I sit on the steps at the top of the stairs. It's the Christmas of 2012. I can hear my Mom yelling at my Dad.
"It's Christmas Eve, and you get drunk? What will Lydia think of you? She spent her life asking for a Father and when you came along she was so happy. What if she wakes up?" My Mom is doing that hissing whisper that adults do when they yell but don't want their kids to hear. It never works. The kids almost always hear and when they do, they are the ones protecting the adults. No parent wants to know that their kids have heard the most hurtful words spew from their lips. But it's true, that's what happens.
So instead of going downstairs, I choose to protect my parents and I tiptoe back to my room. I hold my breath until the door eases shut. I have the bedroom of a typical thirteen year old girl. A bookshelf in the corner, a good sized dresser, some windows, a bed. I climb into my bed and pull the covers up to my chin, but as hard as I try, I can't fall asleep.
How can this Christmas be so miserable? Christmas is supposed to be happy. I didn't even get to go to church.
I think this to myself, and suddenly I remember a past Christmas. This is the earliest Christmas I remember in detail. I was seven years old and getting ready to go to church. I remember having the prettiest lace dress, and seeing the nativity. I will never forget it.
*********
I slipped on my beautiful lace dress. My Mom had gotten this dress for me on sale. It was my Christmas dress, and it was the most beautiful shade of red you ever saw. I tugged open the door to my bedroom and walked into the hallway of the teeny little apartment we inhabited.
"Momma, will you zip my dress?" I asked her. My Momma smiled and she did as I asked. She looked at the dress on me and straightened my tights. She knelt, and pulled the tights out and up, like her fingers were climbing a staircase. Then she finished by pulling the tops of my white tights up my stomach. Next, She buckled my shiny, black shoes. They had a little heel and I loved them.
"You look beautiful." She said, smiling. I grinned and twirled for her. When she smiled, her tired eyes lit up like a Christmas tree, and the worry line between her eyebrows smoothed, making her look younger. My Mother wore a sparkly red shirt with nice black dress pants. She had given up on dresses after she gained weight when I was born. Nevertheless, she was my Momma and my best friend.
"Look Momma, we match!" I said. Her smile grew wider and she laughed. I gave her a hug, and we headed out the door. Momma locked it tight, and we began the descent on the steep staircase down our building. There were sixteen stairs total, I remember counting them as I went, lifting my feet and being careful not to scuff my shiny black shoes. I touched my foot to the pavement with my mother close behind me, the heels of my shoes made funny sounds.
"Lydia, you forgot your coat." My mother told me before she slipped the furry brown jacket over me. Momma was wearing her black and white coat. She loved that coat.
Mom unlocked the car and I slid into the back. The car was a hunter green Buick, a Park Avenue. It was the biggest car my mother could afford. Something to keep me safe, but also affordable. The real leather seats felt cool under my bottom and I squealed and squirmed as I felt the cold seep into the back of my dress. Then, I suddenly remember I was to be lady like and stop squirming. So I smoothed the lace of my dress and sat still. Once Mom got the car started, it was warmer. I buckled my seatbelt and we were ready to go. It was 10:50 at night, and it was a privilege to stay up this late. I needed to behave or Momma would make me go to the earlier church service next year.
When we finally drove off, I watched other cars on the road. I could see car exhaust in the crisp night air. There was no snow, oh but how I wished for it. I remember thinking about it for most of the car ride. I also remember how awful it was to find a parking space, but we managed, we always did. We had to walk a little farther, but I didn't mind. I got to look at all of the Christmas finery the church and the church-goers sported. While I didn't mind the walk, I was glad for the warmth of the church when a nice man opened the door for us. The gust of warm air in my face flushed my cheeks and warmed me to my toes. So I shrugged off my coat and stepped inside.
Outside the Sanctuary doors, there were to baskets with candles and little handles to hold the candles in. I took one, wondering what they were for. When I asked my Mom, she just smiled and winked at me. We took seats towards the back of the Church. The Altar was surrounded by poinsettias that made me sneeze. On a chain hanging from the ceiling was a circlet of blue and white candles held together by a circle of green leaves, there were two white candles, and two blue. Even the tiled floor seemed more festive and full of warmth. I took my seat and sat up straight with one leg crossed over the other. We sang carols to begin the service before the pastor began to talk about the birth of baby Jesus, the baby who would later become a man and die for my sins. Then pastor beckoned for people to come in. I was struck with wonder and awe.
