Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there, Sakura!
This piece is short and sweet, so I'll keep the review the same.
Beginning with your first line, I want to bring focus to the redundancy of your feeling: "I am alone, I feel alone." Redundancy in poetry should be a tool--a very specific tool used to add to an idea. However, in this instance, you just restate it, but in a bit of a weaker way. My challenge is that you shy away from directly stating your feelings in a poem verbatim. Now, this is expanded a bit later on, but it doesn't really justify the bold statement.
Now, I'm a fan of the imagery in the second couplet: the mention of an all white middle of nowhere. At the same time, though, you still restate your idea just before the mention, calling it a snowy road. Now, either one of the images states your claim well enough (though I'd much rather you use "all-white middle of nowhere"). So consider your image here, imagine how to expand it, bring more life into your meaning and description.
Think of it as cooking: ingredient A doesn't change when you add more ingredient A to it. But an ingredient B can give you something completely different: the flavor of an ingredient C, but it keeps the elements of both. Does that make sense? So try adding more, changing things, to emphasize.
Your central idea is solid enough: loneliness, frantic lack of direction. When you feel this (which is an emotion that's really easy to relate to), what other images come to mind? More than snow--give me that.
As far as the lyricism of the piece:
This feels a bit bland to me, to be honest. While I can relate, it's not very engaging, and I'd like to challenge you to change that. How would you describe this feeling to a second person? What if you plugged me into the piece as a reader? How would I feel things, see things? Give me that.
Let me know if you have any questions, and keep writing!
-Lumi
Today I am alone; I feel alone. ((Nice start))
Like I am in the middle of a snowy road,
in a plain white, middle of nowhere ((I don't really understand this line. Maybe it could be phrased better?))
I am frantic about it, searching for an end
at either side but there is none. (( Nothing here, just a nice stanza))
Just me. And the snow,
the wind and the long road ahead (( I love this stanza))
Just me. On my own.
Just, me.
Nice poem!
Greetings!
it had good structure, good flow, good imagery. but i think at some points i have to agree with yuriko, it doesn't leave the reader anything. the repetitions work good, though.
the description of being alone was done quite simply and i liked that. it was short and fun to read. also, people can relate to it.
hope to read more of your work.
Puck
Hello there!
It's been months since I've reviewed anything here so I'm warning you in advance that this might probably be a little vague when read- but I hope you can get at least the gist of this review. haha ^^
Onto the poem, I don't think this doesn't leave your readers anything. It just feels empty/bare right there, like a line drawn on a paper and nothing more. Don't get me wrong-the simplicity of the poem is a charm, however, there wasn't really a point in terms of giving your readers a message. Alone here, alone there- seems repetitive that it actually comes off uninteresting. What I would probably suggest is being more creative on how you play at words or giving it a twist of imagery-something like that. In terms of your grammar, this is pretty clean and neat. But just like I've said before, having a good grammar isn't enough, it should also have a good prose and imagery (try applying figures of speech).
Hope this helps.
Keep writing,
Yuri
Hi there!
Anyway, there isn't any rhyme scheme which I like. Sometimes when poems rhyme they end up sounding like forced rhymes and that bothers me. So, yeah, good job on this poem.
Alright, so I like the general idea of this poem. Honestly, this is how I feel most of the time so I can totally relate to this.
The structure of this is good. I also like the imagery you used. The metaphor with the snow is great. I can really imagine it. I also like the snow so that's a plus for me.
Comments/Suggestions/Critiques:
Overall I give this a 5.7/6. There are a few tiny things I think that could make it better. You don't have to do what I suggested of course, that's just my personal opinion. At the end of the day it's your poem, not mine.
Keep writing!
**Noelle**
Thank you for your review, very much appreciated.
Also, I am going to edit this and use your ideas, I think they make sense. Thank you so much for the help. 