z

Young Writers Society


12+

The Battle. Prolouge

by dogsrule5


This battle started 5 years ago and ended just today. The battle was sad. My own father died, and I was sad, because when I was a little girl my mom died. My dad put me in a boarding school. There were so many rules but I couldn't keep track of all of them. I was a day-dreamer. I day-dreamed about my dad coming to get me after the war. But when my teacher said my dad died just a few days ago in battle, I cried for the three days after. I couldn't believe my dad died. This is the third boarding school I have been into, because my dad was always in battle, until now. He is not in battle anymore and never will be, because of his death.

A few years later my dad's sister (my aunt) came to pick me up from the boarding school, but my teacher wouldn't let me go with my aunt. I told her that she could give me an education because she is a school teacher. She finally said yes. My aunt was coming back tomorrow to take me with her, so I was packing. While I was going through my stuff and putting it in my suitcase, I found my picture of my dad, the picture that he gave me before he went to the first battle.

I finished packing and went downstairs to dinner. I was starving. After dinner I took a shower and got ready for bed. I read a little bit of my book, and went to sleep.

The next morning my aunt came back, and I got my suitcase form my room, and put it in the car. My aunt told me I was going to have a good time at her house. I was in the ninth grade, and I would have my aunt as my teacher. I already knew who my teacher was. Witch I thought was good. The only thing I didn't know was what the other kids were like at school. I was a little nervous to go to school, but when I got there, my aunt introduced me to everyone. I met a friend named Alex. She was really nice. We hung out at lunch and we were partners in the partner activity.

School was finally over, but I kind of liked meeting a new friend. I told my aunt all about Alex forgetting she already knew her quite well.

I still missed my dad, I stared at the picture he gave me for a long time. I went to sleep hugging the picture. I felt as if my dad was there, even though I knew he wasn't.


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
4096 Reviews


Points: 253363
Reviews: 4096

Donate
Wed Jul 07, 2021 10:53 am
KateHardy wrote a review...



Good Morning/Afternoon/Evening/Night(whichever one it is in your part of the world),

Hi! I'm ran into the first chapter of this story while trawling around the ancient works of YWS...and thought I'd check out the prologue too...so here I am.

First Impression: Okay...as far as prologues go, this one's not too bad, but having read the first chapter, I wonder how this is going to actually play into the story itself though...cause it seems like the story takes place a lot after this. At any rate, if this is just meant to be a bit of context for the backstory of the protagonist...that's not bad either...but uhh...this pacing would still need to get sorted out a bit here.

Anyway let's get right to it,

This battle started 5 years ago and ended just today. The battle was sad. My own father died, and I was sad, because when I was a little girl my mom died. My dad put me in a boarding school. There were so many rules but I couldn't keep track of all of them. I was a day-dreamer. I day-dreamed about my dad coming to get me after the war. But when my teacher said my dad died just a few days ago in battle, I cried for the three days after. I couldn't believe my dad died. This is the third boarding school I have been into, because my dad was always in battle, until now. He is not in battle anymore and never will be, because of his death.


Okay....well, this one definitely is quite an attention grabby start here...a child having to suffer the consequences of having a father that's constantly in a war...and then also having to suffer through losing said father to the war. Adding the death of the mother to that equation definitely makes things even worse. At any rate, this is setting up a pretty sad premise here right off the bat...and you can instantly empathize with the protagonist here.

A few years later my dad's sister (my aunt) came to pick me up from the boarding school, but my teacher wouldn't let me go with my aunt. I told her that she could give me an education because she is a school teacher. She finally said yes. My aunt was coming back tomorrow to take me with her, so I was packing. While I was going through my stuff and putting it in my suitcase, I found my picture of my dad, the picture that he gave me before he went to the first battle.


Okay...looks like perhaps we've skipped to things happening in real time finally...at least it appears so here...and well, it looks like an interesting move their with the teacher refusing to let her go...considering the aunt is probably one of her only living relatives, if the aunt asks, I don't know if the teacher can even think of refusing there...that nitpick aside, a neat little start here. And that mention of her finding a picture of her father while packing up definitely is one of those things that tug at your heartstrings there.

