Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Quite an interesting tale you are spinning. Something that bothered me was that the Messiah was awake when he was dieing, I belive most patients that near death were put into a medical induced coma, I almost jumped out of my seat when he started talking.
But perhaps your universe, or with this special case is different, I would not know.
It will be interesting to see how you countine this, here's to more good work from you.
Thanks y'all. I've made some simple edits to it, and will probably make more major edits sometime in the future.
In other news, Part Three is also up.
Wow.
This is really well-written and interesting! Others have beaten me to all the nit-picking, but one suggestion I have is perhaps you could describe the hospital in a bit more detail? I didn't really get a vivid image of the character's surroundings. Like KJ said, hospitals tend to be immaculate places. I get the impression this is a very important, high-end hospital, so I imagine it as being almost scarily clean-overwhelming whiteness, harsh light, etc, and being full of high tech equipment.
The pace frustrated me a bit- by the end of the segment I was left with very little indication why the patient was a "Messiah" and what kind of society this was... but I know that's just me being impatient, I'm sure that part 2 reveals more about that.
So very nice work! The doctor's voice is very realistic and you have a fascinating, if creepy, beginning. ^_^
Just a few nitpicks (and they really are major nitpicks. This story would be great even if you just ignored them all).
Should be dash between flesh and draped.
"tv" should be capitalized.
Just so you know, hospitals are highly hygenic places. Hands are constantly washed, and there's rarely a speck of dirt to be seen anywhere (I should know - I used to volunteer in one). So the fact that people who are treating this man, touching him no less, are getting his papers dirty, is unrealistic. In a real hospital the papers may be bent - but never smudged or dirtied.
But other than this, I loved it. Very well-written and creative. Going to look at Part Two.
Thanks for the reviews guys. ^_^ I'll be sure to refer back to your crits when I come to edit this in a couple of days.
For anyone interested, Part Two can be found here.
(BTW: I've changed the rating of this part to R, because Part Two has potentially R rated material in it.)
I really liked this story, it had an essence of nature, and was flowing, i really enjoyed it, mail me if you have any more stories like this one...
A true masterpiece...
Quite an interesting tale you are spinning. Something that bothered me was that the Messiah was awake when he was dieing, I belive most patients that near death were put into a medical induced coma, I almost jumped out of my seat when he started talking.
But perhaps your universe, or with this special case is different, I would not know.
It will be interesting to see how you countine this, here's to more good work from you.
*waves* Yo, Sureal!
This seems contradictory; if his breathing is being controlled by life support, his chest would be moving in the same rhythmic way a normal person's would, not erratically.
You go through all this building up of how the doctors can't figure out what's wrong with him, and it makes me think that it's something super-serious. But 'his organs are weakening' sounds a bit, well, weak. It doesn't have the same BAM impact on me that the previous sentence did. It doesn't take much to weaken organs and they can still function.
Switch the period to a semi-colon? That's just me though XD I don't think it would detract too much, just made me a little itchy.
It feels a little odd ending a sentence on the word though. Doesn't feel quite right.
This reminded me of German, in that you have the verb riiight at the end. But it meant that by the time I got to the end, I'd sorta forgotten what the beginning was and had to go back and read it a couple of times before I worked it out.
There's a bit of repetition with night, although I think you could pretty much end it with 'I want to observe the patient'.
Shouldn't that be 'There are always two specific doctors' instead of is, given that it's plural?
This shocked me quite a bit as I assumed that because he was on life support he would be in a coma or something similar. Anyone I know who's been on life support had to be put into medically induced comas before they could be hooked up, although I'm not sure if it's the same in all cases. But yeah, I thought he was out cold so I was very surprised when he started talking.
I really like this comparison, between the scrying and the doctor =D
One last thing is your use of commas, in that there are an awful lot of them XD Quite a few of them could easily be removed I think, some seem to be there from mental pauses when you were writing. I'm terrible with it myself, and it's something I know that I personally have to go through and check very carefully. But yeah, you should be able to pick out the ones I mean ^^
Anyhooz, this was pretty funky! I quite like the religious undertones and the way it seems quite clinical. You ended in on a cliff-hanger you fiend, so se sure to let me know if you post more so I can take a look-see XD
Hope that I've been of some use to you!
-fish!
I like it, I like it.
The repetition of "night" bothers me.
Same here with the chuckles.
This is a good sentence; it reveals his scientific mindset.
Creepy.
The present tense doesn't really bother me in this story. I think it might be because you gradually ease into it, starting with events that took place in the past, and then coming into the present.
Nice cliffhanger, by the way.
Solid.
Prokaryote