We act as if everything is fine and smooth
that we are united enough to live together.
We overlook our rifts that stretch longer
because this talk about races is insensitive.
We live in the same country
and breath the same air.
Although we differ in complexion
it does not define us.
Or does it?
How many times
have you mentioned
the whiter one’s skin,
the prettier one was?
We live in the same country
and breath the same air.
Although our mother tongue differs
it is not a hindrance to us.
Or does it?
How many times
have you ignored
the national language
and used your own instead?
We live in the same country
and breath the same air.
Although we differ in religion
we can live in harmony.
Or could we?
How many times
have you claimed
this religion defined your race
and that religion deserved insults?
We live in the same country
and breath the same air.
Although our interest differs
we still help each other.
But do we?
How many times
you filed complaints on others
And talked about unfairness
for the sake of your race?
Because this talk about races is insensitive
we overlook our rifts that stretch longer.
That we are united enough to live together
we act as if everything is fine and smooth.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there! Thanks for requesting a review in my review thread.
Let's get straight to it, then.
I am not a fan of political poems - in my opinion, they tend to just inflame opinions that people already have rather than persuading them to look at something differently. Furthermore, they tend not to be poetry, just a thinly veiled argument with none of the flow and rhythm that defines poetry.
Flow
Unfortunately, you poem falls into that category. It's blunt, and there isn't much flow to it. You have stuck to a particular style admirably, but the words do not evoke feeling (except for something I'll get to later). The flow of the piece reads more like prose than poetry. I could remove all the line breaks and get a perfectly functioning paragraph that could go in an essay. Poetry is not prose with extra line breaks and weird punctuation.
However, the blunt flow wouldn't be that much of a problem were it not for what you are saying with it.
Content
The problem is, your poem is rather accusatory. I'm pretty sure you didn't intend it that way, but it is. In plain, simple language, you ask pointed questions to the reader, accusing them of being racist or religiously intolerant. You don't even ask if the reader has done this, you ask them how many times. I'm sure you know that not everyone is Xist, but your poem makes it sound like you do. Far from making the reader re-think their "bigoted" ways, this approach usually does one of two things:
1. If the reader has not done these things, they are annoyed that you assume they have. This tends to decrease their sympathy towards those who are fighting for equality, as they are sick of being called bigots when they really aren't. (This, quite honestly, is me.)
2. If the reader has done these things, they might feel guilty, but since they feel like they are being accused, they aren't very likely to willingly change. You can't change someone by accusing them of bigotry over and over again.
In short, this poem is full of good intentions, trying to call out racists and people who are religiously intolerant, but accusing them is not going to make them change, and it doesn't make for a very pleasant poem.
But never fear! I will now give suggestions on how to re-work this and make it more powerful and less inflammatory.
Suggestions
1. Tell a story, and focus on the details. There's a quote in the quote generator that reads:
This is really great advice, in my opinion. So, aim narrow. Pick one topic. Religious intolerance, or racism? Then roll with it. Choose a protagonist, probably one who's part of the group being discriminated against. Choose the smallest angle of the discrimination, and show how it hurts them.
2. Be emotional. You should probably have the poem be deep inside the person's head. Let us feel what they feel, and let us empathize with them. However, make sure they are likable, and not just generic. Give us a specific reason to like them.Be careful to not have them wallow in anguish the entire poem - that tends to be more annoying than anything.
3. Be unique. Don't go with the classic examples of discrimination - those are overused to the point of boredom, and most people would never be that extreme in their discrimination. Go with something smaller, less common.
4. Write poetry, not prose. Use lots of imagery (it's really good for stuff like this). Don't just write a short story in poem form.
You're probably wondering, "Why on earth would this work?" The reason is that people become more tolerant through learning about those they call "other". If they know these people, they realize that, no matter what they look like or what they believe, they are people.And one of the best ways to do that is through reading stories about those "others."
This isn't just conjecture, either. Studies have shown that people who read a lot are more tolerant of other viewpoints and beliefs, because they have read books with protagonists that think differently then them. Not only have they been exposed to different ideas, they have been exposed to the people behind the ideas, and they understand that everybody is human, with desires that are often just the same as theirs.
I truly believe that this method is a much better way to challenge "bigotry" than throwing around accusations with a slightly self-righteous air. It's not accusatory, it doesn't start arguments, instead it helps people empathize with others.
TL;DR: Tugging at peoples heartstrings works a lot better than throwing accusations around.
Conclusion
Anyway, I hope this review helped. As someone who is increasingly tired of the cruel and inflammatory language thrown around, and how easy it is to get called a "bigot," (when I've never hated anybody in my life) this sort of thing hits rather close to home, and I'm sometimes overly-eager to "correct" what I see as flawed methods that are well-meaning, but only inspire hard feelings.
I hope I didn't offend you, and if I have, I'm sorry. I think you wrote this poem with the best of intentions, and I commend you for that. The only problem is in the execution. I'd love to see a re-write of this - if you ever do re-write it, tell me, and I'll be sure to review it.
If you have any questions, feel free to PM me!
Very good! I have to say that your poem really struck truth. It spoke to a deeply personal topic, and spoke it with a nice rhythm. In Fact, when I read it, I somehow read it as if it was a song! And what you said in your poem really happens, not just in Malaysia, but all around the world. It's true that even myself, at times, has acted in precisely the way you said in your poem. It really struck home with me on that point! There were just a couple of minor grammatical errors and sentences that could be said a little better. For example, i think that 'Although we differ in skin colour.' would be better said as 'Although we differ in complexion' as it reduces the number of syllables in the sentence, and evens it's length closer to the other sentences in the stanza, making the poem's pace more even. Also 'we can live with harmony' seems a little wrong to me. I think 'we can live in harmony' would sound better and make a little more sense. Also, I think the poem would flow better if you added commas after each sentence that doesn't end with a full stop. however, all in all, this is a very good poem, and I can't wait to see more from you! Please keep writing!
-Zeus
Thanks! I'll consider your suggestion when editing it!
I can always tag you when I publish a new piece if it's okay with you.
Fine by me!:) Provided I can tag you whenever i publish a new piece!
Ahahaha! XD You could but since I have a review shop, I prefer you leave a request there.