Just keep on
pressing "enter"
while you...
type some words.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
That was cool!
Haha thanks.
'Ello, it's Cello! Here for a review.
I'd like to start to say I appreciate satire poems. If you check my portfolio, my earlier works were nothing but satire. I even had a few things similar to this that poked fun at different types of writing. However, this work brought me little entertainment.
With all honesty, I've seen this joke in many places online before. I'll admit that I've fallen in the trap of overused humor while writing before but I learned from it and I hope to help you do the same.
Now, let's push aside my problem with the concept of this work and let's move on to pretending I fell in love with it and am simply here to help you improve.
This poem was broken into four lines. It is clearly a work meant for two. With the style you've formatted this in, the reader reads in a choppy fashion that in no way supports your thesis that hitting enter makes a poem. What do all poems have in common? Flow. They can rhyme, they can be free verse, they can be satire or serious, but they all have some sort of flow.
This did not.
For this to read slowly in a readers mind you'd have to write
"Just keep
onpressing "enter"while you
...type some words."Clearly, this does not have the 'poem look' you're going for. If you want to improve this, you'll need more content. Like I've said, I've seen jokes like this before and with all honesty they've worked just fine. They have a fair amount of content and I found myself reading the work like a poem. Take this for example-
"If you keep hitting enter
as you type
your writing sounds like poetry"
I saw this (or something very similar to this) on tumblr. The lines have more length and not just 'adding words to lengthen it'-length but content filled length. This gives the writing support and balances the feel of the words.
If you noticed earlier, I took the 'on' out of the poem. Although (to the best of my knowledge) 'keep on' is proper english, it's only used in very casual situations. Free verse poetry (Which you seem to be trying to imitate) it not for casual use. This type of writing tends to be filled with meaning and story. 'Keep on' is not something you'd expect to see.
I also removed the ellipsis. I really hate ellipsis' (is that the plural?). They're over used and repeatedly used improperly. Trailing off? Ellipsis! Taking words out of a quote? Ellipsis! Anything else? Probably not. (It all depends on the situation but I've never seen it used properly apart from the example I gave) You use an ellipsis to indicate that there's text or dialogue that's missing. You do not have this here so you do not need an ellipsis and besides, it slows the reader down even more.
I really hope you took a lot from this review and I encourage you to keep writing.
-ChocolateCello
Haha! I can relate to this, I have read a few poems where it seemed like the writer had just taken a description from their book, pressed enter every few words, and then published. It seems like that is what free verse poetry has become.
Hey there Keepwriting. It's just lizzy dropping by real quick, so without a further ado, let the reviewing begin.
Ahh. An extremely short poem, you can just love 'em, hate 'em, or both emotions at the same time. On the upside, the line by line analysis is easier but the meanings are more cryptic. Though from the title and description your meaning is pretty straight forward.
I have seen a couple of poems like this on YWS since I got here. Most of them were very long and filled with very vivid descriptions. I usually prefer when poems are filled with color but this time was different. The simpleness of the lines and description of a situation/possible thing was better in getting the point across.
I like how the question was posed. To me it sounded sarcastic but you may not have meant it that way. Considering this was filed under humor, I'm guessing it was meant to be sarcastic.
My last poem, though I thought the meaning was straight forward, was evidently not. I assumed that when a gun goes off in a Cold War setting and a scientist is talking to a spy, my meaning would be clear. Next time, I shouldn't assume anything. The way this was written though no assumption about the audience needed to be done. I should probably get back to my actual review which is coming up in the next paragraph, so stay tuned.
It's just easier to put the entire poem in a quote than to separate it out into four quotes. Just stay with me for a little bit longer and this review will soon be over.
The seems to be rolling really slow and drawn out, as if someone is saying this to another person. They are explaining it as a joke but they are being very careful to make it look serious. Was that the feel you were going for? If not, what was the intended reaction emotion? I'm still trying to decide if the ending on the third line felt right. I guess it needed more of a pause than the other lines right. The ending was great because it was so simple and easy to see.
Well, that's about all I have for this review. Sorry if I couldn't offer anything more than a couple of comments. Yes, this was mostly praise and weird relations from my own writing career but there wasn't that much to find in the piece.
Have a nice day.
Lizzy
Queen of the Book Clubs
All sarcastic. Thanks for the review.
Don't forget to click the "like" button if you liked it of course.Hi! Sarah12 here to review. Or try to review, as it is so short.
This is very accurate, and it did hit the humorous side of me, although not very hard. I saw two things that could be changed, however.
1. In the title, "A" should not be capitalized. It should look like this: "To Write a Poem".
2. I'm not sure you need the ellipsis in the third line. I understand what you were trying to do with it, but it doesn't quite work. I'm going to keep thinking on that because I feel like something else would be better on that line there, or it could be rephrased somehow that would make it more effective, but I simply cannot think of it right now. I will comment it when I think of it.
Also, since the poem seems to be all one "sentence", you don't need to capitalize the beginning of any of the lines besides the first. That is personal choice, but I think it would be better if you didn't.
Congratulations on a very accurate poem, and, well, live up to your username and keep writing!
Sarah12
Thanks, yeah I'll change it. If you liked it don't forget to click the "like" button.
Hello Keepwriting!
Right. Hi. So, as I mentioned above you clarified HOW to write A poem. However, my humble opinion in certain types of poetry is that the words come from somewhere. In this piece, you make the idea sound so simple, which perhaps it is, in some cases. But I do not believe the method described above is accurate for many of the poems that I write. Again, this is simply my opinion.
First of all, I want to thank you, because this poem literally made me burst out laughing. Well done. As far as criticism goes, there isn't much I can say based from these 4 lines, but I will do my best to give you a decent review.
First of all, I would like to mention that this poem is incredibly accurate, for the title it was given. To define how to write a poem, you need to look at the definition of a poem. And, by definition, your "method" works to simply WRITE a poem. What I'm about to say will likely be completely opinionated, and you do not have to even acknowledge it (thus the spoiler). The choice is yours.
Spoiler
Back to this:
For a humorous poem, this certainly achieved its goal and I commend you on this piece. Very well written. Typically when I close reviews, I say "keep writing", but in your case I believe that would be redundant (based on your username).
I hope to read more from you soon,
Sis
Hahaha thanks. I was making fun of free-verse poems.
Okay good to know! Thanks for clarifying