Introducing...the Checklist Challenge!

19 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 46598
Reviews 641
The March Review Day is incoming and a new challenge is on the horizon! We all know the classic drill for Review Days - teams, competitiveness, and as many quality critiques as you can crank out in the time limit. But now we beckon in something new, with the promise of prizes for those who triumph over it. May I present...

Image


What's it all about?

Aside from getting lots of great critiques done for Review Day, the Checklist Challenge is all about pushing yourself outside of your comfort zone and critiquing works that you usually shy away from. It's as much a challenge to yourself as a competition against anyone else!

Why should I take part?

To broaden your critiquing skills, to help all our wonderful authors, and for fun! Plus, if that's not enough of an incentive, I'll be offering 2000 points to the person who completes the most items from the list, 1000 points for the person who completes the second-most, and 500 points for the person who completes the third-most. I'm also offering 5 reviews to anybody who manages to complete all of the items on the list!

What are the rules?

  • The challenge will start and finish to coincide with Review Day (25th March 2018).
  • You can only tick items off the checklist by doing a review on Review Day. Old reviews can't be used to check items off.
  • A single review can be used to check off multiple items (e.g. the 11th chapter of a fantasy novel would check off three categories).
  • You can review non-Green Room works to check off items, but try to keep in the spirit of Review Day by helping authors that still need feedback!

How do I enter?

To be in with a chance of a prize, copy and paste the code (enspoilered below) into this thread. For each checklist item you completed, post a link to the review you did to check it off. If you didn't complete that item, leave the category blank.

You can do this at any time during the week following Review Day, so don't worry about putting the list together on the day!

Spoiler
Code
[b]Review of novel chapter:[/b]
[b]Review of poem:[/b]
[b]Review of short story:[/b]
[b]Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:[/b]
[b]Review of something from the teen fiction genre:[/b]
[b]Review of work published in February:[/b]
[b]Review of something from the sci-fi genre:[/b]
[b]Review of script:[/b]
[b]Review of something from the fantasy genre:[/b]
[b]Review of Green Room poem:[/b]
[b]Review of rhyming poem:[/b]
[b]Review of something from the horror genre:[/b]
[b]Review of article/essay:[/b]
[b]Review of fanfiction:[/b]
[b]Review of Green Room novel chapter:[/b]
[b]Review of something from romance genre:[/b]
[b]Review of something with zero reviews:[/b]
[b]Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:[/b]
[b]Review of work from the mystery genre:[/b]


Note: in the case of reviewing works in the Green Room and ones with zero reviews, the work must have been in the Green Room/had zero reviews at the time you published your review. If someone beats you to it, I'm afraid it can't count towards the list.

And that's about it! By all means, use this thread to ask any questions or to state your intention to take part. Go forth and take up the challenge!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5523
Reviews 51
Muwahaha! I'm getting those five reviews!... soon...

Review of novel chapter:
Review of poem:
Review of short story:
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
Review of work published in February:
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
Review of script:
Review of something from the fantasy genre:
Review of Green Room poem:
Review of rhyming poem:
Review of something from the horror genre:
Review of article/essay:
Review of fanfiction:
Review of Green Room novel chapter:
Review of something from romance genre:
Review of something with zero reviews:
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
Review of work from the mystery genre:

sorry im not sure if i can leave this here or not
"Be the butthole" - Lareine, 2018




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 11482
Reviews 351
*Cracks my knuckles* Let's do this.

Review of novel chapter: Summoning Persephone part 15
Review of poem: You Are Real
Review of short story: Our Secret Dance Part 1
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above: Summoning Persephone part 15
Review of something from the teen fiction genre: There’s So Much More To Juno Blackwood chapter 33
Review of work published in February: Sorcerer Part 1
Review of something from the sci-fi genre: Rejuvenated Light Chapter One
Review of script: Sister Brookes (TV Horror Series) Episode 1 “Angels”
Review of something from the fantasy genre: Summoning Persephone part 15
Review of Green Room poem: You Are Real
Review of rhyming poem: Washing Machine Dreams
Review of something from the horror genre: Sister Brookes (TV Horror Series) Episode 1 “Angels”
Review of article/essay: Every INDIAN 00s KID Will Relate To
Review of fanfiction: Hungry Storms
Review of Green Room novel chapter: Summoning Persephone part 15
Review of something from romance genre: Our Secret Dance Part 1
Review of something with zero reviews: Our Secret Dance Part 1
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above: There’s So Much More To Juno Blackwood chapter 33
Review of work from the mystery genre: Sorcerer Part 1

FINISHED.
Last edited by Kanome on Sun Mar 25, 2018 4:21 am, edited 11 times in total.
PROTECTOR OF LIGHT
Knight of the Green Room




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 0
Reviews 324
Why not try?

