‘To thine own self
be true,’ they say, but for me, that was a battle against the weight of my last
name. As the streets of Elysian Shores bustled with ambition, I stood at my
dorm window, frozen. In the distance, I saw the ocean roaring back and forth, a
lone sparrow soaring effortlessly above, and a building sprawled with the name
Winslow in gold letters. As I stared at the word, my eyes threatened to roll
out of my head. Students rushed across the courtyard near the building. People,
with their phones, backpacks, and briefcases, exuded a sense of direction and
purpose. Then there was me, Abigail Winslow.
After finishing my
classes, I walked to the art building, through the halls, and entered the
studio. In the large room, students sat in sectioned-off spaces, consumed by
their individual projects. Soft brushes caressed canvases, pottery wheels spun
with a steady hum, and the gentle scratching of pencils on paper created a
symphony of artistic sounds in the room.
I walked to my
designated space, my secret sanctuary, which I have had since I was a freshman.
The area had a window with a stunning view of the campus garden, a wooden table
nearby, some storage shelves, and a large easel. The shelves and tables were a jumble
of sketchbooks and paintings. I had the freedom to be whoever I wanted in this
space, without needing to perform for anyone.
As I began painting,
my hands took over in instinctual movement. With each brush stroke, my mind
quieted. The canvas transformed into tones of light and dark. Cobalt blues
blended seamlessly with cadmium yellows, creating a dynamic composition of
abstract radiance. As the lines and exaggerations swirled and morphed, each
accent and gradation became an unspoken phrase in my artistic dialogue with the
world. The canvas turned into an azure butterfly fleeing toward a ray of golden
sunshine.
My paintbrush
swirled in a cup of water, cleansing the colors like purging intrusive
thoughts. I meticulously wiped it dry on a paper towel; each stroke aimed to
dissipate the dread building in me. But as I glided it up and down, black
seeped through, as dark as the doom of my impending meeting with my
father.
Typically, time
faded into a distant memory when I painted. However, I couldn't help but notice
the hours slipping away this time. The sun started its descent, slowly casting
long shadows across my canvas, and I reluctantly cleaned up my workspace. Apprehension
grew in the pit of my stomach, setting my nerves in overdrive. Wish as I may, I
could not avoid talking to him.
A large iron gate
allowed me entry when I arrived. Our mansion had stood for generations, a
testament to our family’s wealth and influence in Elysian Shores. Doric columns
stood tall in front of the two-story colonial. As a child, this house was a
treasure trove of wonder and adventure. But as an adult, it transformed into a
symbol of confinement instead of comfort, like a prison with strict rules that
dictated my every action and behavior.
Inside, the
atmosphere was cold and formal. The servants rushed to their duties with
precision. My boots clacked on the marble floors, echoing through the halls as
I went to my father’s study.
I took a deep breath
when I approached the ornate double doors, mentally preparing myself. I knocked
softly, and a voice as hard as granite beckoned me to enter. My father, a
commanding centerpiece, sat behind his massive mahogany desk. His face, engraved
with the wisdom of age and the weight of authority, regarded me with an
unwavering scrutiny that carved into the very marrow of my being. His office,
polished with sepia bookcases and austere leather furnishings, bore testament
to his power. With his phone resting on his shoulder, he nodded and pointed at
a chair opposite him. I sat, and the chair’s leather upholstery was cool as I
rubbed my hands back and forth.
“We have
competition, but this buy is a must-have. Listen, let me call you back.” He
ended the call with the touch of his phone. “There’s my girl!”
As he said this, my
posture grew tall. Despite my anxiety, my expression remained calm and
stoic.
“As you know,
our family companies have been the foundation of our success for generations.”
Suppressing the urge
to roll my eyes, my fingers lightly traced the edge of a paper on his desk. I
nodded hesitantly.
He leaned back with
his fingers steepled in front of him. “As you approach graduation, thinking
about the future is important. I expect that you step into a leadership role
like your sister. There is a wide range of options currently, especially in the
real estate market.
I focused on
breathing, trying to calm the burning sensation. I longed to show my talent
freely. It yearned to shine under the spotlight of an admiring audience.
“Father, I
appreciate the opportunities you’ve given me, but—”
“You’re part of a
lineage that has worked tirelessly to build what we have today. Being added to
that line and carrying on the legacy is truly an honor. Never take that for
granted.”
A pang of guilt
washed over me. I had everything I wanted and was aware of our family’s
privilege. However, I had never been happy and could no longer prioritize
others. I gathered my courage and tried to speak again.
“I know the honor
that carries, but I have been thinking...”
He tilted his head.
“Go on.”
My hands clasped
together tightly in my lap. “Well… I find deep fulfillment in painting. It’s
something that I have loved since I was little… and well–”
“What will painting
get you?”
“Art is where I
express myself and connect with the world.”
He leaned forward,
his eyes locking onto mine. “It's not a profession, just a hobby. That will not
sustain your life or our fortune. It would be best if you didn’t underestimate
the responsibility that comes with our name. Your great-grandparents started
our success, your grandparents furthered it, and your mother and I have made it
bigger than ever. Your sister has taken her place, and now it’s your turn.”
