it was my first poem so it well...sucks, lol

1

Comments & reviews · 15
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Leja
Review
Leja wrote a review · Mon Jun 25, 2007 8:11 pm

First of all, the title is a huge turn-off. If you don't like your work, how do you expect others to?

Woah... repetition. I'm sure you can gauge my reaction here. I get bogged down in the repetition so much that I can't even really read the rest of it.

The last stanza, while pleasently devoid of repetition within itself, was just a summary of what happened in the previous stanzas, and didn't seem to add mcuh that was new, rather than helping to understand everything else in a new light.

Rethink your approach, and you might have something going here.

The last two lines were off rhythm and didn't add much to the poem. The repetition was getting boring. I knew the entire feeling and subject of the poem by the time I read the first stanza. why did I need to go on? But for a first poem, not bad. keep writing.

User avatar
Lora
Review
Lora wrote a review · Sun Jun 17, 2007 10:12 pm

*sigh*
it seems that everyone has said everything already. but that's ok, because...your poem had to much repition in it...so why can't everything else? it's because it is a bit tiring to hear after a bit, right?
so maybe if enough people say it, then maybe it will make sense to you?
other than that the last verse, was indeed sweet! Muy Bien! nice first try...but remember, you can only get better now!...well let's at least hope that all of our repetitious posts have helped! keep it up!

---Lora

User avatar
whence
Review
whence wrote a review · Sat Jun 16, 2007 7:38 pm

well, everyone else has pointed out the content errors, and Claw already said my standard recommendation: Read.

However, I still feel there's something to say.

Whatever you do, do not set yourself up for failure. If you introduce your poetry by saying 'yeah...it sucks', you might think you're just trying to excuse any mistakes via admittance, but in reality you're putting everyone in a mindset to read something terrible. Also, if you just bluntly say you think your piece is crap, it lends to thinking that you don't care about it. And if you don't care, then why should any potential-critiquers care?

Regardless, if you expect to write poorly, then that's what's gonna happen.

Oh yeah..... read
:D

~Ed

User avatar
Emerson
Review
Emerson wrote a review · Sat Jun 16, 2007 7:25 pm

It repeats to much, and has no punctuation. (Unless you count the one period at the very end.) Those are my biggest complaints.

Since you yourself say you are new to poetry, I suggest you read poems. That helps. Read some on the forum, look at the comments, see what is good/bad, and figure out how you can improve your own writing by what other people look for in poetry.

User avatar
Rydia
Review
Rydia wrote a review · Sat Jun 16, 2007 11:24 am

Not going to mention the repetition seen as others dealt with that... oh dear. Too late. I mentioned it. Seriously though, that doesn't work. One or two lines repeated for emphasis is fine but the whole poem is repetition with the odd other word. Also, you mistyped your a few times -

Write a poem that 'wakens you eyes (here)

Laugh a laugh that 'wakens you eyes (and here)

Also, 'wakens makes little sense. Even as awakens your eyes, it still doesn't sound quite right but I agree that the ending is sweet and well written.

User avatar
biancarayne
Review

Like everyone is saying, there is too much repetition in here that does nothing to this poem but rather takes away from it's potential power. Also punctuation might help too. Otherwise, for a first ever poem, which you said this was, this was definitely a very impressive write, as I've seen people who have been writing poetry for a while that don't right this good. I think you could be good at it if you kept writing and working at it and developing a style and all, ya know?

User avatar
Twit
Comment

The last verse was very good,but if you had varied the first verses it would have been better. Just a little too repetitive,that's all.

User avatar
London Aspen
Review

lulu_lizzrd, I think that your poem whould sound less repetitive if you made it something like:


Sing a song that opens your heart
Dance a dance that 'wakens your eyes
Write a poem so lovely you weep
Laugh a laugh just for we
For whatever you do
I will always love you.

You whould add more punctuation, but it should probably sound something like that.


Good Luck,
London

User avatar
piepiemann22
Comment

What everyone else said. Keep going, you seem to have potensal.

Random avatar
checkers;, Comment

Its repeats to much. Try going along the same lines... but using different worrd. if that makes any sense.

Random avatar
checkers;, Comment

Its repeats to much. Try going along the same lines... but using different worrd. if that makes any sense.

User avatar
Swires
Review
Swires wrote a review · Mon Jan 08, 2007 4:37 pm

I didn't like it: I think the repetition didnt carry any meaning and took all power away from the poem. In future, consider writing what your heart says - don't try and make a pattern of your words and don't try and force a repetition or rhyme that doesn't work.

User avatar
pink puppies
Review

Hi! I like the ending of the poem! (but the begining........, don't repeat so much.) :?
But overall, it's a good poem! :D

User avatar
Ares
Comment

Uhm. Stop using all the same lines...

And how do you laugh a laugh? That sounds weird. Dance a dance sounds funny too. This could be cool if you had more in it and didn't use all the same stuff again and again.



Time is not your best friend - unless you use it wisely.
— Marco Pierre White