Author's Note: This poem is a bit personal, so try and refrain from rather harsh reviews, I'd still appreciate feedback though. This poem has a purpose beyond posting it here. I just needed your guys' help for any little mistake such as grammar and punctuation. And if there is too much repetition with certain words, just comment. Thanks!
___________________________________________________________________________________
The day I turned 9,
I noticed the glamour in the air.
The complete and utter
excitement hanging.
I saw how there were
only 8 candles on the cake;
you said because candles
only come in packs of 8.
I smiled and giggled, just like you.
You said it's my last year
being 9, only having one digit.
-
The day I turned 11,
I saw only 7 candles on top of the
vanilla flavoured ice cream cake.
You said that during my brothers birthday,
the 8th candle melted too short.
I nodded and blew out my
7 candles, wishing that
I still would have 7 candles next year.
-
But this year seemed
to last an eternity.
It seemed to drag on and on
like the sleepless nights that proliferated.
I noticed how I stopped
smiling and giggling that year.
I felt the solemn air with my fingertips,
all the same time I had a blanket over my head.
Thinking that maybe it would deafen
the constant bickering and
the sustained ringing of glasses
shattering against the floor.
-
When the year I turned 12 came,
I thought that I had gotten used to
finding cans of beer on the counter.
I thought that maybe if I just
stopped thinking about it and
started ignoring instead, that
I would be able to sleep at night
without sweat beading up on my face.
But to my misfortune,
I still jumped when I heard doors slamming.
I still felt the solemn air with my fingers
that now had nails chewed down.
-
As I turned 13,
things started changing for the better.
That year, glasses stayed in cabinets,
doors were kept open
and counters were clean,
as if the rings of beer
never dwelled among them.
I noticed how I slept soundly at night.
I could dream and wake up to
songbirds and the smell of coffee.
But I never forgot the single note
that the glasses once sang.
-
I reached 15,
I realized dreams don't last forever
and that I was so very foolish to believe.
Broken glasses appeared on the floor once again;
as if they were caged too long and found freedom,
but like you, they didn't see how delicate they were.
The fractured glass was picked clean and discarded.
I'm coming to think that maybe that's exactly how you feel.
But maybe you feel more like
that 8th candle that never made it.
I can't tell.
Needed for too long, or not needed enough.
It came to my attention that I never was bold all along.
I recognized how easily I turned up my music
to submerge the yelling and slamming.
It all felt too familiar, but with the feeling,
along came the somber tinge in the air.
-
Nights began to lengthen once again.
You were right about one thing.
I yearned to have a one digit age.
I desired to be 9 once again.
Wishing that cakes still had 8 candles.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello.
I will try to be gentle with this. It's a rather solid poem and I don't think it needs much critique. However, I did notice a few things.
Firstly, the middle of this piece which describes the decent into alcoholism a bit repetitive, with the same descriptive language used when I think better words exist. "Solemn" was the biggest offender, showing up twice in a couple stanzas, but the imagery of glasses also felt like a bit much.
I'm not sure what you can do to tweak this but I'd like to see the imagery maybe get a little darker as the decent progresses? Then the language reflects how things are getting darker, and harder. Maybe go more into fear for that second segment, but I don't know how you were feeling so I can't suggest past that.
I don't think the snap back to alcoholism needs to be changed much because it pulls from the dark and adds an edge of hopelessness, which darkens it enough.
Overall I actually did like this. I can tell it's very personal, but you've shaped it in such a way it's relatable. You give us just enough in terms of concrete events that I can see the kitchen, the counter, the glasses and hiding in your room. Rather chillingly, it turns into my own house, which for me is a good sign because you've given me nothing but emotions and let me fill in the unimportant details.
You had good focus with this, but like I said the decent into alcoholism was a bit repetitive because the tone didn't seem to darken as it went on once it hit a certain point. I understand those were probably the hardest to write and if you don't want to add to them; for flow, I think going from light to dark, back to light, then crashing into dark is the best way to go, but it's not my poem.
Hope this helps. PM me if you have any questions or comments.
~Rosey
Hey there, rhia here to review!
As you mentioned that this is personal, I will avoid reviewing based on content and focus only on grammar. However, even if you hadn't said that, I wouldn't have had too much to say about content anyways, because I think you did a very good job, and the story is very well conveyed.
Anyways, nitpicks
Brother's should be brothers. You don't need the apostrophe, because it's possesive, not a conjunction.
I think this would make a little more sense if you said "wishing that *I would* still have 7 candles next year.
This should say "all the same time I had *a* blanket over my head". You just forgot the a, probably just a little typo.
You just left the "u" off of the end of "used", it says "use" instead of "used"
This bit is a really long run-on sentence. Maybe try adding some commas. I would do it like this
"I thought that maybe, if I just/stopped thinking about it and started ignoring instead, that/ I would be able to sleep at night
Same here, I'd add a comma after "cabinets".
Your grammar with starting a new sentence with this type of "as" is incorrect. I'd just cut that "as if" out of this.
Otherwise, really good. I hope I could help with the grammar.
Wow, thank you so much. I think that I am going to fix basically all of your 'point-outs'. This helps a lot, Happy Review day!
Hello! Katya here to review! I will not be harsh about the topic and all that because I suck at that sort of thing. Well here goes!

NITPICKS:
Spoiler
Flavored is spelled incorrectly here. (Don't worry we all make mistakes.)
That's needs an apostrophe before s. Think of it this way. Is it a conjunction? Does it expand to that is? Try thinking about thats and that's that way(so many thats!).
I love the theme of this poem. I was about to cry when I read this. When you said this is personal, I realized that this is probably a true story in some way. How when you were little you had little problems but you didn't realize how little they were(I still wish I was nine too). Then when you grow up, things take a bad turn and you get more and more huge problems. I have a friend that had something similar to this. I have been trying to help him, but it is really hard. Anyways! Great piece! Keep writing! Tell me when you make something else!
Flavour was spelled correctly, Kat. They used the British spelling.
ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. XD I don't know how to spell in British gosh!
Hey KatyaElefant! Thank you for this cute review! I didn't notice my missing apostrophe (whoops)! And honestly, I'm not even British. xD I just really like how they spell it, along with 'colour'.
Yeah! I am always so confused on spelling especially when reviewing spelling errors. XD Sometimes people end up being British and they go I spelled it right...Just in British XD