User avatar

IncohesiveScribbles

IncohesiveScribbles

  • Poetry » Dramatic, Literature Re: The Argosy

    Hello b00kthi3f, This poem is beauty and tragedy all wrapped up in one. I love how you never mention death's name but it is obvious who it is. Shtoobie might ...

    May 30, 2015
  • Poetry » Romantic, General Re: High Wire

    Hello Hermione315, I love this poem so much! It has wonderful imagery, the high wire and the wind being the one you love. The only minor changes I would make ...

    May 30, 2015
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, Other Re: *Untitled* Chapter One (Title Suggestions Welcome!)

    Hello Masquerad3, I really like this story idea, and I feel if is carried out well it could make an amazing story. Everything in this first chapter is good content. ...

    May 8, 2015
  • Poetry » Dramatic, Spiritual Re: A Gentleman Fighter (Speaking to the Devil)

    Hello Theironnovelist, I like this poem. It is very dramatic from the beginning to the end. It does irk me though that you left out capitals at the beginning of ...

    May 8, 2015
  • Poetry » General, General Re: The Final Judgement

    Hi Forestqueen808, I like this poem. It has a certain mystery to it that's just appealing. The ending however seems off. I'm not sure what you mean from about the ...

    May 7, 2015
  • Poetry » Romantic, Realistic Re: What Is Love?

    Hi Anshira, This is a beautiful poem. It completely captures all that love is, was, and ever will be. In the fourth stanza the rhyme scheme is slightly deterred by ...

    May 7, 2015
  • Poetry » Fantasy, Mystery / Suspense Re: The Lady and the Lady's Song

    Hello AdelVise, This is an amazing poem! Like Laelle said, this would make a beautiful song. The only thing I'm not sure about is when you wrote "A violon leaving ...

    May 7, 2015
  • Poetry » Lyrical, Other Re: Thoughts slip between the trees

    Hi Deanie, I enjoy this poem! The symbol of foxes slipping out of reach like thoughts from our brain is really powerful. I especially like the ending where you make ...

    May 7, 2015
  • Short Story » Science Fiction, Dramatic Re: The Water Men

    Hi Sothisonekidwrites, This is a really interesting short story. I hope you expand it into a larger short story or a full blown novel. I want to know what the ...

    May 4, 2015
  • Poetry » Realistic, Dramatic Re: Shutting It Out

    Hello Queen Anne, This is a very powerful poem. I like how it shows even though you want to just curl up and make it all stop, life keeps you ...

    May 3, 2015
  • Poetry » Humor, General Re: Save Your Work.

    Hello Pickled Chrissy, I connect with this poem on a spiritual level. Especially the first two stanzas. There's really nothing I can say that hasn't already been said for critiquing. ...

    May 2, 2015
  • Poetry » Other, General Re: A night of thought for the Joker

    Hi Raver, This is a really interesting poem. I realize that it's supposed to be about the DC characters, but it might be interesting if you changed Harley to "she" ...

    May 2, 2015
  • Poetry » Dramatic, Realistic Re: Sugar-Coated Melody

    Hello Bambi, This is an awesome poem! I love the ending saying you've fallen out of love. The last line just stops the poem in such a dramatic way it's ...

    May 1, 2015
  • Other » Spiritual, Dramatic Re: The power of escape

    I really like this extended metaphor. I like the imagery of the little devils tripping the people in the house. The last line is also very powerful, like a message ...

    Apr 20, 2015
  • Poetry » General, General Re: Celestial movement

    I like the symmetry of this piece. The three peaceful, but, then three chaotic. Space has always intrigued me and this poem is a beautiful capture of it's ferocity. Space ...

    Apr 18, 2015


The idea that a poem was a made thing stayed with me, and I decided then that I wanted to be an artist, not just a diarist. So I put myself through a kind of apprenticeship in writing poetry, and I understood even then that my practice as a poet was deeply related to my reading.
— Edward Hirsch