Review of novel chapter: work/DreamingofWriting/The-Fallen-Princess-Chapter-One-The-Past-139836#c645336
Review of poem:
Review of short story:
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
Review of work published in February:
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
Review of script:
Review of something from the fantasy genre: work/DreamingofWriting/The-Fallen-Princess-Chapter-One-The-Past-139836#c645336
Review of Green Room poem:
Review of rhyming poem:
Review of something from the horror genre:
Review of article/essay:
Review of fanfiction: work/Archangel/Joker-Missed--Agitated--Chapter-5-139857#c645268
Review of Green Room novel chapter: work/DreamingofWriting/The-Fallen-Princess-Chapter-One-The-Past-139836#c645336
Review of something from romance genre:
Review of something with zero reviews:
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
Review of work from the mystery genre:
Last edited by Evander on Sun Mar 25, 2018 6:14 am, edited 3 times in total.
Want to talk about your project? Head on over to the Writers Corner! If you have a question about writing, then head on over to Research! Is your question not big enough to warrant its own thread? Ask away in Little Details!

German rat enthusiast.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8976
Reviews 983
Yaaaaaaassss

Review of novel chapter:
Review of poem:
Review of short story:
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
Review of work published in February:
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
Review of script:
Review of something from the fantasy genre:
Review of Green Room poem:
Review of rhyming poem:
Review of something from the horror genre:
Review of article/essay:
Review of fanfiction:
Review of Green Room novel chapter:
Review of something from romance genre:
Review of something with zero reviews:
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
Review of work from the mystery genre:
“I can't go back to yesterday because I was a different person then."
- Lewis Carroll




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 650
Reviews 766
Alright. Let's do this.

Review of novel chapter:
work/DeltaAllon/GenExile-Chapter-1-The-colony-139935?c=645276#c645276
Review of poem:
work/Chaser/Hearts-Broken-Like-Chocolate-139693?c=645502#c645502
Review of short story:
work/GreyMatter/Suggest-a-title-in-comments-139995#c645303
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:
work/dogsrule5/Unsafe--Chapter-12-139868#c645482
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
Review of work published in February:
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
work/DeltaAllon/GenExile-Chapter-1-The-colony-139935?c=645276#c645276
Review of script:
Review of something from the fantasy genre:
work/BlueAfrica/The-Chosen-Grandma-Chapter-252-139113#c645466
Review of Green Room poem:
Review of rhyming poem:
Review of something from the horror genre:
Review of article/essay:
Review of fanfiction:
Review of Green Room novel chapter:
work/DeltaAllon/GenExile-Chapter-1-The-colony-139935?c=645276#c645276
Review of something from romance genre:
work/Chaser/Hearts-Broken-Like-Chocolate-139693?c=645502#c645502
Review of something with zero reviews:
work/dogsrule5/Unsafe--Chapter-12-139868#c645482
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
work/BlueAfrica/The-Chosen-Grandma-Chapter-252-139113#c645466
Review of work from the mystery genre:
work/dogsrule5/Unsafe--Chapter-12-139868#c645482

the brigadier rides again!
LMS VI: Lunch Appointment with Death





User avatar
Gender Female
Points 90000
Reviews 1085
*cackles madly* (We'll see how much my awful WiFi lets me do today.)

Review of novel chapter:
This is Going to Be Fun Ch 1 (2500 Words)
Review of poem:
its complicated
Review of short story:
Alibi
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:
The Wrong Era Chapter 10 Part 1 (First Draft)
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
This is Going to Be Fun Ch 1 (2500 Words)
Review of work published in February:
Every Indian 00's Kid Will Relate To
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
The Infection: New World (Chapter 2-3)
Review of script:
Sister Brookes TV Horror Series Episode 1
Review of something from the fantasy genre:
I Will Return Chapter 3.3
Review of Green Room poem:
To Break a Heart
Review of rhyming poem:
To Break a Heart
Review of something from the horror genre:
The Face
Review of article/essay: An Essay on the Spanish-American War
Review of fanfiction:
Review of Green Room novel chapter:
The Wrong Era Chapter 10 Part 1 (First Draft)
Review of something from romance genre:
Why me
Review of something with zero reviews:
Sister Brookes TV Horror Series Episode 1
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
Review of work from the mystery genre:

(Didn't quite get all of them, but I got most of them!)
We're all stories in the end.

