Hey inktopus,
You already know what I'm going to say in terms of an introduction, so let's just skip that altogether, shall we? Okay. So getting started...
The long days of travel were mostly uneventful, and it seemed to Asha that silence began to swell between her and Yuni like a festering boil. Asha had declined to speak to Yuni barring those unavoidable contacts, and Yuni seemed content to spend the days living inside her own head, happy to let Asha take the lead.
Wait, what? What happened? At the end of the last chapter they seemed to be off on a pretty good foot with an amicable relationship. And now suddenly they're barely speaking to each other and traveling in a tense silence? What happened between then and now? This is a shocking way to start this chapter, and not in a good way.
It was unnerving to find that no matter how rude and dismissive she was toward Yuni, she would always meet Asha with a genuine smile.
Why in the world is Asha being so mean to poor Yuni? Yuni literally saved her life, and now Asha is just being a complete jerk towards her. It doesn't make sense.
~ ~ ~
Not going to lie, this chapter isn't my favorite. I think the sentiment is good -- but it just feels extremely... rushed? Like I felt disoriented being thrown into such high strung tempers so suddenly, with no build up to why this explosion happened. And then Yuni's reason was a bit of a cliche as well.
I would recommend taking time to slow this chapter down and really work on exploring the emotions going on and the build up to them. No one has such an explosion all at once -- usually it's hours and days and weeks of irritation that people bottle up and up and up until suddenly bam explosion.
Plus this chapter is extremely short. Like, I wouldn't be surprised if this review ends up being longer than this chapter is, which is... meh. I read your author's note about this not being the final product which is well and all, but I would recommend you do your best on your chapters before you post them. That will get you the best help.
I mean if you post a chapter you're already not planning on using, what's the point? If you post a chapter that you genuinely worked at, then we can help you improve it beyond what you can currently do -- and then when you go around with revisions it'll be even better. But if you start with a half-hearted attempt, then it's harder for your reviewers to give helpful critiques.
Anyway, since this chapter is soooo short you have tons and tons of room to slow this down and really work on exploring the relationship between the girls and the tense emotions that lead up to this point -- which I think would be the main thing that would significantly improve this chapter at this point.
However, just let me mention that I really like your description of magic. I really enjoyed getting to see the magic in use, and also get a better understanding of how magic works in your universe. I mean there are a ton of ways for magic to play out -- so getting to see first-hand how magic works in your world is a definite strength of this chapter.
Sorry if that was overly critical -- just my thoughts on this chapter.
Keep writing!
~Shady
Points: 2806
Reviews: 935
Donate