Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Review part two!
This chapter seems to be a contrast to chapter one. There are several characters introduced at once, and a lot of names mentioned, which makes it harder to really get to know the characters.
I did like the overall style, like the difference between talking with the pack in italics and talking aloud. It's interesting, and a nice change to normal dialogue.
The only critisism I can offer for this is to introduce the characters one by one. Maybe you could exaggerate their personalities for the time being to emphesise them, at least until your reader is familiar with them.
Heya again
Here to review as requested! You know the drill...
Overall
Just like the first chapter, I very much enjoyed reading this chapter. Your descriptions were once again very nice and very vivid. You definitely created some nice imagery, especially at the beginning. Thankfully, this is clearly becoming less cliché now. There's still the little point about the wolves reading each other's thoughts, but I don't really mind that. Your grammar was pretty good, it was especially good at the beginning of the chapter. The discussion between your characters was rather amusing as well, even if it was kind of clumpy. Also, this chapter was a lot less confusing than the previous chapter I read and the spelling was once again perfect. Well done for that!
My main critique here is probably about the discussion between your wolves, actually. Like I've already mentioned, your dialogue and your discussions are a bit on the clumpy side. The main problem with dialogue/discussion dumps is the fact that it can get on the readers nerves a bit. It can also be very annoying and disrupts the flow of a story. You'd actually be surprised to the amount of readers that will stop reading something because of dialogue/discussion dumps. This is a very easy problem to solve though, as long as you keep in mind what you need to do. Whenever you're writing dialogue or are writing a discussion, remember to include the odd snippet of action or description in between. Don't write an entire essay in between the discussion though, that would annoy the reader even more. Like I just said, sprinkles of action or description is best. That way, it will keep your readers interested and it won't get on their nerves either.
My only other critique is actually the same as the other one in your previous chapter. I think that the ending of this wasn't as good as the beginning! Although this time, it was more of a grammar issue than the concept of the story itself. As you might have noticed, I pointed out a lot more grammar mistakes in the second half as this compared to the first half. I'm thinking that you might get so 'into' your story as you're writing it, you begin to forget about making sure that you are using the correct grammar. To be honest with you, that's fine. As long as you make sure you check over the grammar once you've finished writing the chapter. Simply to make sure you haven't done any silly mistakes. I know that you can recognise where grammar marks should and shouldn't be because in the first half, you've used your grammar very well! All that you need to do is to make sure that you check over your work, especially before you post it here on YWS.
They are the only real critiques I have for you. Overall, I really did enjoy reading this. I especially liked how you seem to have introduced some evil wolves! I love evil characters, I'm weird like that.
Keep writing and good luck with this!
xoxo Skins