This is for a contest at my library. The rules are to write a poem with the idea of go green. I honestly don't know if this sucks or not, so please tell me. Is it too dark or sad?
REVISED VERSION.
Never before
Have I been alone.
I look out at the empty wasteland,
Where my brethren once stood,
Where the animals once roamed.
Where now the flowing wind
Whips with her merciless torrent
She is angry
Without the lush canopy
To play in.
I’d like to say this was the cemetery
Of my brothers.
But alas,
They have been kidnapped.
I cry my silent cry for them.
My brethren who watched over me
Since I was a seedling.
Protecting me
As I grew.
We watched the centuries go by,
Time dancing around our aging trunks,
Building us stronger
As it passed.
But now all has gone.
They are but a memory.
Destroyed without a thought.
And soon,
It will be my turn.
The wind mistress returns to me.
But now her chill
Is comforting.
Goodbye wind,
I always thought you were beautiful.
A heavy machine
Laden with sharp edges and
Pointed corners
Comes nearer
And nearer.
Now that the end is so close,
I think;
Humans.
I worked for centuries
To provide them with oxygen
So they could live.
We all did.
Now they kill us
With their sharp machines,
And brutish greed.
And most definitely,
I would give
Anything in the world,
For all of humanity to
GO GREEN.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I really liked your poem! It was really moving and it would be exactly what a tree would be thinking and speaking if it could! Congrats on 1st place! You deserved it!
I thought it was brilliant! In my opinion that is exactly what a tree would be thinking if he were the last one on Earth! Everything I was going to say has already been pointed out, so my only other issue is the final line: 'GO GREEN!' I find that it ruins the end of the poem, so maybe you could get rid of the capitals and the exclamation mark? I'm assuming that because it is a competition that you have to write it like that, but personally I think it ruins the ending.
Good job!
I WON!! OMG I WON!!!! FIRST PLACE BABY!!!!!!!!

Wow, that just made my entire life.
Hey there! Okay, first of all allow me to comment on your format: it needs work. You've got this huge block of text that's off-putting to any sane reader, not to mention your intended audience. So break it down into stanzas, I'll try to show you where as I go through the line by line...
Okay so overall, I think this is okay and it's a good purpose poem but by way of being dramatic or convincing, it needs work. The trouble is, you tell your reader what it is you want them to do. It's not a terrible approach but it's not the most effective. Your poem should make it clear that you consider certain behaviour bad and it should make your reader automatically squirm and think they should maybe change something. The personification of trees is in theory a good idea but the trouble is, readers know (or I suppose believe) that trees don't really feel. A more effective way to convince a person living in the modern world to go green would be to concentrate on the effects towards the animals and towards humanity.
A good poem that you should read is Thomas Hardy's 'The Man I Killed.' His poem makes the point that war is wrong without actually saying so. It isn't what some people call 'preachy'. I prefer to say inexperienced because we've all written poems like this and some still do. It's a habit that's not necessarily bad but the sooner it's broken, the better the poet gets.
Good luck with any edits you might make and feel free to pm me with questions or further requests. Sorry if this sounds a little harsh,
Heather xx
Hey! I'm finally reading one of your works!
I'm glad I am, too. Repeatedly banning you made me feel bad.
I love it!
Is it too dark? No.
Is it too sad? Yes, but in a good way.
Does it suck? Who gave you that idea?!
Like happy-go-lucky said, this is very thought provoking, and it adds such a personal twist which I adore. I love how you it into the trees point of view... makes it more emotional that way. I can almost hear the poor little tree, like it were speaking to me.
happy-go-lucky's nitpicks are good, and I agree with them. But, I do have one more.
Those first two lines; toss 'em. Not are they not necessary, but they don't belong. The poem has a much different voice than this. And besides, the third line is a great intro on it's own.
And also, remember some punctuation. You have some throughout, but it needs more to help with the flow.
Nice topic. It's time the world know how to go green. *goes into activist mode*
Glad to finally read something from you! Will I be seeing more?
~LIF
Oooh! Very thought-provoking! I don't think it's too dark at all. It's a unique and personal approach to going green and good luck on the contest!
A few nitpicks:
Maybe say "tears" the second time? Personally I think it sounds a little better, but this could be just me.
This line's a little out of place and not really needed. All the wasy through the poem has been very factual and definite - this line kinda changes the mood a bit.
Hope I've helped!
happy-go-lucky