The next morning my aunt came back, and I got my suitcase form my room, and put it in the car. My aunt told me I was going to have a good time at her house. I was in the ninth grade, and I would have my aunt as my teacher. I already knew who my teacher was. Witch I thought was good. The only thing I didn't know was what the other kids were like at school. I was a little nervous to go to school, but when I got there, my aunt introduced me to everyone. I met a friend named Alex. She was really nice. We hung out at lunch and we were partners in the partner activity.


Okayy....things kinda sped up there again, the pacing of this prologue has so far been a touch all over the place, it kind of slowed down to talk about that packing scene and the aunt but now it speeds up a whole lot more here, which makes for a transition that's a tiny bit too fast in my opinion, you may want to rethink that bit a little.

School was finally over, but I kind of liked meeting a new friend. I told my aunt all about Alex forgetting she already knew her quite well.

I still missed my dad, I stared at the picture he gave me for a long time. I went to sleep hugging the picture. I felt as if my dad was there, even though I knew he wasn't.


Okay...so this again seems to be slowing the pace down to just a single moment here at the end, which kind of seals the full circle on this pacing that keeps speeding up and down. Well, at the very least, this doesn't seem to be too bad of a prologue...although I am wondering how this ties into the story...having read the first chapter, it seems like this would be a something that happens way before the first chapter...

Aaaaand that's it for this one.

Overall: Overall, a pretty decent prologue, its got a couple of issues here and there but for the most part its not too bad. Seems like a pretty interesting story this one...and ehh...I just might read the rest of these chapters cause it looks like you did in fact finish this particular story. :D

As always remember to take what you think was helpful and forget the rest.

Stay Safe
Harry




dogsrule5 says...


Hello! I appreciate the review and am aware there are probably many errors to through this whole story! Just a disclaimer I wrote this story about 7 years ago, so I was very young, (I was about 12) and I never went back through and edited it! Read on if you wish and keep reviewing as well, (it%u2019s good points) but I probably won%u2019t be looking back on this story in the future to edit. It was just a small book I wrote, and it%u2019s honestly not one of my personal favorites of the ones I%u2019ve written. But again, thank you so much for the review it%u2019s always good to get feedback :D



dogsrule5 says...


Hello! I appreciate the review and am aware there are probably many errors to through this whole story! Just a disclaimer I wrote this story about 7 years ago, so I was very young, (I was about 12) and I never went back through and edited it! Read on if you wish and keep reviewing as well, (it's good points) but I probably won't be looking back on this story in the future to edit. It was just a small book I wrote, and it's honestly not one of my personal favorites of the ones I've written. But again, thank you so much for the review it's always good to get feedback :D



KateHardy says...


You're Welcome!! And thanks for the reply, I really wasn't expecting one on this review. :D



dogsrule5 says...


No problem! :D



KateHardy says...


:D



User avatar
232 Reviews


Points: 5846
Reviews: 232

Donate
Wed Jun 11, 2014 9:44 pm
WillowPaw1 wrote a review...



Hi, dogs! Yay, new story! :)

First of all, I recommend you edit the nitpicks others have pointed out for you, since they went to all of that work. I'm not trying to sound rude or anything but yeah. :3


This battle started 5 years ago and ended just today.


Personally I think you should change the 5 to five. ;)

I was a day-dreamer. I day-dreamed about my dad coming to get me after the war.


Yes!!!! Yes!! In like the fourth sentence, we already know somethin about her! Great job! However, I would recommend building up on this character. How does she act? Is she shy, or hyper? Of course, this is only the prologue, but try and get in all the information!

The next morning my aunt came back, and I got my suitcase form my room, and put it in the car.


*from my room. Just a little mix-up with letters.

We hung out at lunch and we were partners in the partner activity.


This was pretty brief. What was the partner activity?

I told my aunt all about Alex forgetting she already knew her quite well.


This is just a suggestion, but maybe you could change it to: I told my aunt all about Alex, forgetting the fact that she already knew her quite well.

