There are still good things in the world. No matter how bad it gets in my head, no matter how scary the news on the telly is, there are still good things in the world. Like last night when I couldn’t sleep and decided to pop into Insomnia Cookies for a treat (yes, that is literally it’s name, and yes, it is an ironic one). They’re only open from 6 p.m. to 1 a.m. and why I thought a double chocolate cookie would help me sleep is a mystery.
The walk over was terrifying. It’s just across the street from the halls, but you have to cross a busy road (four lanes of traffic) and all the stop lights were broken, stuck on blinking red. There’s no lights for two blocks across the street, so right past the purple and pink awning, you can’t see anything except for the faint streetlight glow in the distance. It looks like the abandoned neighborhood street from I Saw the TV Glow, and I wouldn’t be surprised if an axe murderer appeared.
But I went over and chatted with the man at the counter for a bit about how the streetlight was out, and wasn’t it a shame that the city hadn’t fixed it yet, and wasn’t the weather nice earlier. As he was wrapping up my order, he said “I just made another batch of cookies, so I threw in a chocolate chunk as well.” Then he gave me the code for a survey to get another free cookie. And despite eating both cookies in one night and getting another stomach ache, maybe two cookies for the price of one man’s kindness was good.
The day was also good. I competed in a Country Swing Dance competition and workshop. I lost, but the dancing was fun and I didn’t do too terribly. My used-to-be-friend Rose lost, as well. That shouldn’t make me feel good, but it did. She and I are also not friends anymore.
Last post I promised to tell you about my not-quite friend who lives in halls like I do. Aaron and I met in my Autumn term in 2023 at a common land cleanup put on by the uni. We both sat on the first-year Student Council together, but I’d never really noticed him before. However, after two hours of building fences around an archeology site, you start to get to know people better.
Anyway, I suppose we became some kind of best mates after that. We’d go to events together, hang out in the events, get dinner together sometimes. The last week of Spring term, I went home before he did, but I drove back almost 3 hours cause he said he wanted to see me one last time before summer. Last term, we’d go to different cultural events together on behalf of Student Council (we’re both Senators now with the other second and third year students). Even last week, one of the girls I occasionally see around campus asked me who that guy I was always with was and if we were dating (no, we weren’t).
But then last term we started to grow apart a bit. He said several hurtful things, such as asking me to be nice (not kind or even civil, but nice) to a fellow senator who’d been hitting on me and lied to me earlier in the year. Among other things, this fellow senator had used my name to attempt to dissolve our United Multicultural Council behind my back.
And when I mentioned a mutual friend’s homophobic and transphobic Instagram posts made me uncomfortable to hang out with her, he defended the posts and started inviting her to hang out with us without telling me in advance. I thought our class trip to Turkey would fix things. We bought seats next to each other on every flight. But then his brother fell dangerously ill, and since Aaron practically raised his siblings, he couldn’t go.
And I almost asked him out. But I realized that we would be terrible together. He has major conflict avoidance issues. In Student Council, we were doing this exercise around conflict resolution and we had to divide up a crop of imaginary oranges. After 30 seconds of discussing it, Aaron told me we could just go with my idea, he was tired of arguing. And in real life, if I ever try to mention that something he’s said or done bothers me, he changes the subject or walks away. So now everytime I see him, all I can think about is the hurtful things he said.
And the other night, we were walking back to the halls, and he was sick. We’d been at a Student Council event and all evening the senators had been telling him to go home, get rest, while he insisted he’s fine. We’re almost in the halls and he almost falls over coughing (keep in mind he was in the hospital with a fever of 41 Celsius five days prior). He then tells me that it doesn’t matter how sick he is, or how much he’s hurting or how much something is bothering him, he will never let another person know something is wrong.
I’m willing to try to save our friendship, but I can’t if he won’t tell me what’s wrong and runs whenever I bring it up. He hasn’t asked me a question about myself in almost two months. If I try to tell him about my day, he interrupts me and changes the subject. And it hurts, losing the person you feel close to, even when you aren’t good for each other.
In some ways, it felt like we were a couple, not romantically, but with the other things: asking if he’s low on groceries when I’m at the store, him asking if I want anything when he’s ordering food even if I’ve just eaten, calling him for a ride home from the hospital, when I was sick the week before him, making sure we both eat, and get some sleep. I was the only person he told outside of his professors when his brother was in the hospital. He texted every couple days, despite the 9 hr time difference. At cultural events and parties, we were each other’s default plus one.
It just hurts too much right now. Even before the thing with his brother happened, we were growing apart. And he’s perfectly normal with everyone else, except me. And I don’t know if that’s because he’s more comfortable around me or because he can’t bear to be around me, but I can’t play this guessing game anymore when he won’t tell me what’s wrong.
Maybe that’s why I’ve never been in a relationship. I’ve only ever been interested in my friends, and by the time I’m comfortable enough to ask them out, I’ve already realized we wouldn’t work. My friends say to take more risks. I say there’s something to be said for not being in a new relationship every three months and ignoring red flags. I guess only time will tell who's correct.
I met someone else, though. I was going to ask him out, before a very unfortunate class assignment happened. I’ll tell you more next week!
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello there, human! I'm reviewing using the YWS S'more Method today!
Shalt we commence with the scary S’more?
Top Graham Cracker - This chapter is all about friendship and how it can wither away, how even the most bright of friendships can disappear into nothingness. And of course, Insomnia Cookies! (I heard of that place and I would LOVE to eat cookies from there!)
Slightly Burnt Marshmallow - I have no recommendations to make as of right now, but if you would like to edit this, then you may.
Chocolate Bar - I love how the relationship between the narrator and Aaron is described. There’s always this one person out there who we initially think is cool to hang out with before we realize it’s not the case. It’s not like the narrator wanted to stop hanging out with Aaron, but that’s what had to happen the more they learned about Aaron. It’s sad, but it happens, and this describes it perfectly.
