Hello!
RandomTalks here with a short review!
This was quite an enjoyable read. I love the way you have captured the western vibe, your narration painting quite a vivid picture of the times you are representing. It actually reminded me of some of the old Hollywood movies that I used to watch. I also liked the light-hearted tone; there was a simplicity to the story that was quite a refreshing and welcome change.
I enjoyed the light humor in the story, but I think some of it sneaked past me as I do not have a very clear knowledge of the Old Westerns as you mentioned in the beginning. Still, I liked your way of narration and how you used the third person voice to tell us the story in a fun and entertaining way.
His horse could run as fast as the lightning that split the sky in the Colorado thunderstorms, and his smile was as bright as the sunshine that lit the blue, blue sky as blue as his eyes.
I was a little confused because this description - "his smile was as bright as the sunshine that lit the blue, blue sky as blue as his eyes," comes up several times in the story and yet every time it seemed to be a conscious choice on your part. I cannot tell if this is a humorous device that you are using which I am not understanding or if you used them unknowingly. Either ways, the overuse of this description felt a little repetitive to me and maybe I would find a proper context before using it.
His fist was quicker than the lightning the split the sky in the Colorado thunderstorms, and his frown was as dark as the clouds in a Colorado thunderstorm. The enemies ran as fast away from him as they did from the dangerous Colorado thunderstorm.
Here you again use repetition in the descriptions, but this actually made me laugh. The humor is very clear here and the constant references to the Colorado thunderstorm draws amusement from your readers rather than annoyance.
Just to give you a little taste of what Wild Shane McGraw was like, here's a story telling about his greatest exploit -
The word 'telling' feels very out of place here. We know that a story is supposed to tell us things, I don't think you need to mention that to your readers. Maybe skip that word and write it either as, "here's a story about his greatest exploit ," or "here's the story of his greatest exploit."
Wild Shane McGraw was even more startled because only a moment before he had been riding on a prairie, and it mystified him as to how the Colorado Savages were suddenly looking down at him from a ridge, but he soon got over the concept and began to think about how he could get out of this fix, beat these Colorado Savages and get back to his town.
This sentence feels more like a paragraph with how much information has been dumped into it. It still holds meaning and conveys what you are trying to stay, but it does make one breathless if they try to read it at one go. I suggest splitting it up this way:
"Wild Shane McGraw was even more startled because only a moment before he had been riding on a prairie, and it mystified him as to how the Colorado Savages were suddenly looking down at him from a ridge. But he soon got over the concept and began to think about how he could get out of this fix, beat these Colorado Savages and get back to his town."
That's all!
Keep writing and have a great day!
Points: 82352
Reviews: 659
Donate