z
  • Home

Young Writers Society



Talking to the Moon

by Elektra



Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
180 Reviews

Points: 12649
Reviews: 180

Donate
Stickied -- Sat Aug 24, 2024 1:10 am
Elektra says...



Text Version:

There you are, old friend.
I’ve got some questions, you know, stuff I can’t really say out loud to anyone else.
“How do you keep it together, being the one everyone looks at but never really sees?
I’ll wait, because I know you don’t rush with answers, you take your time.
I’ll make myself comfortable.”

“It’s not really calm, you know,” you said:
“but I’ve learned to carry what I must—tides, dreams, the lonely thoughts of people like you,
who look up at me hoping I’ll give them something I don’t really have.”
Your eyes dimmed for just a second. I saw that.

“Is that why you’re always so quiet?” I asked, soaking in your soft glow,
“Is that why you just watch, instead of jumping down here and fixing things yourself?”
You took your time, like you always do, letting the silence settle between us,
and I almost thought you wouldn’t answer. But then, with a gentle sigh, you spoke.

“I’m quiet because I’ve learned that not everything needs fixing.
Sometimes, all we can do is witness, just be there for the things we can’t change.”
It made sense, this quiet wisdom of yours.
The world below is full of noise, of chaos, and maybe that’s why you choose to remain so still, so distant.

But then, you spoke again. “I remember why I’m here,” you said, your light flickering just a bit brighter,
"even if it’s faint, even if it’s borrowed. And I find strength in that, in knowing that my presence,
however small, means something to someone, somewhere.”

“Thanks,” I breathed, “I needed to hear that.”
You didn’t say anything, but your light stayed with me,
You shifted, just slightly, and the light in your eyes dimmed again.
You looked at me, and in the quiet of the night, you whispered something I wasn’t ready to hear.

“You see, I’m not what you think I am,
I’m just a reflection, a mirror of something far away. I hold no secrets, no answers,
only the light borrowed from another. The truth is, you’ve been talking to yourself all along,
searching for answers within your own darkness, projecting them onto me.”

The world seemed to pause; my breath caught in my chest.
And in that moment, I realized—
it wasn’t you who needed to listen,
it was me.




User avatar
62 Reviews

Points: 8108
Reviews: 62

Donate
Mon Sep 09, 2024 3:57 pm
View Likes
candyhearts wrote a review...



Hai :3

I reviewed one of your other poems!! ^_^

I really like this one!! It's so soft yet so heavy at the same time!! The conversation-like flow is just perfect ~~ I adore how it opens, like you’re talking to this old friend who’s been there for you forever, but there’s this aching sadness underneath it all that builds in such a beautiful way. It's like I am stepping into something intimate, a long-standing relationship, but with some weight to it. There's so much unspoken tension that never comes to fruition, but it's so incredible here!!

The whole question of being seen but not really seen!! That hits deep. Like, you're talking to someone (or something?) that’s always there but never fully acknowledged. It's something I've never considered for the moon, something almost not perceivable past a surface level, but I'm really enjoying it!! The poem turns inward in such a profound way when you look past the metaphors.

I’ve learned to carry what I must—tides, dreams, the lonely thoughts of people like you


SO poetic !!!!

It almost feels like this old friend is the moon, carrying all of these unspoken feelings and forces beyond human control. The fact that you gave them a kind of tired wisdom feels so grounded ~~ Like, yes, even celestial beings can be tired of being everyone's emotional dumping ground. Such a raw, gentle moment!! It feels like the heart of the poem, this realization that sometimes the act of witnessing is enough. There's so much power in that one idea!! I can imagine it's very close to home for some.

The only suggestion I’d make is maybe tightening up some of the phrasing for even more impact. Like, when you write “letting the silence settle between us,” that’s such a gorgeous image, but I wonder if something even more visual could elevate it? Maybe something about the silence being heavy, like the tide rolling in or a fog settling? Just a thought!! But seriously, this is already so strong!! Maybe you can give space to other angles or dive into something deeper than that!!

^^^ Also, you nailed this whole bittersweet vibe, but I wish there was a little more perspective on the other figures. You've been talking to yourself this whole time, searching for answers in your own reflection. I feel like there could be room to have more interpretations, or a different perspective thrown in!!

it wasn’t you who needed to listen,
it was me


Gorgeous !!! I'm usually not a big fan of these "plot twist" type of endings, but I think the emotional journey the narrator went on calls for that!!

This poem is full of depth and feels so raw, yet controlled. I am obsessed with the way you write!! You're so good at balancing the dialogue with this underlying emotion that seeps through without being overt. That's an amazing skill to have!!

- Payton




Elektra says...


Thank you so much!



User avatar
1249 Reviews

Points: 145925
Reviews: 1249

Donate
Thu Aug 29, 2024 5:26 pm
View Likes
alliyah says...



Love the voice in this - really nice poem Ley!




Elektra says...


Thank you!!!! It means a lot. <333



User avatar
36 Reviews

Points: 650
Reviews: 36

Donate
Wed Aug 28, 2024 9:47 pm
View Likes
theromanticchemist wrote a review...



Hi, just popping in with a review!
This is so profound, the imagery really sucks me in. The conversation format just really makes the message sink in that much harder.
Again, the imagery is so vivid. The usage of metaphors using light is one that I think really fits here. The voice and tone of the poem fit here, and this is truly an amazing work. I will be reading more of your work now, I loved this one so much!




theromanticchemist says...


how did I not realize I didn't post this as a review :( hope you still take the compliments, it's really good!!



Elektra says...


Thank you! I can have a Poetry Mod change your review to an actual review, it is no problem! Thank you for the kind words <3



User avatar
35 Reviews

Points: 5015
Reviews: 35

Donate
Sat Aug 24, 2024 3:59 pm
View Likes
khushi17bansal says...



Just dropping by to say that I really love your poetry! Your very talented, and the covers are also very pretty <333



Spoiler! :
Also, have you heard the song?




Elektra says...


Yes! I have! And thank you for the lovely comment <3




Oh no, I’m sorry, you’re under the impression that here on YWS we *help* writers instead of just feeding their gremlin tendencies.
— winterwolf0100