“Our legacy hangs
over my head like an anvil every single day. Is it wrong to want to pursue something
of my own? What is terrible about something that makes me happy?”
With a sigh, he
examined me closely, his face betraying no hint of his thoughts. “I want you to
be happy, but you were born into this. Your future lies within our business.
It’s about carrying the torch on.”
I lowered my gaze,
looking at my hands in my lap. My fingers twiddled back and forth as I realized
I would not win this argument. He clarified his views on this when I wanted to
take painting classes as a child, and he refused to pay for them. I put my hands
on the desk, feeling defeated.
His hands reached
across, resting on mine. Although his touch should offer comfort, his coarse
fingers rubbed against mine. “I only want what’s best for you. I believe you
can accomplish great things. Remember, you are a Winslow. I expect you to act
accordingly.”
He leaned back in
his chair, waiting for my reply. I opened my mouth for a moment but couldn’t
find words. Glancing around the room, I tried to find something tangible to
reach him. There had to be artwork somewhere. The walls were full of newspaper
pages featuring articles about expansions, Winslow education acquisitions, and
photos of when my father was on Forbes’ lists. Among the many frames, there was
not a single piece of art.
My eyes met his, and
their frosty blue sought my agreement. His sleek, peppered-gray hair did not
have a strand out of place. A Rolex rested on his wrist, one of many he owned.
He prioritized being the best dressed person in the room. People around him were
required to live up to his high expectations. He encouraged me and my sister’s
talents, but only when they fit into the confinement of what it meant to be a
Winslow. Growing up had been like walking a tightrope, weighted by balancing
his demands while longing to be free of them. I had never dared to step off
that line or defy him. He considered it a betrayal to deviate from his plans,
as it went against everything he took pride in.
I nodded, giving him
the illusion of compliance. His phone rang, and he glanced at it.
“I need to take
this. We will discuss this further another time.” He touched his phone, put it
to his ear, and dived back into the conversation I had interrupted.
Taking my cue to
leave, I stood, my steps retracing my way out. The drive back to my dorm
matched my thoughts. Roads seemed to twist like my tangled emotions. As a
little girl, I actively sought approval, desperate for praise, especially my
father’s. I now found that his love was conditional and contingent on living
vicariously through me.
First impressions of this beginning is that I feel like it's a tad bit weaker than the prologue in my opinion. However, it's still good! I do like it ^^ it just doesn't feel as impactful as the prologue.
‘To thine own self be true,’ they say, but for me, that was a battle against the weight of my last name. As the streets of Elysian Shores bustled with ambition, I stood at my dorm window, frozen. In the distance, I saw the ocean roaring back and forth, a lone sparrow soaring effortlessly above, and a building sprawled with the name Winslow in gold letters. As I stared at the word, my eyes threatened to roll out of my head. Students rushed across the courtyard near the building. People, with their phones, backpacks, and briefcases, exuded a sense of direction and purpose. Then there was me, Abigail Winslow.
I think a part that's keeping me from feeling great about this beginning is the amount of visual scenery that we're chewing through here on the first paragraph for the sake of providing exposition.
I have two suggestions here: one -- to separate the paragraph a bit. Make a new paragraph starting at "Students rushed...", and two -- I think you could add some action to Abigail here, specifically on the second paragraph. Maybe more about how she was frozen or how dramatically she stood out from the busy people in the streets. Just an example but he could like close her curtains to remove the name from her field of view.
Among the many frames, there was not a single piece of art.
I love this distinction here, and how cool would it be if this was permeating throughout the entire scenery of the mansion and her father's aura/buildings in general.
Overall, your writing is great. You know exactly how to write in details and descriptions with imagery. There's a bit of sensory details here as well with the fidgeting that Abigail does. You're a great writer and it's obvious you have either been writing on this piece for awhile (maybe through multiple drafts) or you have a clear vision of what you wanted and the writing reflects that extremely well.
I think my biggest critique of this part is probably going to be the conversation between Abigail and her father. I think it's too on the nose. The conversation would have so much more weight if it was what they weren't saying to each other that was conveyed, or that Abigail/her father didn't reveal their true intentions with their conversations. Oftentimes as writers we tend to craft dialogue to serve the purpose of pushing forward the story we want to tell, but a great and real detail of communication is just how often it fails to convey exactly what we want, as people and as writers.
I think we get that Abigail likes drawing and art from the first part of this scene so the second part is retreading ground which makes the impact hit not as hard.
But, gosh, what a compelling story and so well written! I really only have nitpicks so far which is the sign of a good piece.
Hello, fellow author! Happy Review Day! Today, I’ll be using the Review Monster! (Don’t worry, he’s actually very friendly!) This review template is inspired by the wonderful YWS S'more Method! Let’s take a look, shall we?
The Glowing Eyes: First Impressions!
