User avatar

Aley

Aley

  • Short Story » Realistic, Dramatic Re: The Calm

    This is hard to review because it is so emotional, and I think that is exactly what makes me feel like I have to review it. I'll start with the ...

    Jan 14, 2013
  • Short Story » Fantasy, Culture Re: Weapons of Reivina

    First off, I would like to question why this is in the short story section instead of the chapter section. It seems like a chapter to a much larger book. ...

    Jan 14, 2013
  • Poetry » General, Other Re: Wishbones

    To me this poem is saying that where-ever you are, bury hope to make a better future. It is a very simple theme that I like, but I would like ...

    Jan 14, 2013
  • Poetry » General, General Re: Grab My Heart (Twist it 'round)

    There feels like there is a mismatch between the first two stanzas (lines 1-3) and the third stanza (starts line 4) with the beats. -=stressed beat .= unstressed (for the ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Poetry » General, General Re: Who am I, am I at all?

    For me this poem is asking what we really are as people, and how we find our identity within the questions of who we are. The fog represents an inability ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Poetry » General, General Re: Zenshi ichimi

    "Aimless clouds pass by / driven only by the wind; / we too are dream-walkers" For me, the last line seems strange. It doesn't quite seem to fit due to ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Teen Fiction, Fantasy Re: Untitled

    My first initial reaction was that the mother should be stepping in to the conflict. She might in the next part, but I don't seem to know where she is ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Poetry » Other, Spiritual Re: Bye Bye, Butterfly

    I feel like you're missing some stanzas in this one. Instead of using repetition I would suggest putting in stanzas where you have no repetition between stanzas you reuse. You ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Poetry » Other, General Re: The Monster and I

    Personally I dislike the repetition of "The Monster and I" when I have no context for who the monster is. I understand who "I" is, the speaker, but without some ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Realistic, Dramatic Re: "Home" Part 1

    This is an interesting read from the perspective of a kid in a doghouse, but I am having some problems with the set up. First off, I don't quite understand ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, Action / Adventure Re: Rovaalian. Chapter 3: Merciless.

    It is interesting that someone who was raised through the time when their moral compass is developing, would be so upset about something like killing. It seems like they would ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Short Story » Realistic, Narrative Re: Ramblings of a London Mind

    Overall, I would like to see more investigation into why people do this as a thought, musings about possible psychology behind it perhaps. I think that would help round this ...

    Jan 13, 2013
  • Short Story » Dramatic, Lyrical Re: Ballad No. 1

    I feel almost like this is missing the real climax. It does good getting up to a point where the climax should be, using the storm and the thunder, but ...

    Jan 11, 2013
  • Short Story » Dramatic, Horror Re: Run

    Having this jump from using a narrator speaking to the character, to the characters thoughts is a little jarring, but she is being jarred. I would like to see less ...

    Jan 10, 2013
  • Poetry » Lyrical, General Re: Grounded

    As a poem it is somewhat easy to tell that you're new to this but that only leads to improvement in the end. We wrote these types of poems back ...

    May 10, 2010


Half goat, half fish, all goatfish.
— OSP Red