*removed*
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Thanks for the great critiques, you lot! I love you all! I'll edit as soon as I ever can.
It's so nice to be back...or have I said that before?
~MademoiselleKool
Whizz-whizz, sir! Wings be back!
Apart from the delay in updates *glares meaningfully at Mademoiselle* this was very good, and I'm glad you added the little note up the top. This has been gone so long, I'd almost forgotten what had been happening.
Just a few things:
Slightly awkward. Maybe, "He pulled some papers out of the pouch as he ran"?
Maybe just, "He reached the clearing and stood panting, looking around him"?
I'm not sure how to change this, but the repetition is too much.
I'd change these to words less flowery. They come off as rather pompous. Maybe, "The king must be expecting great danger to the forest, if he was ordering all creatures to leave."
Nitpick: too many "and"s.
Cat just mentioned this, wouldn't that have reminded him?
Complement = compliment
I know it shouldn't have, but I found this amusing. It's like Dominic's a school kid who's messing around in Mariamne's garden.
And ditto to Kitty's comments.
Very good, and I'm intrigued as to what's going to happen next, and what's happening with Brad and Kiera. *meaningful nudge*
Keep writing!
Yay for more Mercenary Wings! An excellent chapter my dear. I'm loving the character of Lane but starting to wonder if I'm so fond of the king. He seems rash and quick to anger. Brisk and commanding. He seems quite a lot like the other king but then, that's not a bad thing. Merely an observation.
Your dialogue is lovely as ever and I think Seden and Annie would make a brilliant couple! Though perhaps he will end up with Cat? Or neither? Either way, they're all fantastic characters. I think that's probably your greatest strength - you manage to make your characters flawed just enough that they're completely perfect!
More description could still be added in places. Like with the meadow. I think you could add just a little more detail there and great job with that by the way. Hmmm. That reminds me. I think I'm starting to dislike Mariamne a touch too. She's a very well developed character and I'm starting to think her priorities are a little out of place.
The speed of the nitewalkers is well portrayed but perhaps emphasised a little too much? Maybe take out a sentence or two on that; there's no need to keep reminding your reader that they're fast.
Also, I like how Annie is developing. She seems to show a touch more emotion now and I get the impression that recent events and people have effected her more than she let's on. Certainly an interesting character.
Anyway, general observations finished and here's two small, specific suggestions -
"Let's off to the castle." [This seems a little fragmented which doesn't feel right with the character of Mother. So maybe 'Let's be off to the castle." would work better?]
It seemed like a moment [This is too vague. A moment? That could be any length of time. You need to use a short moment or something, just to clarify.] from the time they had started walking to when they reached the end of the forest and looked down the meadow towards the castle.
Other than that, it was perfect. One of my favourite chapters so far I believe. Keep up the good work, maybe try to vary your sentence lengths a bit more so that you have shorter sentences when Seden first spots Lane - turn it into a bit of an action scene? Don't go straight from possible foe to friend perhaps? - but generally very well written. Good work and Merry Christmas. Talk to you soon,
Heather xx