I think of you as a fairy with a green dress and a flower crown and stuff.
-EternalRain

I think you, @Deanie and I are like the Three Book Nerd Musketeers of YWS.
-bluewaterlily




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 136272
Reviews 1283
Completed

Review of novel chapter: work/JadeBunny/The-Flat-Kansas-Society-139891?c=645260#c645260
work/maishaywca/Devils-Disguise-Chapter-1-140002?c=645325#c645325
Review of poem: work/killeham/i-wish-our-love-for-music-could-translate-into-love-for-each-other-139983?c=645232#c645232
work/ShaikhTheWorld/What-do-I-want-for-when-I-die-139985?c=645334#c645334
Review of short story: work/Lareine/Sorcerer-Part-1-139691?c=645305#c645305
work/jsimmons18/The-Day-Eliza-Elijah-Woke-Up-139745?c=645339#c645339
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above: work/Ventomology/Conics-Unfortunately-54-139697?c=645315#c645315
Viggo's Break - Chapter 19.2 - Until next time (seven years ago)
Review of something from the teen fiction genre: work/jsimmons18/The-Day-Eliza-Elijah-Woke-Up-139745?c=645339#c645339
Review of work published in February: work/ZeldaIsShiek/American-Voices-Podcast-Script-Welcome-to-REDACTED-139650?c=645296#c645296
Viggo's Break - Chapter 19.2 - Until next time (seven years ago)
Review of something from the sci-fi genre: work/Ventomology/Conics-Unfortunately-54-139697?c=645315#c645315
Review of script: work/ZeldaIsShiek/American-Voices-Podcast-Script-Welcome-to-REDACTED-139650?c=645296#c645296
Review of something from the fantasy genre: work/Aley/Purging-Land-102805?c=645320#c645320
Review of Green Room poem: work/ZeldaIsShiek/Afton-A-Special-Place-in-Hell-139628?c=645249#c645249
Review of rhyming poem:
work/ShaikhTheWorld/What-do-I-want-for-when-I-die-139985?c=645334#c645334
Review of something from the horror genre: work/ZeldaIsShiek/Afton-A-Special-Place-in-Hell-139628?c=645249#c645249
work/maishaywca/Devils-Disguise-Chapter-1-140002?c=645325#c645325
Review of article/essay: work/outvaders/A-Fun-Perspective-139805?c=645227#c645227
Review of fanfiction: work/JadeBunny/The-Flat-Kansas-Society-139891?c=645260#c645260
Review of Green Room novel chapter: work/JadeBunny/The-Flat-Kansas-Society-139891?c=645260#c645260
Review of something from romance genre: work/killeham/i-wish-our-love-for-music-could-translate-into-love-for-each-other-139983?c=645232#c645232
Review of something with zero reviews: work/ZeldaIsShiek/Afton-A-Special-Place-in-Hell-139628?c=645249#c645249
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above: work/Ventomology/Conics-Unfortunately-54-139697?c=645315#c645315
Review of work from the mystery genre: work/Lareine/Sorcerer-Part-1-139691?c=645305#c645305
Viggo's Break - Chapter 19.2 - Until next time (seven years ago)
you should know i am a time traveler &
there is no season as achingly temporary as now
but i have promised to return




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 220
Reviews 1081
May as well give this a spin.
Spoiler
Review of novel chapter: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-152-139955#c645284
Review of poem:
Review of short story: The Fey Conspiracy: Part 1
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-152-139955#c645284
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
Review of work published in February:
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
Review of script:
Review of something from the fantasy genre: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-152-139955#c645284
Review of Green Room poem:
Review of rhyming poem:
Review of something from the horror genre:
Review of article/essay:
Review of fanfiction:
Review of Green Room novel chapter: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-152-139955#c645284
Review of something from romance genre:
Review of something with zero reviews: The Fey Conspiracy: Part 1
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
Review of work from the mystery genre:

Will Review For Food - Always taking review requests!