The procession that walked in consisted of Children. Some wore long robes with some sort of headpiece. I saw some shepherds, and a few sheep wearing shirts and hats made of cottonballs. There were three children carrying boxes. In the front was a girl in blue, she was carrying a doll. The children then proceeded to act out the nativity. I loved it and clapped with everyone else after the children were finished. After that, the lights went out. I gave a little gasp, and Momma took my hand. She knew I didn't like the dark. But then I saw a light. It seemed to grow and illuminate people's faces. They were lighting candles. It was as if the light of Jesus was growing with each pass of the candle. When Momma lit my candle, I was careful to hold it aloft. I had a terrifying vision of me lighting somebody's hair on fire which made me hold on even tighter to the candle.
When everybody's candle was lit, the woman at the organ began to play Silent Night.
Silent Night, Holy Night!
All is calm, All is bright.
Round yon virgin, Mother and child,
Holy infant so tender and mild.
Sleep in heavenly peace,
Sleep in heavenly peace.
With each line, I could hear other more lovely notes resonating from the congregations voice. Everybody's voices joined together as one, even my childish sound. As the song continued, I looked around the church. All I could see were the flickering lights of the candles. I grasped my Momma's hand and continued to sing.
Silent Night, Holy Night!
Shepherds quake at the sight.
Glories stream from heaven afar,
Heavenly hosts singing Alleluia.
Christ the savior is born,
Christ the savior is born.
I imagined baby Jesus. I remembered vaguely how Pastor said nobody had room for Mary and Joseph, so they had to sleep in a barn. I thought about how if I had been in an inn that night, I would have gladly given up my room. Then again, those people didn't know Christ was the Savior. Then a more sobering thought filled my head. How Jesus later died on the cross for me and my sins. So I sent a silent prayer, thanking God and his son for allowing me to go to Heaven.
Silent Night, Holy Night!
Son of God, love's pure light.
Radiant beams from thy Holy face,
With the dawn of redeeming grace.
Jesus, Lord, at thy birth.
Jesus, Lord, at thy birth.
The song finished, the lights snapped back on and people began to blow out their candles. So I blew out mine as well. I was sad to see it end, the candles were so beautiful, the most beautiful thing I had seen in a long time. Even the beauty of my dress was nothing compared to the wonderful end of that service. I didn't complain when Momma hurried me to bed, I was so deep in thought. Well, about as deep in thought as a seven year old gets. After all, Santa was coming the next day! But I always kept the feeling of those candles and the hope they gave me in my heart. I had asked Santa for a Daddy, and I would get one. Santa was always good to me on Christmas. Somehow, the candles gave me the feeling that I would eventually get one.
Although I felt the hope of getting a Daddy that year, I didn't. I asked for a Daddy every year after that as well. I did eventually get a Father, but not until much later.
**********
As I lay awake in bed, recalling that memory I heard my Mom's door slam shut downstairs. I know my Dad must still be at the kitchen table, and that door slam probably woke half the neighborhood. I also know that my Mom was being harsh. Daddy made a mistake, but I've made mistakes too. So I get up, put on my robe and walk downstairs.
"Hi Daddy." I say. As he looks at me, I see how red his eyes are. I can't decide if it's from the alcohol or from tears, or both. I can see the shame in his face, and I know he really regrets it.
"I'm sorry Baby girl, I-" But I cut him off. I take a deep breath and look him in the eye.
"Daddy, I love you. Every Christmas I wished for a Dad, and I never expected to get one, let alone one as good as you. You made a mistake. It's okay, you aren't perfect. I've made mistakes too, and I know you love me no matter what happens. I love you unconditionally as well. Just promise me this won't happen again. Okay?" He nods and begins to cry. So I throw my arms around him.
My Mom comes walking in then, and she joins us.
