Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I can't grasp the meaning, but it's very good use of words considering the vagueness and variety in them, and they all give a certain calm and cold image/feeling. Imagine a thumbs up in front of you. That's my hand saying this is nice. But I can't make a great connection or review without grasping the complete meaning, but for this it's more of a personal matter, of course it's there but as for me I can't see it everywhere, except the last stanza which was a little more clear.
Hello, Dreamwalker
I'm glad I stumbled on your poem, and let me just say I throughly enjoyed it. I have to agree with lilymoor on the title; it really gave me a great image of Summer and the heat, as I live in Georgia and do have a liking to ice cubes, haha. Of course, when I read it, I began to picture the cold and the snow.
I didn't see much to edit, but there are a few lines that have word confusions.
'ice's' should be changed to 'ice is', but besides that, everything seems good.
Once again, wonderful poem, and I look forward to reading more poems from you.
-Hiccup
Hey there, Dreamwalker!
First and foremost, let me just say that I was hooked at the title. Something about the idea and the image that it stirs up, well, right away, it reminded me something of a summer poem, girl on the porch sucking on ice cubes to keep cool. But then you turned it around and you gave me this very chilly poem that, though not what I expected, was worth the read.
The first thing that really stood out to me about this is the way you alternated in telling the story, second and forth stanzas speaking about the narrator and the first and third stanzas focusing on the "you" of the poem. Your word choice was really good as well. You picked words that didn't just mean cold but felt chilly as well.
A couple nitpicks:
"Numbing" is the big issues I have with this line. The water tastes cold and numbing. The parallelism that makes lines like this stronger is missing with the word numbing. When keeping lines parallel, it would look like "colding and numbing" (which is wrong) or "cold and numb." Numbing just feels weird because it's in a different tense from the first descriptive "cold."
"swell" and "swollen" are too very similar words and I don't know if I like how they sound so close to one another, especially if you take out the first descriptive "blue" and then it just reads as "swell like swollen lips." Just something to keep in mind. It actually wasn't something I noticed until the 3rd time I read through the last stanza.
Otherwise I liked this overall. The exactness of "you" in the poem is a little vague but it leaves a hint of mystery for the reader and influences the cold and lonely feeling of both winder and loss really well.
Best of luck and if you have any questions, feel free to shoot me a PM or leave a note on my wall.
~lilymoore
This was written really well! I have to admit that I kind of stumbled on the first stanza because the way it was worded tripped me up a little, but I love the way you're describing everything. It's interesting that you didn't capitalize any of the first lines....it works better in some poems than it does in others, and in yours it's okay although it doesn't seem particularly necessary. You also have a line "Where the *ice's* too thin to cross" - change it to ice *is,* and I think that it will actually flow better.
But all this being said, this really was a pretty fantastic poem. *liked!
It flows well and it's soo creative; I just wanted to read more and more. There are a lot of maudlin, singsongy poems on this site, so it's nice to see these unique ones now and then.
Keep writing,
StoryWeaver