I went back to read the prologue before this, and I must say, this story intrigues me! Right off the bat, we're introduced to the protagonist's struggles. Abigail wants to chase her dreams, but she is held back by her family obligations, and possibly her own mind. She is hindered by anxious thoughts, and, from the prologue, we can infer that she went through an abusive or toxic relationship.
The Fluffy Fur: Things I Loved!
I absolutely adore your writing style! Your descriptions are captivating, and they sound like poetry! You balance this well with the plot of the story, too. There was never a spot in the chapter where I felt it dragged on. Finding balance with detailed writing can be tricky, but I think you nailed it!
I especially liked the painting scene, just because I thought the descriptions were so beautiful. Your writing is captivating!
The Roar: Favorite Lines!
Cobalt blues blended seamlessly with cadmium yellows, creating a dynamic composition of abstract radiance.
Again, I just absolutely love your writing style. This sentence was so elegant and sounded like sunshine. It is such a serene moment, reflecting how calming our true passions can be.
As a child, this house was a treasure trove of wonder and adventure. But as an adult, it transformed into a symbol of confinement instead of comfort
This line not only gives us some background information, but it is also beautifully written! It shows how much Abigail's views have changed, and also gives us hints about her childhood.
The Sharp, Yellow Teeth: Improvements!
One part I was confused by was the correlation between the prologue and chapter one. While I could tell that it was the same protagonist and same author, the two felt very different. Now, I understand prologues sometimes tend to be like this, but establishing that right away might help with that initial thought of, "Hold on, what are we talking about now?" I also am wondering when exactly the prologue takes place, and how it relates to chapter one. Did the prologue happen before or after chapter one? Was there a time skip?
If this part is meant to be mysterious, then I think you nailed it! But I also think that it can be slightly disorienting for the readers. But remember, these are just my interpretations. You are the author, after all, so take and leave what you please!
Stomping Away: Closing Thoughts!
Overall, this was a beautiful chapter that set the mood for Abigail's relationship with her father. We can assume that this will be a further issue that the protagonist will need to explore. With elegant writing and unique figurative language, you hooked me right away!
Hello friend! I saw your work in the Green Room and figured I’d check it out.
Per my interpretation, this was a phenomenal start to a novel! It had captivating detail and introduced a central conflict.
It follows the story of a young woman, Abigail Winslow, who has aspirations of being a painter but also has to live up to the family business.
This seems like an amazing foundation for a really good book! Also, from reading this, it feels like this novel is going to have a wonderful overall theme.
If I could offer any sort of advice, I wouldn't offer anything to extraordinary! This was really good, and I couldn't find much of anything wrong with it!
But there was one small thing that confused me a little when you said,
With a sigh, he examined me closely, his face betraying no hint of his thoughts.
This could very well be just me, but I don't think I've ever heard the word "betray" in that context, and I thought it was a little odd. I think "portray" could work just fine, but that could very well be correct too.
But, obviously, this is just a suggestion, and it's always up to the writer, so please take this criticism lightly and know that I mean nothing negative by it—only trying to provide a somewhat useful critique.
If I had to pick my favorite part, it would have to be the way you described certain things throughout the story and showed what the characters were feeling.
One example of this that I really liked was the way you were able to portray painting as somewhat of a coping mechanism for Abigail.
With each brush stroke, my mind quieted.
This quote felt like it portrayed really well how artists of all kinds feel when they're in their element, and it's really neat how you captured it here!
I also really liked the way you set up the story for conflict. It was just a little tidbit of information that was thrown in and seemingly changed the entire course of the chapter.
But as I glided it up and down, black seeped through, as dark as the doom of my impending meeting with my father.
This is not only foreshadowing but also a very evocative description of what was going on in that moment, and it felt very surreal to read, so kudos to you for making that happen!
Overall, this was fantastic! You did a wonderful job depicting everything you were trying to get across in this, and it was fun to read as well!
Thank you for taking the time to write and post this and all of the other chapters! I'll definitely have to check those out in the future!
Goodbye for now! I hope you have a magnificent day (or night) wherever you are!
ariah347 says...
Hi my fellow wonderland enthusiast! Thank you for taking the time review this. I appreciate your comments!!! As for the advice, good catch. It should be portray rather than betray. I adore your commentary about Abigail's coping mechanism. For her character development, there is clear connections as to why it is her main passion in life as well as a tool to help her process and release. Thank you for your kind words <3 May you stay in the rabbit hole and come out with some whimsicality.
Did you ever hear the Tragedy of Darth Plagueis the wise? I thought not. It's not a story the Jedi would tell you. It's a Sith legend. Darth Plagueis was a Dark Lord of the Sith, so powerful and so wise he could use the Force to influence the midichlorians to create life... He had such a knowledge of the dark side that he could even keep the ones he cared about from dying. The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural. He became so powerful... the only thing he was afraid of was losing his power, which eventually, of course, he did. Unfortunately, he taught his apprentice everything he knew, then his apprentice killed him in his sleep. It's ironic he could save others from death, but not himself. — RazorSharpPencil
Points: 7389
Reviews: 394
Donate