The beast was terrorizing his kingdom.
Malin was the greatest mage and warrior in history. It was his kingdom and he would not tolerate the beast; he would hunt it and kill it himself. He wouldn’t fail.
They’re watching.
As if to prove he was worthy of such a feat, he turned to the fireplace, held out his wand, conjured a whirling, glowing red sphere, and gently tossed it. The fireball missed the fireplace by an inch or two, catching onto the blanket on the floor.
He gritted his teeth, feeling the council’s disapproving eyes on him. Not a whisper passed among them as Torin rushed to put out the fire.
“No damage done, Malin,” Torin said nervously, gingerly holding the blanket. He pushed open the window, letting an icy winter breeze whip through the room, and tossed the blanket in the snow.
Somebody cleared their throat, and everybody turned to an elderly man who sat at the head of the table. He pushed his glasses up his nose as he said, “You’re still young and learning. Perhaps we should send an experienced and proved mage such as your brother.”
Malin clenched his fists, but managed to keep his expression neutral as murmurs of agreement sent the room into a tizzy. The council could never stop praising his brother, Andreas, as if he were some god. He was surprised they hadn’t started praying and offering his brother sacrifices yet.
“No!” he shouted, barely containing his anger. “It must be me! I will kill the beast and I will not fail.” A dark shadow passed over his face as he met the gaze of each councilman. They stared back with expressions of shock, disbelief, and uncertainty.
They didn’t believe he could do it.
“The beast has kidnapped a girl,” a frail voice that belonged to Argos said. His robes were ragged and unwashed, his skin pale and sickly. “He kidnapped Emilia. We received word not even ten minutes ago. The stakes are rather high. Andreas would be much better suited for this task.”
His stomach clenched. Emilia, a nobleman’s daughter. The girl Malin wished to marry, the girl he loved. She refused his hand in marriage for years now, saying her father was sick or she needed to finish university and then she would consider it. Well, now her father was dead and she finished school in the fall.
It was perfect timing.
He would kill the beast and save her and they would finally marry. The stakes were high, indeed.
“I said I could do it,” Malin seethed, eyes burning. He gestured towards the fireplace. “That will not happen again. Every day I grow stronger than Andreas. You cannot disagree with that.” He paused, and nobody opposed him so he continued. “Andreas will not be back for another day, by then Emilia could be dead.”
Andreas was strong, he’d surpassed all the mages at the guild. But Malin’s power was growing fast. It wouldn’t be long until his power was greater than Andreas’. He was already making history, and he smiled proudly at the thought.
The men fell quiet, contemplating. The fire crackled, filling the room with overbearing heat. Malin whipped sweat from his brow, longing to be outside in the snow.
The elderly man with glasses sat straight, pushing his shoulders back. “Very well, Malin. We will grant you your wish this one time. Don’t fail us.”
Malin nodded curtly, spun on his heel and left, finally enjoying the coolness the winter breeze offered. Snow crunched under his feet and he kicked piles of it as he walked.
The beast had Emilia. Who knew what kind of tortuous things it was doing to the poor girl. At the thought, he picked up a light jog. The councilmen knew she was being held against her will, and yet still took time to squabble over who would kill the beast.
Idiots.
She could be dead by now.
No. He shook his head, not thinking of the impossible. He would leave immediately and soon she would be in his arms.
…
The beast wasn’t all that hard to find. In fact, his footprints in the snow led them to a cabin not even an hour’s walk in the wood outside the kingdom. Not very secretive, Malin thought smugly.
It would be easy. If his magic didn’t kill the beast, then an arrow certainly would. He would have its head mounted on the wall and Emilia in his bed.
Trees clawed the sky, branches stark and white. The sun was sinking, casting ghostly shadows over them. They followed the tracks to a cabin set in a small clearing.
The cabin was small and plain. Smoke pillowed from the chimney and a pile of logs stacked neatly near the door. It looked so normal, so human. Except for the long, deep gashes etched on the wood door. Claw marks.
Malin motioned for the men behind him to quiet before pounding on the door. “Beast! I know you’re in there, come out!”
There was nothing but the whisper of the wind through branches. The men’s armor clinked as they shifted. Not even the winter birds chirped.
Malin gripped the knob, but it was locked. Just as he was about to turn away, the door creaked open. Emilia’s red lips parted in surprise, her gold-brown hair plaited around her head, as if a crown.
“Malin?” She glanced around, behind him, towards the trees.
“Emilia. I’ve come to save you and kill the beast. Where is it?”
Her gaze was frozen on something behind him, in the trees. Just as he turned, there was a large, guttural roar. Malin sucked in a breath as he took in the beast, cloaked in shadows.
