
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
A Poetry Jam collaboration by @creaturefeature, @herbalhour, @envy, and myself. Text Version below:
Hey everyone! First of all, I love collab poetry, so seeing a poem, written by so many amazing people made me really excited. Let's jump right into the review, and not waste any time
The first thing that stood out to me, was the beautiful graphic and image that this text is pasted onto. This lovely design made me very intrigued to read the rest of the poem. This poem, in my interpretation, really speaks to the cycle of life shown through nature. To me, it speaks of acceptance, for what we have, and for how the wind carries us, things in our control and out of our control.
Right from the very first lines, I was very intrigued. Mistaking things you see, as ghosts seems to say, "I am stuck in the past, unable to move on, everything I see reminds me of you." And then, spring is described as a haunting time. Spring is normally seen as a time of growth and rebirth, but instead, when we see things grow, we are consumed by this fog, this constant reminder that never leaves us. This poem spoke of trauma in a very interesting way. I love this.
The roots may be gone, but the remnants of the tree are still there. Strength may be gone, but there is still an external personage fighting to live. Although, they may already be gone, or too far gone to ever be saved. I love how you guys described different parts of nature almost yearning for this life that has been lost. And then we go from these external descriptions to a more personal reflection, becoming a whisper in the wind. Something that was, which is not there anymore. I love the following line where you talk about becoming a bird song. Although we may be gone, the parts of us that changed others will live on forever.
This poem hit me very deeply. It's such a beautiful reflection on life and death. Seasons and change. Spring to Fall. And just like the title, says, when we leave this earth, we leave our bodies here. But what we bring with us is the change we brought to this place until we have been shaped to become. Most importantly, we leave behind memories which will live forever. This poem made my day better and inspired me to leave a little more happiness everywhere I go. Overall, fantastic writing to all of you! I can't wait to read more in the future.
Your friend,
Ellie
Woooahhh people hold your horses….this is great!! The raw emotion and the desperation yet slight almost…jealousy portrayed is amazing and of course, the lowercase poetry is mind-blowing! I love how sad the whole “feel” of the poem is and the dreamy view the character has that they miss something or long for something SO MUCH that they start to put that something into everything they see.
“I mistake every nesting bird, for another one of your ghosts”
This is absolutely awesome! Happy Napo!!^^
This is great!! Incredible work, all four of you!! ^^
Hi names 22Midnight
hope your doing well, let's get into it!
this is such a beautiful poem that you all have written together so much so that i had to read it more then once to really feel the meaning behind it, I feel like it is a poem about loss love and pain and losing once self. in very descriptive lines used with simple words that flow so well when together it showed such meaning, it in away made me feel sad but grateful for what I have at this present point.
I don't read poetry very often but since being on YWS i have seen very talented poets in a very short space of time, and i am almost in owe of how you write this so wonderfully, i look forward to seeing more of everyone's poetry.
Please keep writing, published poetry that is this good is hard to come by at least it is for me, you all have a gift and I hope you continue to use it.
hope it's okay that i did a review but didn't give any advice i'm new to this hole thing so not really sure what i'm aloud and not aloud to do in regards to what I can put in a review.
anyway that's it from me
hope you have a great dawn/dusk/midnight
See Ya
lowercase poets united
monumental moment for yws poetry