"I'm sorry, Bill. I shouldn't have been so hard on you." They kiss, and I smile. Christmas is okay this year. I don't need to see my candles this year to feel the Christmas Spirit blossoming in my heart, but I know it's there. So I tiptoe quietly back up the stairs to my room. After I climb into bed, my last waking thought is of family and how thankful I am to have a complete family that loves me. I love them, more than anything or anyone else on Earth. I always have, and I always will.
Finis
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Alright, sorry for the delay, ED here with some feedback.
First off, this is my favorite section here:
It's so poignant, I know exactly what you are talking about.
Now on to the rest...
I found that, while this story had a good premise, it sort of fell flat as soon as you hit the flashback. I understand that this is a very personal story, but you can't let the fact that it's personal get in the way of telling a good story. Conversely, this wasn't personal enough in some places. And what I mean by all of this is detail. You're detail came up a little short.
Remember, show. Don't tell. What details are truly necessary for the story? Only add those ones. Eliminate the ones that just take up dead space, or aren't as powerful or functional as they could be. Edit ruthlesssly, keep only the essentials. But the description really could use some help.
I loved the scene with the candles, it seemed like the crux of the story. And honestly, I have no idea why you didn't just start this story at that point. Everything moves along nicely enough, but I think whatever point you were reaching for or trying to make ended up being buried in a pretty shallow ending at the, well, end. I don't say this to sound harsh, by any means. But what I mean is that the ending was sort of ho-hum. Remember that story is about conflict, and in real life things are always messy and emotional when it comes to conflict. I think you've brushed the surface here, but haven't really delved into or grappled with your subject. Maybe you needed to identify a subject, I don't know.
That all being said, this isn't bad. You did have a few lines of great imagery in there, and the piece flowed nicely. It was believable. The only two technical things I would have suggested is to leave out the date "2012" and only keep the most pertinent/relevant lines of "Silent Night" in there, as it's rather clunky otherwise.
Great job, keep writing!
~ED
Hi, Gravity! It's me again (I know, you can't get rid of me, right? Lol). I just wanted to let you know that once I realized you could and did tweak this story (I also misread the rules, so don't worry about that), I reread it to see what you changed. This is great! Without the repetitiveness, the story flows much better. I'm very impressed. Nice work!
Thinks Lulu, you rock
Hey, defying.
This part irked me. If someone loves something unconditionally it means no matter what. But she made a provision: promise you don't get drunk on Christmas, and I'll love you still. That's not right. And really, who wouldn't want to get drunk on Christmas? It's a celebration.Here is my honest opinion. It's filled with good intentions.
Honestly, I had trouble getting through it. It didn't hold my interest, especially through the middle part. It was boring.
The issue was not the plot, but the detail. Usually, I'm all for detail. But here, you need to think of what is needed and what is not. While a description of the outfit and the car that the mother drives might tell us something about the character, this is not a character driven story. You don't need all the descriptions before getting to the church.
I like the description of the candles. Pretty. It's needed for the plot, as well. I think you can cut everything up until that point (in the flashback). I read some of the other comments that say you can't edit after you post for the contest, but you should always be working on everything. You might need it again someday.
I don't think you needed to include all of the lyrics to "Silent Night." A bit is lovely, a stanza or so, but all those verses aren't really needed.
Another thing: your eyes don't get red from drinking. Your cheeks can get red, but your eyes? That's something else that makes your eyes red.
The end gets a little sappy. Don't get sappy. Avoid sap at all costs.
Don't ever put "Fin" or "The End" or in this case, "FINIS" at the end of anything. If it stops, it's the end. I don't need something to tell me it's the end.
Remember to show and not tell. If you're going to describe something, don't tell the reader. Show us. This line is unneeded, and you should take it out, but I'm going to use it as an example. That's telling. Show us. Try something like this: While it doesn't tell us everything about the room (we don't need to know in this case anyway), it does add a bit of description that might tell us a little about the character.
I hope that this review was helpful to you. Happy writing, and happy Christmas.
I appreciate your criticisms, your opinion is your opinion and in some places I can see where you're coming from. Thank you.
Hiya, Gravity. Lucrezia here to review.