It was hideous. Magnificent. Lethal.
Its head was that of a lion, mane puffing around its head, but its body was similar to a bear. Its paws were larger than his head, each lined with deadly talons that could gut him with one swipe.
The beast growled, revealing two rows of sharp canines. That would also gut him without a second thought.
He pushed his fear down, but didn’t advance as the beast studied him with its yellow, unnaturally human eyes.
It took in the group of soldiers cowering, their weapons and armor. With the beast’s gaze upon them, they shrunk back, staring at their feet, whimpering. It lost interest and turned to Malin, who refused to show fear like a coward.
Its gaze latched onto Malin’s wand, which was pointing at the beast.
“You’ve come to kill me.” It wasn’t a question. The beast stepped forward, sending his men tumbling back in fright. The beast paused, paw hung in mid-step. “Emilia, go back inside.”
Malin’s face tightened in anger. “Don’t tell her what to do!” He glanced behind him. Emilia’s face was pale, eyes wide. He nodded and she stepped inside, letting the door close behind her.
“Alright, Beast. Any last words?” Malin turned, readying his wand.
The beast tilted its head, as if contemplating. It was such a human gesture for an animal. It wasn’t right.
“I was cursed by a witch. I watched as she burned to death and refused to help. With her last breath, she bound me to this body,” the beast said slowly. Cautiously. “I live here peacefully, searching for a cure, a solution, a way to become my former self.”
Malin laughed as if the beast had made a joke, and a few men chimed in with weary chuckles. “Peacefully?” he spat. “Is that what you call stealing, scratching on doors at night, kidnapping innocent girls?”
“Kidnapping? Emilia came here herself! She’s been-“
“Enough! You will not trick me with your lies.” Malin’s smirk dissolved, replaced with an icy glare. In one smooth motion, he conjured a fireball and threw it. The beast ducked, and the fireball landed in the snow with a loud hiss.
Malin cursed and the beast leapt toward him. He flicked his wand and the beast stopped midair, falling to the ground with a muffled thunk, snow flying. The beast struggled to get up, but its legs and arms were bound by invisible bonds.
Its roar was filled with panic and despair, gaze pleading. “Please, I’ve done nothing wrong. Let me go and I’ll prove it!”
“Let you go?” Malin cried incredulously. “Let you go so you can destroy us all? I think I would much rather see you dead.”
He took a bow and arrow from one of his soldiers, not bothering with his magic. He always enjoyed the art of archery, the way the arrow slung across the bow.
The arrow struck though its eye, and the beast made no sound as it fell, dead. Blood stained the snow.
Malin held the bow over his head and shouted, “The beast is dead!”
The men cheered and raised their weapons. Malin wanted to scold them for being so useless but that would have to wait.
“Emilia,” he called and the door creaked open. “Emilia, it’s alright. He’s gone now.”
She stepped into the snow, her gaze skimming the group of soldiers, Malin, and then the beast, dead in the snow, an arrow protruding from its brow. She let out a sharp cry and fell to her knees, cupping her hands over her face as she began to sob.
Malin wrapped his arms under her knees and behind her back, picking her up in one effortless motion.
“You’re safe now,” he whispered as they made their way back to the castle, leaving the dead beast behind.
...
Sunlight streamed through the window, the winter birds singing their morning tune. Malin groaned and rolled over, pulling a pillow over his head. He hated morning.
He paused mid-stretch. He moved his arm over and screamed.
Flying from bed, he scrambled over to the mirror, knocking several chairs and a dresser over on the way. The reflection of the beast stared back: The massive head of a lion, body of a bear.
He looked down, but only saw mounds of golden fur. He lifted his hand – no, paw. His heart hammered. He had claws.
No, no, no, no, no!
How could this be?
It much be some sort of nightmare. He backed away from the mirror, sending a vase shattering to the ground. Something sharp bit the bottom of his paw, drawing blood, but he barely noticed.
The door opened, a servant poked her head in. “Is everything alright-“ She froze in horror, her mouth working as if she wanted to say something. The beast turned, setting his yellow eyes on her and she screamed.
The beast stumbled to the balcony, adjusting to his new legs. He crashed through the glass doors. Glass rained on him, but that didn’t stop him from jumping from the third story balcony and running across the yard, hardly noticing the snow clinging to his golden fur.
…
Emilia didn’t move when Malin woke and screamed. She smiled and pushed deeper into the pile of pillows, enjoying the luxurious silk.
She did feel bad about the other beast, the one Malin had heartlessly murdered. He was telling the truth when he pleaded for his life: he was innocent. It had taken a lot of sneaking around, hiding in shadows, and lies, to make the beast look a criminal.
