z
  • Home

Young Writers Society



held by a memory, lost to a stranger

by Elektra



Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
182 Reviews

Points: 11016
Reviews: 182

Donate
Stickied -- Thu Nov 07, 2024 4:08 am
View Likes
Elektra says...



Text Version:

i finally opened the picture album you gifted me when i was three.
when i was innocent; when i only knew the world in shades of pink and blue.
the first photo is of you,
with that bright red hair, like flames under the sun.
it framed your face beautifully—
accentuated those high cheekbones and full lips that you passed onto me.
your eyes were the deepest green, wide and laughing, crinkling at the corners
as you squinted into the flash.

at first glance, nobody would know that
when this picture was taken, you were lost. lost in your own little world,
controlled by demons that held your soul in their grasp. your mind was
corrupted by the very thing that created me.
when i was old enough to understand, my sisters told me
you were "sick," that love alone couldn’t save you,
that you were stuck somewhere and i couldn’t follow.
but all I remember are the whispers and stares,
the pity in strangers' eyes when they said your name.

i had to close the photo album.
because with every reminder of you,
i feel the sharp edge of a love that almost was.




User avatar


Points: 14
Reviews: 4

Donate
Tue Nov 12, 2024 3:05 pm
SavageRaptor109 wrote a review...



This is a beautiful poem. The way you described the photo of who I'm guessing is the mother, the use of language in the second stanza to create an almost eerie setting, and the short and simple last stanza makes this poem feel perfect. The use of the word "sick" in the second stanza feels perfect because it could have several meanings based on the surrounding context. Though, I feel like you could make the last stanza a bit longer to go with the other two stanzas. Other than that, I feel like it is an amazing poem that uses language and descriptive words perfectly.




User avatar
661 Reviews

Points: 65968
Reviews: 661

Donate
Sat Nov 09, 2024 5:53 am
EllieMae wrote a review...



Hey Ley!! I loved this poem of yours so much </3

One thing that I really loved about this is how narrative it felt. You tell the story of how you open this picture album that was gifted to you by your mother. I love how you talk about being a child and how, at that time, you were so innocent, and maybe we're not so aware of all of the darkness that was also existing in this situation. I think you did such a good job at describing your mother, her beautiful features, but also how they were passed on to you and how you are able to recognize that in yourself now. I think you did such a good job at showing this growth that you have had within yourself from a child to an adult who is now, conscious and aware of everything. Once we get to the second part of the poem, it gets a lot deeper.

controlled by demons that held your soul in their grasp. your mind was
corrupted by the very thing that created me.
when i was old enough to understand, my sisters told me
you were "sick," that love alone couldn’t save you,
that you were stuck somewhere and i couldn’t follow.


That first line above, really stood out to me. You talk about how your mother's mind was corrupted by the very thing that created you. There's so many possibilities as to what this could be. If we look at it in a positive light, it could be some thing like love or inspiration or romance. But if we look at it in a different sort of flight, it could be something more dangerous, or filled with evil or lust or pain. I found it interesting how quickly you changed from the past to the present. I actually really like that, because it feels really accurate of how it feels to reflect on painful memories. We go from this moment of living and imaginary in a sense in our minds, to realization that it's not real, and that we are here in the present.

The last three lines were so gorgeous. You close this photo album, because every reminder, every photo, it all points back to the fact of what didn't happen, but almost did. I have to say, you posted this as such a convenient time, as I have had a very similar experience lately. Recently, I found a photo album that contains pictures of me with my parents before they got divorced (as a toddler), so I so so deeply related to this poem. That pain of what could've been, what you deserved, it's more painful than the life you lived and what never happened.

Anyways, amazing job, as always. This poem was very simple, and not overly complex, which is something that I love with you. You are a poet who has the ability to create and craft insanely complex metaphors, but at the same time I love to read a poem like this, which feels so refreshing. Still, I think it is highly symbolic in its own ways, but I felt like I could relate to it really deeply, and simply, almost like it was a metaphor that a child could understand. Great job <3 Can't wait to read more!

Your friend,
Ellie




Elektra says...


Aw omg thank you Ellie! <3



User avatar
6 Reviews

Points: 159
Reviews: 6

Donate
Thu Nov 07, 2024 4:57 am
Vanya wrote a review...



It was awesome, especially when you defined what the girl's father looked ked like. Each example was right on the point. But I didn't quite understand the last paragraph where you talked about demons but it was definitely good. And the last paragraph where the girl closes the album tells us about her misery. The pain you painted through this paragraph was amazing.





The function of education is to teach one to think intensively and to think critically. Intelligence plus character - that is the goal of true education.
— Martin Luther King, Jr.