E - Everyone

Crescent Landings

There are crescent moons

imprinted in the skin 

of my palm, canker sores 

in my gums like craters 

of things I thought 

could never be said


But you landed 

in my atmosphere;

your words 

crumbled my mouth 

to dust.

Comments & reviews · 5
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Sassafras
Review

Helo, Indee.

Something about your poem is really appealing. I can't say what it is exactly, though, as they two stanzas didn't exactly fit together at first glance, and I was more confused than awed. That was, however, before I took the time to take a deeper look, and I will say, this poem requires a lot of analyzing to try and get what the topic is about.

This is both something good and something bad. Good, because AP English buffs like me were basically brainwashed into the ways of analytic reflection, and reading this, trying to figure out the meaning, was actually a lot of fun. It also helps if you're big into Sherlock - deductions! However, this could also be really bad, because some people might not take the time to sit down and contemplate the possibilities of what this poem could mean. But, then again, I've got a feeling that the people described in the latter are not your targeted audience.

There are crescent moons
imprinted in the skin
of my palm, canker sores
in my gums like craters
of things I thought
could never be said


While I absolutely love this stanza, I feel like it could be sectioned more evenly and cleaner. When read alone as a stand-alone sextet, it's actually pretty perfect, but when you continue on with the poem, to the next section, the first then becomes a bit dis-conjoined and starts to look a bit bumbling.

It's not really an obvious problem, and some may argue that it's actually not a problem at all, but I ask you to read it out loud anyway and just try to get a feel for the harmony and see for yourself.

As I've said, I really love this. It's one of the best I've read today.

Keep writing! :)

-RP

User avatar
ERZA
Review
ERZA wrote a review · Sun May 26, 2013 7:43 pm

Hey Indie,
I will be reviewing your poem. Soooo basically I do not really get what the poem is about. It needs length color polish finishing and basically everything. It sort of looks like a piece of draft that you hurriedly had written somewhere without thinking twice or going with the flow! This is simply not good. I suggest you first clear your mind and then think abiut what you want to write after that allow yourself to filled with ideas till the brim and after that jot them down patiently with out losing you focus and concentration...if you are successfully able to do the feat then your skills will sharpen to a great extent and also you will be able to write much better stuff. :-D

User avatar
ERZA
Review
ERZA wrote a review · Sun May 26, 2013 7:42 pm

Hey Indie,
I will be reviewing your poem. Soooo basically I do not really get what the poem is about. It needs length color polish finishing and basically everything. It sort of looks like a piece of draft that you hurriedly had written somewhere without thinking twice or going with the flow! This is simply not good. I suggest you first clear your mind and then think abiut what you want to write after that allow yourself to filled with ideas till the brim and after that jot them down patiently with out losing you focus and concentration...if you are successfully able to do the feat then your skills will sharpen to a great extent and also you will be able to write much better stuff. :-D

User avatar
ScarlettFire
Review

Hey indieeloise! My name is Scarlett and I'll be reviewing your poetry tonight. ^^

Wow, Indiee. This is amazing. I love it. But I just have one problem; it doesn't feel finished, and the flow is slightly disjointed--but that's not a huge problem. Sometimes, people prefer that. I think it works here, though. It's definitely missing *something*, but I'm not sure what. Perhaps you could add something to this? The ending is a little abrupt, and it was just starting to get good!

I don't have anything more to say other than it's good, but not the best, and with a few little fiddles, it'll be really good. I suggest adding another couple of stanzas to it. Despite this, I do like it so far, and that's a good thing. Revise it and please let me know. I'll be sure to come back and read it again! This is a wonderful and interesting little poem. Thanks for the poetry! I hope this review helps, somehow. ^^

Remember; keep it up and never stop writing!

~Scar. <3

User avatar
Morrigan
Review

Hi there, Indie.

I like your ideas, and the way you illustrate them. The ending is nice, too. That being said, I think this needs a little polishing.

Honestly, I'm not quite sure what you're trying to say. It's rather vague (I'm sorry if it's due to my stupidity). The sentence structure of the first stanza I think is what's messing me up there. The second stanza is pretty, but I don't know why this person crumbled your mouth to dust. I want more feeling toward this person or thing. I don't know if they crumbled your mouth to dust because they said something awful, or because they said something important and enlightening and left you speechless. Make sure that the reader knows if the person in the second stanza is the hero or the villain.

Now on to more nitpicky things.
If I were you, I'd rearrange the words in the first stanza to more clearly reflect the message. I would rearrange it like this:

crescent moons imprint
themselves into the skin
of my palm, and craters
canker my gums
like impossible words.

By doing this, I've also made it less wordy around the "impossible" bit. I changed it to "canker my gums" because it creates a stronger image. Also, it connects better to your moon theme. If "craters" is the subject, that's the first thing the reader sees.

What if something other than "you" landed in the atmosphere? What if
but when your
clean white suit
and static landed
in my atmosphere,
your words
crumbled my mouth
to dust

Or what if
but you landed
with strange ideas
and blue hair
in my atmosphere
to crumble
my mouth
to dust


I'm just playing with the last stanza, trying to show you ways to imply things about this person who landed in your atmosphere. I want to know who it is, so we can read further into the story.

Altogether, I like the connections you're making in the first stanza, but it needs some polishing. I can't wait to see it when it's really shining. I hope that this review was helpful to you. Happy poeting!



If you receive a bribe, you must report it in your income.
— John Oliver