And when she discovered the curse. A former human, he was bound to the body of a beast. There was no way to break the curse. But if somebody dared kill the beast out of spite and hatred, they would assume the curse. Become the next beast.
She hated Malin, the egotistical know-it-all who thought he could have everything he wanted. There were plenty of girls in the village would could barely scrape by, driven by starvation, their only source of money from going to bed with Malin.
She frowned in disgust.
But the council would never get rid of Malin, he was a growing powerful mage. That kind of power was rare. It was the kind of power that went to your head, made you a tyrant.
A large crash sounded from across the hall, the sound of glass breaking. She rushed from her room, dodging a servant in the hall, and came to a stop in Malin’s room. Dressers and chairs were upturned, glass shards littered the floor.
She hugged herself as an icy gust blew through the room. Glass crunched under her feet as she stepped on the balcony. There, across the field was Malin. The beast. He ran on wobbly legs, like a newborn fawn. A few soldiers standing guard noticed and began to chase after, not quite realizing who it was.
“Emilia,” a soft voice said from behind. A warm hand clamed on her shoulder and she turned. Torin, one of the council men, watched the beast stumble across the field. Even on weak legs, he was still faster than the soldiers.
“Come inside,” he coaxed, gently leading her back into the warmth of the hallway. “Our men will catch the beast. You’re safe here. I’m sorry such a terrible thing has happened.”
He patted her arm reassuringly, and she surprised herself as a tear escaped. She didn’t bother to wipe it away.
Torin left her in her room, locking the door behind him. Alone, she didn’t bother hiding her smirk.
Everything had gone perfectly.
....
A few questions:
Did the story hold your interest from the beginning? If not, why?
Did the dialogue keep your interest and sound natural to you?
Was the ending satisfying?
Thanks for reading!
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there Lumos! Here to have a review!
I liked how you have done your work, it's straightforward with sufficient description and details. Character backstory, the mood, and settings.
But, below are most mistake or something I highlight as an inquiry. Correct me if I'm wrong...
1.as murmurs of agreement sent the room into a tizzy.
Tizzy is defined as: a state in which you feel very worried, upset, and confused.
2. praying and offering sacrifices- should be worshiping. because Andreas is there, alive... praying is to speak something celestial and not really physically there (you know what I mean)
3. every day I grow stronger than Andreas
This needs some rephrasing. Every day I grow stronger, one day will be stronger than Andreas / Every day I grow stronger, faster than Andreas.
4. whipped sweat from his brow,
Wiped.
5. tortuous defined as: having many twists and turns : complicated, long and confusing. Torturous.
6. It was hideous. Magnificent. Lethal.
It was hideous, lethal. But, Magnificent. Hideous and lethal is more to negative, while magnificent is more to positive. adding a connective word 'but' would be more suitable.
7. yellow, unnaturally human eyes.
No natural human eyes are not yellow. Unnaturally human eyes indicate that the beast has human eyes. Maybe, rephrase such as "the beast eyes were human eyes, but it was glowing yellow, like a beast, should be."
8. their only source of money from going to bed with Malin.
I hope that it means " Their only source of money, earned by going to bed with Malin(manwh**e).
9. he was a growing powerful mage.
He was a powerful growing mage.
10. Introduction to unnecessary charcter, Torin. he was just a councilman, who was not part in any Emilia's evil plan. Can just replace it with a random soldier.
That's it for now. See you soon!
~Wendy
To answer your questions,
1. Yes, who wouldn't love some magic warrior?
2. Instead of natural, like our everyday conversation, it's more like a theater act natural.
3. Ending, Wooooahhhh, such a twist! Love it!.
Hello, Lumos!
Thank you for sharing.
I loved your first few paragraphs. Your writing style is simplistic but has a true fairytale ring to it. Your characters are interesting too, with enough description that I can get a feel for their personality but not so much that the plot is weighed down. The only nitpick I have is that first thought (they’re watching...), as I wasn't sure who was thinking it. The narrator? The Beast? Malin? Making that clearer would eradicate any confusion the reader has.
No. He shook his head, not thinking of the impossible. He would leave immediately and soon she would be in his arms.
For the sake of the review, I questioned who he was really saving Emilia for. For Emilia herself? To prove himself to the council? To be better than his brother? It's obvious that Malin hates how popular his older brother is, and on the outside (if this wasn't in Malin's pov) it seems like he is doing this to prove himself. It is only because I can hear his thoughts that I know he wants to save his 'one true love'. That's what you were aiming for, I think, so no nitpicks there.
Emilia’s red lips parted in surprise, her gold-brown hair plaited around her head, as if a crown.
