Hi there Anniepoo! Niteowl here to review.
Your description says this is based off something that just happened, so I'm not sure when you'll be ready to really edit this. Still, I'll offer my thoughts.
There's some kernels of good stuff in here that could take this beyond the typical unrequited love poem into a strong narrative piece.
I got comfortable as we talked about golf, horses, and pumpkin spice,
Lines like this are good because it helps us see what the people involved are like and what they talk about.
You see, my phone buzzed again
this time from one of the girls.
She told me her secrets, she swore that she liked you,
she said that she would like to date...
I'm not sure I'm interpreting this part correctly, but if I am, this is a dramatic turning point in the poem. So this girl texts the speaker, who may know about her back-and-forth with this guy, and talks about how much she likes him. To make matters worse, this happens while the speaker is with the guy believing he's into her again after months of hot and cold. What I'm curious about is what makes the speaker so certain that he will now turn to this other girl. We know that she likes him, but there's no indication that he feels the same way, at least not in the poem.
She asks if I think you will like her dress,
her hair, her smile,
Oh my god, I just love this line. I can almost feel this girl taunting the speaker through these text messages.
Where I think this poem could be revised is in the rhyming and the length. Rhyming is very hard to do well, especially over a longer poem, and it's rather inconsistent here. Sometimes it's couplets, other times it's every other line, and yet some lines don't seem to rhyme at all. I prefer free verse in many cases because you can then choose the strongest words as opposed to trying to cram in some rhymes. This might also help with the poem feeling too long because you can then cut lines that seem like they're mostly there for the rhyme.
Overall, given the personal nature of this poem, you might not want to edit and I completely understand. Still, if you do, I would set it aside for a while. Once you've gained some distance from the event, you might have a better idea of what can be cut and what could be developed further. I do think there are some gems in here. Keep writing!
Points: 35774
Reviews: 1274
Donate