Okay,I should write at least one more before review day ends...
Specifics
1. I'm not sure about using the possessive form of apostrophe in 'it's'. I've been brought up to only use an apostrophe for its when meaning it is or it has but I'm not sure if that's technically correct, or if you should use one for the possessive as well. I just thought I'd mention it in passing though.
2.
The snake went limp again, but it didn’t stay that way for long. In seconds, it had pulled its head off the spear, but its attention had shifted to Thørn. The boy’s eyes widened as he stared at the creature's scaled hide.
3.
This seems too sudden. I think we need to see Thorn gradually realising this ability he has or to see some surprise from him that the symbol appeared - surely he couldn't be expecting it when he has never done that before? People's magic advancing is a fun thing to happen in novels but there needs to be logic to it or some kind of build up. I'm also not sure that it makes sense for the snake to collapse at the sight of the rune - how would they have predicted that Thorn would gain illusion magic or solve the riddle in that way? I think it needs to be more generic than that. Perhaps the Necromancer stops reviving the snake now it has served its purpose in teaching this lesson?“Look at the patterns on its skin. If you superimpose its markings on top of each other, you get this.” When he said ‘this,’ an illusory symbol flared to life in front of him. Thørn had figured out how to make illusions.
4.
As if onqueuecue, the doors opened to reveal the dark haired man.
5.
“Wonderful job, both of you,” he said, pleased. “Alsari, you did a spectacular job holding off the naga, and Thørn, you solved the riddle inreccordrecord-”
6.
This doesn't make ense or serve enough of an explanation. Why did Quint include it in the test? Clearly the rune has a different meaning for him but I feel he needs to explain that rather than say 'I have no idea'.“I….I have no idea,” Quint apologized. “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to cause you any distress. Is there any chance this could be some sort of coincidence?”
Overall
What a fun end to the chapter! I love how simple Alsari is about the statement, like it's no big deal. I think there needs to be more reason behind this test or like Quint needs to give a better explanation to make it believable that they'd put too kids in danger just so one of them can see a symbol and realise it has some significance. I'm also not sure I buy how Thorn realised the symbol was the solution to the riddle - snakes can have really strange markings so what abut this one made him think twice? Has he seen the symbol somewhere before or did it feel like something to him? I actually think this chapter would work better from Thorn's point of view since Alsari isn't really doing much that's extraordinary. It's Thorn who solves the riddle, who discovers a new ability and who finds out he's hanging out with some crazy girl who may or may not have killed some Gods. I think his emotions/ thoughts would be the most interesting in this situation.
Keep the chapters coming and I may get to the next one in an hour or two but I'm semi obsessed with Being Human at the moment and another episode is too much to resist
~Heather
Points: 6235
Reviews: 2631
Donate