You have such strong imagery! The above is only one example. But from so few words I get such vivid scenes playing in my mind. Well done.
The men cheered and raised their weapons. Malin wanted to scold them for being so useless but that would have to wait.
One nitpick is that I'd like this scene to be drawn out a bit more. I'm not exactly clear on how Marlin is feeling. You cover everyone else brilliantly, but Marlin seems to be observing more than feeling.
When Malin looks in the mirror, I thought the Beast had survived and come to hunt him. Like he was standing behind the dresser, or behind Malin the reflection. It was only in the next sentence that I realised. Maybe you could rearrange the order? Like he looks at his hands, thinks he's just sleepy, blinks and looks up at the mirror? I'll leave it up to you.
I did not expect that ending at all and it was brilliant! Emilia played her part very well, it was good to see her point of view at the end. Taking away Malin's pov somehow symbolises just how beastly he had become. I loved this, honestly. I think it's such an interesting take on the story and it all makes sense, it's brilliant.
Yes, yes and yes to your questions.
Thanks for the review and follow!
Hey Lumos,
I am here to review your story and I'm going to do that just by giving you my reading notes since you have the questions at the bottom.
I have to say that I like how you've taken the story and decided to change it. I think you've done a good job there. If you want to stop it from sounding SO much like The Beauty and the Beast, then you could change what the beast looks like. I mean, what if he became a winged scaly thing? Or maybe a pig-headed cat thing? The options are endless for homunculus so explore a little!
Here are my reading notes:
Why wouldn't the council send him that day, and then his brother when he got home? It makes sense to send TWO powerful mages when just one should do the job. I mean, that's the safe way to play that situation, send EVERYONE disposable and clearly he is if the beast has been unstoppable.
billowed? as in billowing smoke?
Try not to repeat words like this. Say "head was that of a line, mane puffing around its neck" or something rather than head, head, especially since you're going to be saying how big the claws are in comparison to the HEAD again. You could/should compare it to something else, like maybe Malin's arm?
Question time!!
Did the story hold your interest from the beginning? If not, why?
It half-held my interest mostly because I walk away in the middle most of the time. I think the majority of the reason it didn't really hold my interest 100% was because I felt sort of Out of the action, if you know what I mean. Instead of being there with the soldiers in the forest, you do this sort of, overview thing and it takes me out of the story and to my mind just reading the story. For example: "It took in the group of soldiers cowering, their weapons and armor. With the beast’s gaze upon them, they shrunk back, staring at their feet, whimpering. It lost interest and turned to Malin, who refused to show fear like a coward."
This is all visual. There are no smells, no sounds, no clanking or groaning of the snow or the trees. It is all visual like a movie. I don't like that for my stories. I'd prefer it if it was more like...
"The beast lorded over them, examining the group as they reeked of sweat and clanked like tin cans on a dirt road. They hunkered down, their helmets nearly popping off as it pushed against their armor. The beast scoffed, his massive mane shivering at the grunting noise, and some of the soldiers let out yelps of fear, he turned on Malin.
Malin stood tall and proud, stiffened his back, tightened his core, and puffed out his chest and chin, trying to make himself feel manly as his gut twisted with the same fear of his men. He refused to show it, but it was there, and as the cold bit at his nose and ears, and the fear gnawed at his legs to run, he really wanted to get this over with quick."
It may seem like you're drawing it out more, but that's the type of thing which draws me into the story.
Did the dialogue keep your interest and sound natural to you?
The dialogue sounded natural, but it didn't really keep me interested. For instance, there's one point where Malin refuses to listen to the beast any longer, and I felt annoyed by him because of that. If you want to encourage camaraderie with your MC, you may want to make him less of a verbal idiot. You could have the beast finish what he said and then have the rebuke from Malin saying that they Know he is lying, and it would be better dialogue.
Was the ending satisfying?
Not really. I didn't care about him, and I didn't hate him, so I was indifferent to Malin's problem, and I didn't feel any comradery with Emilia either, so I didn't feel like he got his comeuppance. I think if you added in more of his adultery and such to the beginning of the story, you might get more of an emotional connection against this guy, but as it stands now it just makes me want to toss Emilie out in the snow with Malin for being such a devious witch.
Thanks for reading!
Thanks for writing and asking questions and giving us the author notes!
Yes, that's it! Sensory details! I was feeling as if this story was missing something, and that is it. It's been driving me crazy, so I'm glad you pointed that out!

Good point on the ending - I think it might be helpful if I expanded more on the story and their characters. Give the reader something to connect to.
Thanks so much for the review!
I'm glad I was able to help <3
Your questions were really useful to get me to brainstorm what you wanted to know! I love that you're doing that.