Closing Graham Cracker - Overall, a nice chapter on how friendships sometimes do not last and how unlike in movies, they may never be able to be revived again. It hurts, but it’s life. I will be sure to check out the other chapters and…
I wish you a fantastic day/night! ^v^
This reads pretty intimately (like a diary entry as I mentioned in a previous comment). Your tone is direct and to the point without indulging in too much prose. Maybe play with that a bit. This is YOUR story in a world you are building on the pages. Allow yourself to be gratuitous sometimes.
The comments on your character's friendships felt raw and the loss of connection was understandable. People come and go and instead of lashing out your character handles these losses with a sense of maturity, if also sadness. I'd like to see more of her personality in how she responds to the ups and downs of life but no pressure.
Thanks for the feedback! In later chapters (such as Chapter 5, 6, and 7) I tried to address how the character responds to the ups and downs of life. Let me know if I succeeded and if you have any other feedback.
I like how you have written it like a real person's diary. I really believed you were using this platform to tell your own story, so kudos to that, your writing somehow fooled me to think that!
Secondly, I also noticed how you put some little breadcrumbs about the "rumors" about the friend's "brother" etc., this very subtly creates an intrigue about the narrator and her life, that really creates a sense of suspense about this person, also makes me read more of this story.
The only critique I have for this is that, I don't feel for the main character. She feels real, but I don't really care if something good or bad happens to her. I hope you understand what I am trying to say.
I hope my critique do not come across as too negative. Maybe your idea is to reveal about the protagonist slowly. And that is fine also.
I will read more and edit this review accordingly, thank you, keep up the good work.
wizartjay,
Thank you so much for your feedback! I took you advice and tried to make the character someone you can feel for when writing Chapter 6 (please let me know if I succeeded). You're critique isn't negative at all, I really appreciate the feedback, since it helps me figure out what to change/emphasis in future chapters.
SWOOSH! Greetings, lovely Orion! Cupid here, armed with my bow, arrow, and a sprinkle of stardust for an enchanting reviewing adventure! Today, I'm diving into the captivating world of reviews with my very own Cupid's Sweetheart Spotlight. It's like the incredible YWS S'more Method, but with a dash of cupid's magic! Let's get flying, shall we?
Fluttering Wings - Initial Impressions:
Okay, Wow! I love the way this is written! I feels like I'm reading a diary entry, you made everything feel so natural and easy to read! Right from the start, I could feel how much these relationships, (both friendships and the almost-more-than-friendships :eyeroll:) matter to the MC. (Did we ever get a name for the MC? Maybe I just missed it, but I don’t think I’ve seen it in this chapter!)
I think one of the strongest aspects of this piece is how naturally the emotions come through. Nothing feels forced or over-explained. The frustration, nostalgia, and quiet heartbreak, not in a dramatic way, but in that slow, painful drifting apart type of way, which is really well captured!
I also really appreciate the conversational tone! It makes the piece feel like the narrator is just talking to a friend, sorting through their thoughts in real time. That makes it easy to connect with, and even when the story touches on heavier feelings, it never feels overwhelming. Instead, it feels honest!
Arrow Adjustments - Loving Suggestions:
Nothing major for this section, your story is already amazing, and beautifully written as is.. but, there are a few minor things I wanted to touch on.
Pacing & Transitions
Spoiler
Also, there are a few moments where the sentence structure could be adjusted for smoother reading. For example:
Original:
Suggestion:
The original is perfectly clear, but I think breaking it up slightly helps with pacing and makes the "severity" of the moment stand out more.
Expanding Key Moments
Spoiler
This is already a gut punch, but adding a moment where the narrator realizes this, maybe mid-conversation, maybe after yet another interruption, could make it land even harder. A pause. A realization. A sinking feeling. Small tweaks like that could really help with the emotional weight of the story!
Cherished Verses - Cupid's Favorite Lines:
Ugh, this! I hate when people do that stuff, it always makes me feel like I've done something wrong. It's always that feeling of wanting to talk things out, but being met with avoidance is so frustrating and painful, and you captured that experience so well.
This one really got me. It’s such a (unfortunate) universal experience, that slow realization that even though a relationship, (whether friendship or something more) was meaningful, it just isn’t working anymore. The wording is so honest and matter-of-fact, which makes it even more powerful.
Oh! Did you rip out a page of my diary and put it into your story, perchance? (Stop!! I don't like this game!!) You really know how to put real emotions into your work, I really love that about your writing!
Final Whispers - Closing Thoughts:
This chapter really hit home. The way you write about friendships, especially the slow, painful kind of drifting apart, feels so honest. Friendships don’t always explode or fall apart dramatically; sometimes, they just slowly unravel, and you capture that so beautifully! I really felt the frustration, the hurt, and that lingering hope that things could still be fixed, even when deep down, you know they probably won’t be.
I really want to know what happened with that class assignment! Seriously, this was such a good read, and I can’t wait for the next part!!
Sending you all my love in heart-shaped arrows, Cupid! 💘
Youbeaucupid, thank you so much for the review! It was a lovely surprise and I really appreciate the feedback and suggestions! With regards to the MC's name, it isn't mentioned since it's written from first-person (I'll do an introduction to the MC chapter in a few weeks to flesh out the background). If you have anymore suggestions in the future, let me know I'd love to read them. I'll be posting the next chapter soon, so keep an eye out to find out about the class assignment.
I'm glad I could help!!
Don’t mind me, I’m just claiming a reviewer’s spot
Don’t mind me, I’m just claiming a reviewer’s spot
Don’t mind me, I’m just claiming a reviewer’s spot