I still missed my dad, I stared at the picture he gave me for a long time. I went to sleep hugging the picture. I felt as if my dad was there, even though I knew he wasn't.


Perfect ending ! Bravo! *claps* I really liked the sadness and heart-brokenness in this last small paragraph.

All right, now I'm ganna talk about the story.
The formatting is much better than Lost Magic! The no use of asterisks is great, and you split up the paragraphs nicely. ;)

I said it briefly above, but I'll make it longer and stretch the topic out more. I really think you should expand on her personality. Like, maybe when she was hanging out with Alex, try could have talked about what they like to do and their hobbies. I just want to have this MC be strong and developed nicely, with weaknesses and strengths.

Overall, I think this was a great start to this new story! I'm off to review the next chapters! :)

~WillowPaw1




User avatar
12 Reviews


Points: 456
Reviews: 12

Donate
Wed Jun 11, 2014 7:46 pm
jojoann1 wrote a review...



Hi!

This is an amazing start of this book. It made me feel very sad when I started reading. I found a mistake where it says:

Witch I thought was good.

The "Witch" is supposed to be "Which".

Other than this mistake, I thought this book is going to be a good one. I kept wanting to read more and I can't wait to read chapter 1.

Keep up the good work!

Love,
Jojoann1




User avatar
324 Reviews


Points: 0
Reviews: 324

Donate
Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:53 pm
View Likes
Evander wrote a review...



Hi!

Raven here for a review!

As I say almost every review, you need to show not tell. I will go into that in the latter part of this review.

Hm... Second paragraph you say:

A few years later my dad's sister (my aunt) came to pick me up from the boarding school, but my teacher wouldn't let me go with my aunt. I told her that she could give me an education because she is a school teacher. She finally said yes.

If the aunt has custody of the your MC (Main Character), the teacher should not be able to refuse the aunt taking the child. Now, if the aunt did not have custody, the teacher could refuse. I am also wondering why a teacher of all people is forbidding that. It would make a little more sense if the headmaster/principle was doing that.

I still missed my dad, I stared at the picture he gave me for a long time. I went to sleep hugging the picture. I felt as if my dad was there, even though I knew he wasn't.

That was a perfect opportunity to describe that! Throw in something about the picture!

Witch I thought was good.

I believe you mean "which". Don't worry, I made mistakes like that all the time.

I met a friend named Alex. She was really nice. We hung out at lunch and we were partners in the partner activity.

You could have described Alex's appearance!

Now, I said earlier I would talk about describing stuff...

If you say your character was shocked, maybe describe how you see them at that point in time. "I was shocked. One of my eyebrows was up, and the other down. My mouth was agape."
Or,
"Tears were streaming down my face. I couldn't believe it. I wouldn't believe it. He was dead. My hands were trembling, I could barely hold the paper in my hands."
See?

Keep on typing!

Raven,




dogsrule5 says...


It is going to get better chapter1 is the same but i am going to do better at chapter2



Evander says...


Tell me when you post the next chapter!



dogsrule5 says...


Okay i will.



User avatar
401 Reviews


Points: 1658
Reviews: 401

Donate
Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:41 pm
View Likes
ThereseCricket wrote a review...



Hey there! Cricket here for a quick review!!!

Ohhh, I'm just in time for the start of the second book of a series!! :D How cool is that?!!! Gahhh, I'm going to have to go take a look at some of your other chapters! :D I'm just a sucker for series...anyway..on towards my review for you. Now if I get something wrong in terms of plot and such just please ignore it. OK? :P

Oh, and please ignore anything that I say that previous reviewers have already said. Alright?

NITPICKS!!!!

The battle was sad. My own father died, and I was sad,


OK, now in these two lines it seems kinda repetitive. You use "sad" twice. Also I wouldn't just say it directly out. Usually when somebody's father dies, they are sad. So the reader usually (Usually!) picks up that the character is sad if you describe the emotions and the like. OK? :D Hope I made this clear enough.

