-
Re: True Kindness
Prefacing your story with character profiles is a cop out. I can see how it might work if the story revolved heavily around mechanical themes and imagery, but as this ...
Feb 9, 2008 -
Re: Don’t Look At My State Of Mind
This seemed very confused. All the ideas are here, but pay closer attention now to language and word use; it seems a bit raw now. Watch the words ending with ...
Feb 9, 2008 -
Re: Fallen Angel
This reminded me entirely too much of Stephanie Meyer's Twilight series. A lot of this story was "x happened, then x happened, then x happened". Specifically, the first paragraph. Try ...
Feb 9, 2008 -
Re: Prologue: Vice and Viscera
I like how you end your paragraphs. I like the summation of them. so the canned asparagus was off when he got to it.. I don't understand? And is that ...
Feb 9, 2008 -
Re: Gay is My Ex
There are two very conflicting styles of writing in this letter. First, there's the reminiscent feeling of "we shared crayons and blocks" and "young love. That's what it was" etc., ...
Feb 9, 2008 -
Re: For Mathew Brady
I like the feeling of desperation in the first stanza; the sentence breaks for conjunctions and the repetition of "like". There was something about beginning the "but his photographs..." that ...
Feb 8, 2008 -
Re: They steal your health...
They'll age and die just as we do, I thought this quote had a funny rhythm? Too many sounds, maybe, in the "just as we do". An apt response to ...
Jan 30, 2008 -
Re: Inverted Compass: A Mix for Sam's The Something
*Everyone move out of the way! My turn to gush!* Cal, this is wonderful. Not only have you compiled an awesome fanmix with beautiful coverart, but you've introduced me to ...
Jan 25, 2008 -
Re: Cousin Mary - revised!
Gadi, this begins wonderfully, with a clear tone that shows you know where you're going. As such, as a reader, I can't help but be swept up for the ride. ...
Jan 24, 2008 -
Re: This is nothing. Don't look at it. It's just nothing...
This almost seems more like a book report than the beginning of a novel. Why? Because it summarizes the character. There's no action. Pure description takes us out of the ...
Jan 23, 2008 -
Re: Do not Enter
I wish this were written more seriously. Because then I think it'd be hilarious. Now, it's a series of actions and observations loosely tied together with a setting. I think ...
Jan 23, 2008 -
Re: Love, I'm Sorry
Beginning with "friend" and ending with "love, I'm sorry" is actually very nice. It shows a nice progression from the beginning to the end. It shows change. However, it is ...
Jan 23, 2008 -
Re: Ready your swords
I love how this begins, with the phrase in italics (I'm not sure whether to consider the quote as the start of the actual poem or as the preface to ...
Jan 23, 2008 -
Re: The Murdered and the Murderer (extended)
Brutal? I'd love to ^_^ First, let it be said that I abhor rhyming poems. I shall refrain from that statement here, however, because it doesn't overpower the poem too ...
Jan 23, 2008 -
Re: Do You Know Who I Am?
There is no way to see the "mangled insides" if the poem is strewn with generalities like "i'm fed up with what you're feeding me/ i think i'll break inside". ...
Jan 23, 2008
