Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello~ I was told to look at your work for couplet comprehension, so I am reviewing your work >3 I shall now begin.
My Main Problem: first stanza focus-So for me, the key things in this stanza that really stood out were that there were multiple deaths. I connected this to a car crash and I enjoy how wonderfully you paint a picture of so much destruction in just 4 lines. The annoying thing, for me, is that, we have, a lot, of commas to deal with. I think this poem would be easier to get into if you allowed things to flow from one line to the next as they naturally progressed as ideas. We go from "shock,"
(wait for it,)
to "a growing pool" and then we hit "which mock,"
(wait for it!)
"Their soon departure." (dun dun dun) <- but we already had the -dun dun dun- moment when we were wide eyed and horrified, so why are we waiting for the lines? Why take a pause there instead of clearing things up and connecting the single ideas, the single bits of key phrases like "which mock/their soon departure,"? This is a common theme throughout the poem, commas/punctuation at the end. For me this clockwork at the end is very annoying. Unlike-some-of the YWS society though, I don't mind capitalized letters at the beginning of lines, and I typically don't mind end line punctuation, but I do mind punctuation that doesn't matter in the overall scheme of things to me as a reader. The reason these commas don't matter to me is because I already know that there is something special about the word -mock- due to the rhyme, and that it ends the line.
I would also suggest using "the" instead of "a" for the determiner attached to "collision". I think it will make the thing seem more dramatic, like this is THE main event of the season. Aside from that, I love how well you put together your thoughts in two lines and how the rhymes seem to help tie things together. I'm going to be stalking the rest of your work now.
Hi there!
I think this poem was really good!
The length of each line seemed to fit each stanza. Also, the rhymes were nice and smooth!
Also, I understood it more. The poem flowed really well. And I really enjoyed it, Toe!
Great job, and keep writing!
~Kat
Hi Toe!
Cool, rhyming poetry! I was very interested to see a "horror" poem, and since it has rhymes, it reminds me a bit of Edgar Allan Poe, whom I love.
The first stanza is the most powerful in my opinion because of the delicious rhymes within the stanza, not just at the end of each line:
It makes it sound so smooth and good when read out loud, and I definitely enjoyed that.
With that said, I was a bit disappointed to see that you didn't continue this in the rest of the poem. Your rhymes are mostly neat (although "choked" and "afloat" is a bit forced), so it was fine. It would be even more interesting, I think, if you did the internal rhymes throughout the poem.
I hope you've read this aloud. But if not, do it, because there were some lines that I had to read more quickly than the others to keep the rhythm going. You'll be sure to notice the same when you reread this. So when that's fixed, the technical side of this will be golden.
There was also a lot of nice imagery. I especially liked "-- mixture of emotions which mock / their soon departure".
However, I'm not quite sure what the "stone" refers to? I'd like to think it was a symbol for something instead of an actual stone, but I can't think of what it could be. And you mention it at least twice, so it has to be quite important.
I also liked the title! It's catchy.
Demeter
x
Of course it was a symbol! If you like internal rhymes then I think you should check my Portfolio for "Loneliness".
Thanks for the quickie.