This battle started 5 years ago and ended just today. The battle was sad. My own father died, and I was sad, because when I was a little girl my mom died. My dad put me in a boarding school. There were so many rules but I couldn't keep track of all of them. I was a day-dreamer. I day-dreamed about my dad coming to get me after the war. But when my teacher said my dad died just a few days ago in battle, I cried for the three days after. I couldn't believe my dad died. This is the third boarding school I have been into, because my dad was always in battle, until now. He is not in battle anymore and never will be, because of his death.


Gahhh, sorry to cut out so much, but I just had a slight concern with this paragraph. Now in writing, one of the worst traps we writers fall into is telling too much back story. When telling a story the reader always wants you to being moving on. To be progressing. This kinda felt like an info dump to me. You have to really careful to not do that. The reader will get SO bored with that. They always want the story to be pressing on, and progressing. OK? So just be careful to not do info-dumps.

The Battle. Prolouge


Sorry, but I just noticed with the title that "Prologue" is spelled wrong. That's how you spell it. :D

He is not in battle anymore and never will be, because of his death.


Now with this I just noticed that you are kinda just repeating yourself. You already told us that her father died. So try cutting out any unnecessary repetition. OK?

A few years later my dad's sister (my aunt)


Well since usually "a dad's sister" is always automatically thought of as an aunt. So I would just get rid of "(my aunt)".

Anyway I'm finished!! I think Noelle and the other one got everything else, so I won't bother you anymore. :D

KEEP WRITING!!!




User avatar
1417 Reviews


Points: 3733
Reviews: 1417

Donate
Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:28 am
View Likes
Noelle wrote a review...



Hi there!

You categorized this under 'fanfiction' so I was wondering what this a fanfiction for. Just curious.

Alright, onto the review.

The battle was sad. My own father died, and I was sad, because when I was a little girl my mom died.

So I want to talk about this part. First of all, you use the word 'sad' too often here. It would've worked if you had spread it out over a few sentences. But having it twice in back to back sentences is a bit too much. Second of all, I see a lot of telling here. Your MC is sad, I get it. Give us a little more. Has she changed at all since her father's death? Is she more aggressive? Less social? Did her grades fall because of it? This is a great opportunity for you to expand on your character.

While I was going through my stuff and putting it in my suitcase, I found my picture of my dad, the picture that he gave me before he went to the first battle.

Again, you've missed a perfect opportunity for some deep character development. I was reading through this, waiting to see your MC's reaction to finding this picture. But there is no reaction. I want to know how your MC reacts to this. Show us some deeper emotion. Really dive into your character's feelings and show us their deepest emotions. Especially since their dad just died. I feel like they would be a lot worse off than they are right now.

I went to sleep hugging the picture. I felt as if my dad was there, even though I knew he wasn't.

This is the kind of emotion I'm looking for. It's just a simple image, your MC holding the picture as they fall asleep, but it's really deep at the same time. It means a lot that your MC falls asleep with this picture. I can really see how much they miss their dad just from this one image.

My aunt was coming back tomorrow to take me with her, so I was packing.

So there's some things that are hard to write in past tense. This is a good example of something. Terms like 'yesterday' and 'tomorrow' are ones that don't work all that well. Because here, if you say "My aunt was coming tomorrow" then it's a bit of a negation. On one hand, you're saying that the aunt was coming, which implies the past. On the other hand though, you're saying that she is coming tomorrow which is used in the present tense. Make sense? Instead you'll want to say something like "My aunt was coming back the very next day so I was packing". That way you're still using past tense and the same idea is coming across to your readers.

The thing I like about this prologue is that we learn a lot. There isn't much that I'm left wondering about. I know where your MC is and I know what they are doing there. I also know what's going on with their family. It's really sad in all honesty. Here their mother is already dead and their father just died. That's a lot of tragedy that goes on in a few short years.

