*removed*
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
125,020 Literary Works • 672,731 Reviews
You have a good sense of what the world is supposed to look like, which makes it far easier to read, but in several instances you began reusing words you'd already utilized in the same sentences. It's not a huge error, and it's not going to be detrimental to your story, but eliminating it can make your words flow far better.
The use of traditional, let's say, Earth-based names threw me off. Perhaps this is based on fantastical circumstances on Earth, in which case this is fine, but if it's not, it can become awkward.
I loved the bit about the smell of death; it was awesome.
Again, nice chapter. The only troubles I really saw here were that Brad's dialogue, specifically, still seems to be missing something. As it is, he's sort of the sensitive, goody-goody guy, and that's the only facet of his character that we really see in his conversations. I would suggest trying to round him out just a teeny bit more so that we get a better look at his character.
Almost every sentence there starts with "he", so I would suggest perhaps mixing up the structure a little.
Who is he talking to here? It makes an odd sentence - first he's speaking in first person, then he's addressing himself? I don't really understand.
I don't think you need to cut *both* words, but maybe one of them. When I string off obscenities, those two usually don't come out of my mouth in succession.
How does one fly angrily? I think showing vs. telling would be better here.
I really like this part. It's very, very telling. I'm not sure if the part that starts "Then louder" is really a sentence, but I see where you're going. This is my favorite "Brad moment" so far.
The phrases aren't identical, but you have the words "fall/fell" and "ground" repeated in successive sentences.
I think this sounds a little awkward; I really have no idea how to explain what I'm trying to say in terms of English. If it were Latin, I'd say that it reads like a result clause rather than a purpose clause... I don't think that made any sense, but hopefully you know what I mean? I think what you're trying to say is that he went into the forest in order to avoid the smell of the rotting dragon carcasses, but the "that" doesn't really do the job on its own.
This is another one of those places where the dialogue sounds a touch unnatural to me. I think it's because it's a long chunk of text with absolutely no breaks. In real life, this rarely happens unless someone's making a speech or telling a story. It's perhaps even rarer in fiction.
I don't really have anything to point out in the second part. I must say, I'm a bit jealous - your storytelling is so solid! And did I catch Dominic checking out Val? Can't wait to see where that will go...
I like how 'like shadow twit said' expressed brads anger, and the language, kinda falls into the scene for me, i deffinatly see myself screaming my head off if that had happened to me!
KEEP IT COMING!!
Great job describing Brad's anger, though, yes, the bad laguage was off-putting. But his emotions were put down well.
Although I'd make his speech in the woods thoughts, as when you're alone, you don't really say the obvious to yourself, ime.
Things are coming a long! Brad was left and he and Whiperba have met (I knew it would happen).
You might try to reword this. It sounds kind of cheese and a bit awkward.
I agree with Pol, cut the swearing, it doesn't really help the story. Describe his anger more; mabye adding some reminence on all the time the group has been together, making the reader sad and angry. Try to make the reader get into it.
Ahh...that's all I can think of. Goodjob and write on!
-Jay of the Green robes
First of all,
. I feel so bad for poor Brad. (Ryhm not intended). It was so uncool of his friends to totally abandon him like that. Oh well, just another day in the mercenaries life, eh? (Not Canadian) Uh... Well I like how you expressed the coldness of betrayl first then his stoked anger, which was needed. But, uh... Just a tad bit to much swearing.
Anyway, uh... When the spirit of the forest comes to Brad and gripped his throat, you said throat twice and even that gets pretty repedative.
Just knock off the last insult. *coughs for no apperent reason*
Another thing I noticed, I think Its really impossible to land on a branch of a pnie tree. If I'm wrong thats okay but I've tried it before and it deosn't work out very well.
So the way I usaully do it is replace a "throat" with a "neck" or something. Two words same meaning. Also, I would describe the fear Brad gets from the forest spirit when a misty knife suddenly apears. That scared the crap out of me so...
Also, when Val and Erik meet with the dude. Make it a bit shorter so it seems kinda blunt. Like one of thaso fast sceane enders in a movie. Just a thought. Also, explain how exactly does Brad get carried away by the spirit thingy? I like how you described it as warm when carring him away but mabye describe it as cold at first, like anger or hatred.
Wow, that was really long. Ha ha, stealing everyone elses thunder. (Its what I do best) Anyway... Yea.
~Pol [/quote]
Ah... Poor Brad. I didn't expect him to link up with Whiperba though. I can definately see them both going something to try and stop the Mercenaries. This is coming along nicely but the ending where it focuses on Dominic and the othersis a bit short. Still good, but short.
Hope this helped.
~ Shadowsun
I think that the beginning, Brad's discovery, is a touch long and repetitive. Maybe delete some of his thoughts. Other than that though, you have good characterisation and I like your descriptions. Just a few specific points to make -
Just because I have morals, just because I don't want to get myself killed in a stupid war
Brad looked down and watched a solitary tear fall down, [I think 'fall through the air' or 'fall to the ground' would sound better here because you've already used the word down in the sentence.] catching the morning sunlight inside so that it sparkled like a diamond.
His voice sounded tired and depressed, even to his own ears.