and rivers and grass and mountains - I am seeing so much green and blue in my mind, and it all of the little things you mention brings quite a lovely image into my mind. I interpreted this as a sort of tribute to nature - the speaker is reflecting on all of the parts about nature that makes them smile and overwhelms them with emotion. And I love your ending line -> nature is so beautiful that the speaker would be willing to walk even farther just to see the beauty. All in all, I super enjoyed this piece and the different images you brought to mind! ^_^ It's simple and lovely

I am going to go a bit deeper into two aspects of your poem that I'd love to touch on <3 But anything I have to say about this poem are just suggestions - you don't have to listen to any of what I say if you don't agree! c:

Word Choice and Language

I love all of the different words you use to describe the emotions nature makes you feel! I especially love the word "ache" -> something about that word brings such a bittersweet image into my mind. Especially since you're talking about beautiful aspects of nature and that still makes your hurt. I just think that was a great word choice there :)

To be sweet with sugary songs of love


I love that alliteration! Again, we have such a soft and sweet image, and it's contrasted with words like "cry," "throb," and "ache." I love how the two things are almost fighting each other, but I think it works pretty well in your poem.

On the eve of creative dreams


This is also a line that stood out to me! I love the idea of being right on the edge of "creative dreams." You could've used the more common "on the verge of..." but instead you used eve, and I think that was a lovely choice c:

Imagery

One thing I would've loved to see more of is imagery! Since this is a poem about nature after all, weaving in some more descriptions and vivd imagery would make this even lovelier for the reader to picture in their mind c: I'll point out a couple of spots you could expand on (if you so wish to do so) and then you can find some more spots that would work well with any ideas you have! But you don't have to do anything at all if you don't want to c:

Curse the skies above


What kind of skies? Are we talking about day or night here? Stormy? Calm? What colour blue are they? Cloudy? Does the sky look smooth like ripples in the water?

And all the rivers and grass and mountains


I feel like this line has so much potential! ^^ What about the grass makes you cry? The way it whispers softly in the wind? You could even tie each image together - perhaps you could talk about how the rivers carve lines into mountain sides

And the perched branches and trees


Ooh, what tree? A big, grand oak tree? Cherry blossom tree? Specificity can be awesome in poetry, and I recommend for you to utilize it here! ^_^

Random Stuff

I do agree with Elinor about your title being a bit misleading - I imagined this was going to focus more on outer space, but I got a grassy feel out of this, if that makes sense cx I think a quick fix to change this would be focusing your title more on what you talk about in the poem! It can be a specific image, like dewdrops, or it could be a general line about nature!

I noticed you didn't use any punctuation throughout this - punctuation is a totally stylistic choice, so I'm not going to comment on that. I was just wondering, have you considered putting a period at the end of the poem? You totally don't have to, but it might give the reader a sense of finality. Just a thought for you to consider~

And that's it! Like I said, I really enjoyed reading this piece. I think your word choice was quite lovely, and I enjoyed the different images this poem brought to mind. I hope to read more from you soon, and I hope this helped! <3




illy7896 says...


Thank you so much for the review :)



User avatar
78 Reviews

Points: 18
Reviews: 78

Donate
Sun Feb 07, 2021 10:24 pm
Buranko wrote a review...



Hi there illy, I am Buranko, here to give you some feedback related to your poem.

It starts in a strong way. "Curse the skies above". In greek mythology a similar remark was said by a king whose name I can't remember. The thing is that he attracted the wrath of Zeus who struck him with a lightning in a second. That is why such a statement is known as being blasphemic in a way. The person in your poem surely feels like they have nothing to lose and tries to show his/her dissatisfaction with life by cursing the divine, the skies in this case, as to relieve some pain felt.

The poem acts as a act of rebellion, a riot against nature and the divine as far as I could understand. Here, nature is presented filtered by the aching soul. That is why things like birds, songs of love, trees cause the person to feel pain. I love how you added the DO in "for DO they make my...", "for DO they make me..." alongside that inversion, it surely adds to the theme of suffering and genuine feelings.

What I disliked was how you tried to subtly change the poem into a hopeful tone. Don't get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with a hopeful ending, however you did it too sudden and it feels off. I would have changed the but from "But do they make me smile" into however, it makes it a little longer and smoother. Also that do is not really needed here along with the before mentioned inversion. I like the idea of difference between the two terms: hope and pain, that is why if you do it in a similar way as you did when presenting pain it feels off.

Of course these are my own thoughts on this poem, you don't need to change anything if you are happy with how the poem turned out. Overall great job I hope to read other works you might write. Good luck




illy7896 says...


Thank you so much for this review, I never knew that that was from Greek mythology, and I'm really pleased to have (accidentally) referenced this.
I'll try and edit my poem, thank you :)



Buranko says...


I'm glad to know you like my review. I was a little worried I might have been too critical and missed the point of the poem



illy7896 says...


Not at all, all feedback is beneficial :)



User avatar
1260 Reviews

Points: 1630
Reviews: 1260

Donate
Sun Feb 07, 2021 5:51 pm
Elinor wrote a review...



Hey illy7896!

My name is Elinor, and I thought I would drop by to give your poem a quick review. Also, I wanted to welcome you to YWS! I see you've only been here a few days and done eight reviews already, which is awesome!

I really enjoyed reading this poem. To be honest though, I found your description of it a little misleading -- I thought it would make me think of space and the night sky, though what I actually pictured when reading it is standing in a field in the day time, especially because of the reference of birds. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, but if you want this poem to be about the night sky and space, I would do more to paint that picture. Maybe "does the choir of birds" becomes "does the the choir of crickets"? Just an idea. But if being out in the daytime makes you dream of space, that is great too, but I would do more to convey that here.

Like I said, I loved the reading the poem, and think you do a good job of painting a picture, I think any edits just depend on what your goal with this poem is. Don't hesitate to reach out if you have any questions or want me to clarify any of my notes!

Happy writing!

Cheers,
Elinor




illy7896 says...


Thank you so much, I agree. I was trying to get the general feel that nature has over you, including space with all elements of life, but maybe I could do two sections: one with day and night. Thank you so much for your review



User avatar
701 Reviews

Points: 49988
Reviews: 701

Donate
Sun Feb 07, 2021 3:52 pm
ForeverYoung299 wrote a review...



to be honest, i didn't understand the meaning of the first two lines. can you please make me understand those lines? i would be thankful if you do so. rest of all it's a thought provoking poem. your good relation with the nature is straight forward and apprehensible in this poem.
the rivers, the grass, the mountains, dewdrops, birds, branches of trees, stars- all the elements of nature and also the earth are put up in this poem. i also like the comparisons you made between all these and you- what you think of them.

overall, it's a very good poem. i have a few doubts which i specified earlier. i think i would be able to interpret the meaning better if you tell the meanings of those two lines- " why do the sky make your heart throb?". except that, it's flawless and cool.

i hope this review will help you. can you please review the chapters of my novel? i like to give and receive feedbacks and reviews.
thank you!




illy7896 says...


Awesome I totally will, could you please give me the name of it. The first two lines are meant to describe the emptiness of space and birds and clouds and how much they make me ache to be part of that freedom. Sorry if I didn't make it very clear, but now I can definitely improve on my writing, so thank you for that. I'm really glad you enjoyed the poem :)



illy7896 says...


I know the chapters that you mean, I'll review them now



ForeverYoung299 says...


thanks. hope you will review. and now i understand the first two lines.




The beginning of wisdom is to call things by their right names.
— Chinese proverb