i wonder if we came from the same star-
from the same dust that once floated through space
and by chance managed to find itself on this
lonely planet.
i wonder if it makes us search for specks of ourselves
in each other, or if we’re meant to cling to
different bits of the universe that are just as lost as we are.
as if begging to be whole again
we’ll scour through every bit of one another and
pick out everything that feels familiar.
i know i’m not one for talking much but if
hugs and kisses are your love language then
i’d love to have a conversation.
we can be two stars stuck in spiral-
breaking each other apart slowly yet still
unable to pull away.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi veeren, I am Buranko for a quick review (though I have no idea if it will be quick or long). I don't like long introductions so here we go.
I want to start by saying I'm a huge fan of including elements belonging to the sphere of the universe. The beginning of your poem is really good because of you presenting the elements that go into making and possibly poetically explain love as a whole. I prefer poems that are a little more vague but can definitely appreciate one that is more on the explaining side.
Completing the idea from before that lovers belong to the same star introduce the idea that the lovers gravitate one to another and make the star complete once again. Moreover, explaining the concept in the previous line you say that the lovers "pick out everything that feels familiar.". I didn't really like this addition because it feels pretty out of place, conflicting the introductory idea that lovers belong to the same star. If they belong to the same star why would they need to pick specifically something familiar, won't they already feel familiar one in another. But, leaving that aside, I love how you added the notion of language in it. This branches in more interpretations, one that you said " i’m not one for talking much ", implying the need to communicate in one way or another, or the other that I like as much which removes any border, any limit, anything in the way of love, even the language barrier, making love the universal language, expressed through hugs and kisses.
The last stanza doesn't really make sense. I can see you tried to make the lovers individually stand by themselves as two stars but why introduce the idea of a mother star for both of them only to scrap it and make it two stars. You could have tried to make it seem they combine one with another by breaking and being pulled into one mix. That yet is out of place as well.
And when trying to explain stuff you kind of overdid it and made the lines a little too crowded and heavy.
Of course my ideas and critiques are mine and what you decide to do, listen to them or not is completely up to you. I may have missed some important factors when reviewing. If I did it please forgive me for the mistakes and would be grateful if you could explain where it happened. Great poem nevertheless
thank you for your comments <3 as is all poetry it is open to interpretation and the value you take from it is your own. i appreciate you reading through and commenting!
Love this work! Hope to see more from ya!
thank you !: )
Hello! My name is Via and I'm here for a review! So let's started.
POSITIVES:
First and foremost, I love this poem! It's very descriptive and concise when it comes to the theme and mood. I can tell that this poem was edited very well because I couldn't find anything that clouded up the themes and the poem itself. Everything was very clear and to the point. The small little narrative you came up with is truly impeccable! I have to say this is one of the best poems I've seen on this forum.
Your writing style is very lyrical, and I could easily see this poem being recited in a competition like Poetry Out Loud. The use of the lack of capitalization seems to be intentional. I'm all for the use of grammatical lack of structure to add aesthetic depth. I truly think it works here and is not overkill.
My favorite lines in particular were
Your metaphors and figurative language are very well thought out and descriptive. Everything seems to fit seamlessly for the overall narrative. I love love LOVE the romantic and whimsical aspect of it. Usually romantic poems of this manner can occasionally come off as cheesy, but this one is well worth the read. Oh and thank you for using punctuation. Without periods and commas, this poem wouldn't be as good.
Rhythm wise, you seem to have a knack for keeping it consistent, which is an impressive skill for any kind of poet.
CRITIQUES:
I don't really have anything negative to say about this poem, which is a first for this forum.
The only ones I really have are the following
1. In the two of the lines you utilize the word, "wonder." I honestly think that this repetition doesn't necessarily need to the be there. You can easily find a synonym that equals the meaning of the word. Of course, the rhythm has to be taken into consideration. It's up to you really, it's just a thought.
2. I think that the lines in the beginning
Rhythm wise, I think it would be better if the word this would be on the same line as "lonely planet." I just think it sounds better on the tongue.
Overall, truly amazing artistry and work! I would actually love for you to critique my work since you have a much more developed style than me. You're very talented and experienced.
I appreciate you taking the time to read everything and comment on it <3
the repetition of the phrase "I wonder if" is intentional but as far as the rhythm I can definitely take a second look. thank you for your advice!
@veereen You're welcome. You're are without a doubt very very talented.
This poem is lovely!! Extended metaphors are, in my humble opinion, the VERY BEST literary devices, and this poem did it perfectly!! You've created a small story, a comfortable and beautiful love in your words. Your writing style is gorgeous, and every single line in this is intentional and adds to the beauty of the poem. You've managed to weave together several threads and trains of thought into one story and it's absolutely lovely. Great poem!!
thank you for reading and for your kind words <3