Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello, lovely Moo!
I love how this line sounds, but I had to read it several times before I understood what it meant. I think the word that really made the line confusing was "case." It doesn't really say which bird's core is thrumming, and I think that "case" could be substituted for a word indicative of that, though that's your choice, and ultimately, I understood.You're so gosh darn good at poeting. I just look at your stuff and think to myself, "Dang, gurl, dat gurl is a great poeter."
I love the use of "oared" in the second line. It's so descriptive, yet you're able to use a single word.
This line and the conclusion of the sentence sound awkward to me. It might be because it's an inversion, but it doesn't quite feel right to me.
You've used very loaded and descriptive words until now; "little" is a deviation from that. I think you should find a way to work a more beautiful word (as you've used throughout the poem) into this line.
I really like the last line. It's a beautiful way to end the poem. I don't know if you meant it to be a parallel for the bird's call, though, as a kestrel sounds like this. I feel that keening is more of a long cry, and was thinking that you could find a slightly different word here to reflect not only the emotion, but the sound a kestrel makes (which is quite annoying if you've been woken by one at five in the morning).
Altogether, this is just lovely, and the misunderstandings may very well be my own fault. I hope this review proves useful to you! Happy poeting!
I do agree with the usage of the word case. I think it was originally shell so I may change it back to make it more clear.
Keen is this sense is an Irish word describing a sound that is indicative of mourning and loss. I've not seen it defined this way in dictionaries but that would be an Irish understanding of the word used in this context; it also reminded me of bird-like sounds and thus fit well in my mind. I don't think this meaning is widely known though, so you might not have picked up on that :p
Thank you for such a wonderful and constructive review!
Moo
Moo,
I knew that definition, but in my mind's ear (if that makes sense) it always was a long wail, so it didn't really go with my vision. If it's such a general definition, though, man, go for it.
Wow, they are such gorgeous lines! Inspirational and delicate, a beautiful piece of writing
I love your wording, it's unique and professional! Very professional! Your writing style is natural and flows effortlessly. As a reader, I have read this about five times already! I can't help but read it over and over, it's gorgeous! I will definitely be reading more of your work!
I'm glad you enjoyed it Citrus. Thanks for commenting again!
No worries