Hi, sorry it took me so long!
This piece felt really real to me. Just the feel of the beginning gave it that, I think...
He had lived with him all his life. He worked on his farm, danced in the humus interlaced soil and pruned the vegetables. He fed the birds and the cows, saddled the horse before any ride out and he never once felt wrong about it.
Beautifully said. There's just one thing about this paragraph that I didn't like:
and pruned the vegetables.
I live on a farm/ranch myself, and there's no vegetable pruning. Normally the pruning is done on the fruit trees... However, I could be wrong, and there is vegetable 'thinning', which is basically pulling out smaller carrots/turnips/parsnips so that there's room to grow bigger, healthier, veggies.
The very last paragraph I found quite confusing; I have no idea who his father is!
I just read it again and I think I might understand... The rich guy dumped her ( so to speak ), then the other guy took her in, then she had a kid and the rich guy came ( thinking that it was his ) and the other guy was hurt that it 'wasn't' his kid... and the lady had no choice but to go back to the rich guy?
I think you need to explain a bit more, I know you were kind of trying not to, cause of the way the piece is, but it's a little confusing. I'm not quite sure how, but maybe if you took out a few 'whens' and maybe added some names... or at least something more then just 'he' and 'him'.
So above all, I really enjoyed this! It made me think a lot about my life, and what it would be like if someone lied to me my whole life, or if I thought they had. I also think you really captured the emotional element, just the way you wrote it... I felt like I was right in there with the main character. I thought you did a great job. Keep it up!
-Socks
Points: 0
Reviews: 494
Donate