-
Re: Dreams of Suicide
*ugh, physics* Now that my dislike for physics is out of the way :D The ending was great. I thought of it as a light ending, definately like something that ...
Jun 30, 2007 -
Re: You love me
I felt like you could have done more with this. Especially here: "Three little words, Why are they so hard for you to say? Why do they choke you so? ...
Jun 30, 2007 -
Re: alternative history OR how the wooden horse never came to be
The adjective in the last line seemed a little out of place, as it's the only one hanging around. In something so short, it makes it seem almost word-y to ...
Jun 30, 2007 -
Re: Against the Tide/ Love Lies
I think you could have made more of the images you set up. You mention rivers and oceans, but I think it could be stronger if you describe them a ...
Jun 30, 2007 -
Re: .
Line breaks seemed choppy and arbitrary at best. The whole thing seemed pretty ramble-y to me, and I couldn't really get into it enough to give a decent critique. I ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: it was my first poem so it well...sucks, lol
First of all, the title is a huge turn-off. If you don't like your work, how do you expect others to? Woah... repetition. I'm sure you can gauge my reaction ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: What I Love
This seemed too blatant at the end, just coming out and telling what the "moral of the story" is. Just that last line, especially. It made it seem... too simple. ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: Dad
I thought kind of "meh" at the first three stanzas, like it is just a rant-y "why me" kind of poem, but the end redeemed it. I'm not a fan ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: (Not) My Life
I... liked it. I think. There are elements here that I usually mention in a critique as needing work, but here, everything just works. I really liked the last stanza ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: Too High to Land
All the "the"s began to bother me after a while. Do you need all of them before the nouns? I think that this: "My frailty bared, what will I become ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: Rough Draft
I don't see many ideas here that haven't already been expressed. In other words, it seems to be a typical poem about cutting that doesn't even make me empathize with ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: Just one girl.
I feel like you beat around the bush to get to "thousands die for no reason". The one-line interjections seemed a little unnecessary. I don't think that the last stanza ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: Of Bees and Strings
That was... erm... different.... but to be fair, I should have been warned by the rating and the subtitle... As long as I'm still telling you what I think, what ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: Song of Wind and Sea
During the middle stanza, at one point, it just seemed like a long list of things that happened in sequence, and that's... alright, but not too interesting. Make people want ...
Jun 25, 2007 -
Re: You Died
It seems very... blatent. Almost like there's not much to react to because it was all said already, and because of this, I feel pretty removed from the poem, like ...
Jun 25, 2007