I'm very mad at you because this is quite good and I'm planning on entering this contest, as well. XD
Anyway, you did a great job. I'm pretty sure the rules said you can't edit after submitting, but I'll point out a few nitpicks anyway.
This is a bit repetitive.
This didn't flow right for me. Too many "after"s. I would change it to, "She had given up on dresses when she gained weight, after I was born." Or something like that.
Again, this feels sort of repetitive.
Same reasons. I would change it to, "There were sixteen stairs total. I remember counting them as I went." Or you could change it to "steps" instead.
I don't think there should be an exclamation point at the end of "Holy Night." It just doesn't look right to me.
Anyway, other than that, good job on this! I think you should work on making sure you don't repeat yourself, but that's my only advice.
Yeah the punctuation on the song was out of my control. That's how the song is written. As for the repetition, I'm smacking myself for that. I'm sure you could write a short story for this contest much better than I could. Don't hate me! :p lol. Thanks again for the review
Actually I just finished my second draft yesterday and it was pretty terrible. XD And don't smack yourself! The repetitiveness wasn't that awful, and it's really not too big a deal.
As a whole, this story was quite good.
Thanks. If you want to PM me the short story, I could give you some pointers if you'd like. I'm at home sick so God knows I have plenty of time. Plus I have 8 papers I have to write for school due at the end of Christmas break, I could use a distraction.
Thanks. If you want to PM me the short story, I could give you some pointers if you'd like. I'm at home sick so God knows I have plenty of time. Plus I have 8 papers I have to write for school due at the end of Christmas break, I could use a distraction.
Sorry! I only just got this message. That's so nice of you to offer and I would've taken you up on it, but I've already rewrote and submitted it now. Of course you're still welcome to check it out and let me know what you think! I posted the link on the contest's page.
Hello,
You have good content here, that's for sure. The holiday-misery stuff, if executed well, can be very moving and touching.
I'm not a fan of the first line. It isn't powerful enough for me, doesn't pull me in. When you say "Christmas of 2012", after that, it just tells me facts.
You can write: I'm sitting on the steps at the top of the stairs. I can hear Mom yelling at dad; It's Christmas. or something like that. This way it is more powerful. You can bury in the 2012 detail later in the story. I think you should "my" before mom because you don't really need it. It's unnecessary. Always remember to omit unnecessary words.
This is very good stuff. I really like this part. The content is powerful. I love the wording. I love it because i can hear the narrator's inner thought processes.
Here it gets sentimental. You don't want anything to get sentimental. Especially a story that is sad. Because sentimentality will ruin it.
What you're basically doping in these lines is you are preparing yourself for the flashback. You don't have to do that. The reader gets when he is given a flashback. Information is okay. But too much information make it look like you are deliberately letting the reader know there will be a flashback.
You can edit the whole story like this.
You have a talent for the narrative. The narrator is a good character and I think you fleshed it well. If you edit this little prob out, then your story will be golden.
Bye.
This story has reminded me so much of what Christmas is about - family. The writing was wonderfully done, and you have so much lovely details.
[With each line, I could hear other more lovely notes resonating from the congregations voice. Everybody's voices joined together as one, even my childish sound. As the song continued, I looked around the church. All I could see were the flickering lights of the candles. I grasped my Momma's hand and continued to sing.]
In here, you did a very good job of connecting the lyrics of the songs together fluently.
At the beginning of the story, you set up the setting very well, as well as the mood. I can see that she didn't have a dad, or asked for a dad for a long time, and has been quite ecstatic about it when she finally got a dad. But he gets drunk quite often. That scenario can actually happen in real life, and probably is happening a lot in our world. The story is very realistic. Although, in here, you might want to fix the past tense 'heard' to hear.
[As I lay awake in bed, recalling that memory I heard my Mom's door slam shut downstairs. ]
It is a common mistake to make, don't worry - it is a very, very, very minor mistake. I once wrote a whole chapter in past tense, but the book was in present tense, so I had to rewrite the whole thing!
I had so much fun reading this wonderful short story before Christmas! Thank you for writing such a good story.
Merry Christmas!