Discuss the last piece of media you consumed in Media Reviews!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 136272
Reviews 1283
Question for @DarkPandemonium

Can lyrics that have some near-rhyme count for the "rhyming poem" category? It's totally fine if they do not, just wanted to double check since I know sometimes lyrics count as poems, and sometimes they do not. :)
you should know i am a time traveler &
there is no season as achingly temporary as now
but i have promised to return




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1788
Reviews 20
Done!

Review of novel chapter:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Ribeana1/Powerless-139765#c645358
Review of poem:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Radrook/Now-only-I-139964#c645321
Review of short story:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Shootingmoons/The-Dentist-Office-short-139862#c645318
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/lelu/Chapter-20-of-Princess-of-the-Sea-139915#c645386
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/saentiel/strangers-139725#c645361
Review of work published in February:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/alliyah/Sinking-Softly-139723#c645411
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Radrook/Time-Machine-139899#c645331
Review of script:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/SpaceSnickerdoodle/PauseListen-To-Me-139944#c645406
Review of something from the fantasy genre:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/lelu/Chapter-20-of-Princess-of-the-Sea-139915#c645386
Review of Green Room poem:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/ShaikhTheWorld/Theres-a-storm-brewing-139948#c645316
Review of rhyming poem:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/ShaikhTheWorld/Theres-a-storm-brewing-139948#c645316
Review of something from the horror genre:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Archangel/Pain-139848#c645324
Review of article/essay:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Ishan212/Every-INDIAN-00S-KID-Will-Relate-To-139703#c645400
Review of fanfiction:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Daenyss/Back-to-the-Beginning-Chapter-1-139922#c645417
Review of Green Room novel chapter:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Thundahguy/A-Merry-Band-of-Monsters--Chapter-2-140009#c645367
Review of something from romance genre:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/PeijiRestoration/Servants-Love-139813#c645390
Review of something with zero reviews:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/Thundahguy/A-Merry-Band-of-Monsters--Chapter-2-140009#c645367
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/lelu/Chapter-20-of-Princess-of-the-Sea-139915#c645386
Review of work from the mystery genre:https://www.youngwriterssociety.com/work/ayushinav/Its-just-the-beginning-139984#c645328
Last edited by maishaywca on Sun Mar 25, 2018 12:38 pm, edited 12 times in total.
Maisha Mahmood




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 46598
Reviews 641
@alliyah as long as it's in the poetry category and it's got rhyming in it, that's fine by me.

Also, congratulations to alliyah and @Kanome for completing the challenge! I'm going to be busy writing up reviews for you both.

Concerning the matter of first place: in the event that multiple people complete the checklist (as is the case here) I will go by the number of reviews written to complete it to determine the winner. If there's a tie on that, I'll read through all of the reviews carefully and decide who I think has written the most helpful and constructive critiques. The one with the best-quality reviews will then win the full 2000.

Happy reviewing! :D
The backs of my eyes hum with things I've never done.


~Radical Face




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
Review of novel chapter: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-142-139696#c645397
Review of poem:
Review of short story:
Review of chapter numbered 10 or above: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-142-139696#c645397
Review of something from the teen fiction genre:
Review of work published in February: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-142-139696#c645397
Review of something from the sci-fi genre:
Review of script:
Review of something from the fantasy genre: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-142-139696#c645397
Review of Green Room poem:
Review of rhyming poem:
Review of something from the horror genre:
Review of article/essay: work/LeutnantSchweinehund/The-Free-Socialist-Manifesto--Introduction-and-Misconceptions-139971#c645385
Review of fanfiction:
Review of Green Room novel chapter: work/TheSilverFox/Chapter-142-139696#c645397
Review of something from romance genre: work/Lacy/Elizabeth-Marton-139865#c645391
Review of something with zero reviews: work/LeutnantSchweinehund/The-Free-Socialist-Manifesto--Introduction-and-Misconceptions-139971#c645385
Review of chapter numbered 20 or above:
Review of work from the mystery genre:
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 11482
Reviews 351
@DarkPandemonium So uh. Who are the winners? xD
PROTECTOR OF LIGHT
Knight of the Green Room




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 46598
Reviews 641
@Kanome all will be announced later today. Make sure you poke me if I forget!
The backs of my eyes hum with things I've never done.


~Radical Face



When a person tells you you hurt them, you don't get to decide you didn't.
— Louis C. K.