Although I know what's going on plot and chronological wise, I don't know much about your MC. Are they a girl or a boy? What do they look like? Are they wearing their favorite dress? Their favorite pair of blue jeans? It's always important to describe your characters. You know that I'm sure. But it's worth talking about. I know it's hard to do when you're writing in first person POV. That's one of the disadvantages of writing in first person, you can only describe so much. I mean, your MC is the narrator. They don't go around looking at themselves every day. You know what I'm saying? We see everything through their eyes. But you still should sneak in a spot somewhere to describe what your MC looks like. This can also be done in the first chapter I suppose, but the sooner you do it the better.

This prologue seems to span over a good period of time. I suggest slowing it down a bit. I'd love to see a scene or two of how your MC deals at school. You mention Alex. How did the two of them meet? That would've been a great scene to write out. Even though a prologue should be kinda short and to the point, a short scene of any kind would be good here. Just something to pull us into the story even more.

Overall I think you could've given us some more insight into your MC. Don't get me wrong, this is a good prologue. But it could be a tad better if you added description. Again, I really liked how you gave us so much information. I'm going into the first chapter with no questions or confusion. Good job with that!

Keep writing!
**Noelle**




dogsrule5 says...


I didn't know what genoa and my mom said fanfiction



User avatar
179 Reviews


Points: 15489
Reviews: 179

Donate
Mon Jun 09, 2014 4:21 pm
r4p17 wrote a review...



Knight r4 here to review this work. I hope this helps

I have a maxim that might help you improve your writing skills. "All tell and no show makes Jack a dull boy." Yes I know what you are thinking. This is so unoriginal. But it is true.

Now I will move on to the nit-picks.

"This battle started 5 years ago and ended just today. The battle was sad." What in the world do you mean? I honestly have no idea. Is it a literal battle or a mental one. Who/what is fighting who/what. (Sorry for the repetition). This is kind of random and out of the blue.

"and I was sad, because when I was a little girl my mom died." Anyone would be sad. And you don't have to state this so flatly. You would also be sad whether your mom died as well or not.

"I read a little bit of my book, and went to sleep." What was the name of the book? What was it about. I need more description here.

"Witch I thought was good." This is just a small spelling error.

"I met a friend named Alex. She was really nice." First Alex is a boys name! Second did the narrarator know this girl before or did the narrarator just meet her. What did Alex look like? (Who is the narrarator) Is the narrarator dumb? You don't describe what is going on at all.

"we were partners in the partner activity." What happened at the activity.

"I still missed my dad, I stared at the picture he gave me for a long time." First off, this is a fused sentence. Secondly how did he get the picture? When did he recieve it.

Since your name and picture have to do with dogs I will give you an illustration about what I feel when I read your writing. Imagine there is a man who is blind and has to have a see and I dog. But his dog leaves him and he is left helpless in the middle of a field. That is pretty much what I feel without any description or dialogue.

I am confused as to why a dad would leave his daughter alone. You also need to reveal when and where this is taking place.

Overall most of this was telling what is happening or an info dump. Try to show what is happening. Once you do that you will have more dialogue and longer chapters. BTW why is this a prologue?




dogsrule5 says...


Thank you I guess. But I might as well lieave it how it is because I like it
and if you don't like it fine by me there are tons of other people who would want to read it too!



r4p17 says...


I am sorry if I was too harsh. Now that I look at my review it might have come across that way. But I am honestly trying to help.

Don't say that you should just leave it. Every good writer edits his books eventually. It's not that I don't like this but I certainly think there is room for improvement! :)



dogsrule5 says...


Thank you, but I am a girl not a boy and you said his instead of her...



puppys3117 says...


'his' is general ;) plus, boys can think dogs rule :D



dogsrule5 says...


I know. I was kind of kidding anyway, I know what he means and stuff. :)




Here's to the crazy ones. The misfits. The rebels. The troublemakers. The round pegs in the square holes. The ones who see things differently. They're not fond of rules. And they have no respect for the status quo. You can quote them, disagree with them, glorify or vilify them. About the only thing you can't do is ignore them. Because they change things. They push the human race forward. And while some may see them as the crazy ones, we see genius. Because the people who are crazy enough to think they can change the world, are the ones who do.
— -Apple Inc.