Hello, dogsrule! Adrian back here for another review!
"Now soldiers. Listen up" Chief said sounding angry. "The war is almost over, but I do expect you to still be on my team. Understand?"
The whole first scene seems like it's... for Capture the Flag or something like that. While I guess the soldiers do have a choice if the want to help the enemy or not, it doesn't seem all that necessary to say that in a speech. It's the last day. Yes, they could decide to help out the enemy-- but it doesn't seem all that likely. Also, why do they only have to kill twenty men to win? It sorta seems like a video game, when you have a kill goal. Unless that's how many men are on the German side-- but that doesn't seem that likely either. I think to end a war, there needs to be a treaty?
So, there's the end of the war-- and it's just skipped? No details at all? No recounts of the losses, or small scenes? That would have been really fun to read, thought it would have taken quite some research to write. So I do understand why it is not there.
...they chief calls her and isn't aware of her pregnancy? That doesn't seem all that realistic to me. Like Cricket said, would she be on a "do not contact her, she is not fit to fight" list or something at least. Also, I thought the war was over! Why is she being called back to the war once it has ended? Unless there is another one going on. Even if there was another one going on, it should be noted at least. That's very important information that needs to be acknowledged. (Additionally, if the war wasn't actually won, it would be nice to know.)
...saying that Stacy was gone.
I'm assuming in this sense of "gone" that means she died. Which is sad. However, her death was very sudden and there was no build up to it at all. No warning, no foreshadowing. One moment she has a baby, and it very weak, the next she is dead. It was also a very brief death. Only mentioned in the passing. There wasn't really anything for it. Although, I am sad that she is dead. She's the main character.
She had to be 14 or so to actually understand the war, and her mother's death? She literally grew up without a mother, and was told how Stacy died in the eighth grade. I'm sorry, but that seems just a bit too long to wait.
With the end of this chapter, I'm not sure if it's a beginning to another story, or if the story has ended. Anyways, I did enjoy this chapter and I hope that you keep on writing this story! (Or just stories in general if this is the last chapter.)
~Adrian
Points: 0
Reviews: 324
Donate