Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there!
When first reading the prologue, I thought this would be a retelling of Snow White. But I quickly see that it's not and that's fine. It's a nice start.
77 suitors? 77 suitors? Dang, Aurora, you are working it, haha.
For some reason the semicolon here makes me uncomfortable! I don't know why! Perhaps you can change it to a colon, so that it can be "Announcing: Her Royal Highness, Crown . . ." But you don't have to, just because it makes me uncomfortable. Just a suggestion.
Okay. I'm not quoting this because there's anything wrong with it. I'm quoting this because after reading it in the story, I was like, "WAHTTTTT!!!?1?!?122!21?!" No one would win? What was the use of all this then? Amusement? I know the summary says something about selfish parents, so maybe this 77 Suitor Business is their idea, and Aurora's just going along with it. Hm. Interesting. I like how you made me stop and think. I like, I like.
I find it odd picturing someone in a fancy shmancy dress jogging to--anywhere. Maybe change the word "jog" to "hurry" or something of this sort. "Jog" doesn't seem like the right word here. To me, at least! So maybe it can be: "I look around and see no one, so I gather my skirts as I hurry to my chambers to change into more appropriate attire."
I would point out the grammatical issues but JohnLocke1 and Birkhoff already did a wonderful job doing it, so I won't repeat them. I will say that I enjoyed this. More than I thought I would. I was surprised to find it as polished as it was. Yes, there were mistakes, but there were only a few. So good job there! I'm interested to learn more about Aurora and her world. I think you did an awesome job and I can't wait to see what's next! Nicely done.
-Comrie
Hey Aurora!
First off, welcome to YWS! I hope you enjoy yourself here.
Now, writing in 1st person is something quite tricky to do and I'd like to see it more on the site. This is probably what I enjoyed most about this piece, as it enables the reader to get more intimate with your main character, which so far seems to have a solid personality.
However, your piece still needs some work, and there are even problems that present itself as you write in 1st person.
I'll comment as I read:
As I said, writing in 1st person presented some problems here. Depending on how complex your story is, pulling the reader into that world and having them understand everything about it is very hard to do in 1st person. Unless you have your main character spew out a bunch of expositions, which you generally don't want to do.
It is not impossible though. For example, you can have several viewpoint characters. Characters that can reveal information your main character couldn't, or wouldn't. Maybe consider putting another POW character into the mix.
The reasoning behind a prologue is by letting the reader know things that they won't pick up naturally in the story itself. So in your case, if you want, you could fill the reader in on the world of Archaea, it's history and key characters.
Whoa, quite the name. Can I call her Kate?
Good word. I had to look it up.
Edit
If they are only nearly audible, how can she hear them?
Edit
You have a lot of unneeded padding. Some places you describe too much and other you need to describe more.
Edit
You know, these names and titles are starting to grow on me. I like characters like this. It gives them some character before you even know them. Feels like I'm in the world of Frank Herbert's "Dune".
This is a good example of some ok exposition. Small info dump that feels somewhat natural to her thoughts. You forgot a period at the end though.
This is something you could include in a prologue. These dimensions are mentioned several times thoughout the story, yet we have no idea what they are.
Edit
When I got to this part, I got a bit unsure. What sort of time period is this? As I read everything up to this point, I pictured an old setting. A sword and sorcery setting. You even mentioned she had a sword earlier, but now there's a wall clock involved.
Edit
And so far, that's it. It's a decent first chapter, thought it's extremely short to be considered a chapter. But posting here, and maybe continuing it as "chapter 1, part 1, 2 etc" is great.
Your letter format is also a bit big, it looks better when it's one notch lower.
As for your writing, it's pretty good. You use a good and varied vocabulary, good grammar and your paragraphs never open the same, or in a boring way. The dialogue is good, the main characters narration is smooth and you got lots of imagination.
At your age, this is great. And after just a short time on YWS, it's only going to get better. If I myself had begun at such a young age, I would be much further along in my writing. Keep it up!
Cheers
Birkhoff
Hello, my friend.
First, might I say that I respect you for writing in the present. I detest it myself, for I do not have the ability to write in the present without great effort. However, you seem to have an affinity for it. Therefore, I applaud you and your fantastic writing prowess.
Second, a few grammatical things:
This was a bit of a run-on sentence. Use those period! Perhaps, "... that accentuates my waste. That was most likely my mother's decision."
An unneeded word, "...down the stairs off the dais..."
Did you mean, "...my room and the..."
Third, some stylistic suggestions:
Actually, I do not have anything to say about your style. It suits your piece nicely.
Fourth, your characters.
I think you have crafted your protagonist well. You balance exposition about the world that you have crafted with insight into her mind. If I might suggestion, you could add a bit more of her own thoughts. If only to show more of her character for the reader. It is only a suggestion.
Fifth, plot.
If I had one critique of this story that I would want you to remember, it is that of how weak your world is in its current state. Although this is the first chapter, you have presented it in a way wherein you could add more detail about your world. Dimensions? Countries? How are these courtiers arriving from different dimensions? A bit of explanation will allow a reader to feel more a part of the story, which is why they will continue reading.
Overall, you have a very promising start. Build your world, strengthen your characters and add a bit of detail, and you will have a fantastic story. Keep me posted. I would love to read more. Happy Writing!
Hello JohnLocke1! Thank you for your review!!! I wasn't quite sure how to tell more about her world without having her narrate something she wouldn't naturally. I still have no idea how to do this
. I also didn't realize that Aurora doesn't 'think' much in this first chapter, and I thank you for that piece of your review. Thank you for the complements about my style and 'my affinity for writing in the present tense.' I will add though, if I thought I could make this flow in past tense, I would.
Thank you!
Evilly,
Aura
It was a great read, my friend!