Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Oh boy. Realistic fiction. That genre is uncharted waters for me.
I just might continue this (if only from the requests to do so!) but it might be slow. I have other things to work on at the moment.
*Edit* Sorry, but this was really a one-time thing. If you want to find out what happens, well, you'll just have to imagine it for yourself.
yahhh you can't leave me hanging...i need more..what happens does her brother come home...does she become friends with this girl what happens???
Hey there Rosey! June here! I'm going to run over this for you, and try to be as harsh as possible, mwahaha.
. Now, let's get to work... not that there's any work to do...
I don't think the "She added silently" is necessary here, and if you decide to keep it the S in she should remain lowercase, dear
First line: Would a photo be considered a stray piece of paper? I'm probably being overly picky, but that's making the picture sound all flimsy. Maybe replace the word paper with photograph? I know it's not very important, but still, it just kind of stuck out a bit
~~
This part isn't very clear, dear. We can't really tell what she is supposed to be believing in? Maybe just stick "Santa (claus)" somewhere in there so that we understand that it's not snow that she no longer believes in
~~
"had been" sounded a little better as "was"
~~
Drive her where? To the store? Library? Tell us that she's going to school!
-----------
Overall:
This was such an interesting piece to read! There wasn't much to speak about here, it was very well written
I tried to be as mean as possible and pick on anything I found, but, there really isn't anything to change or be mean about. I think it's perfect!
I really don't have much more to say about this, dear. It was brilliant.
Gold star
June
Thank ye!
No, I have found "When one door closes, another opens." The full quote is: "When one door closes, another opens, but we often stare so long and so regretfully at the closed door we do not see the one that has opened for us."
And for the "favourite" thing- I'm Canadian. In Canada, that's how we spell it. Along with "colour" and a bunch of other words.
Then and than. I forgot the change that! Thank you!
Hmm, I'll have to think on the italics thing.
Glad you enjoyed it, both of you!
Geez, such a sweet story. I'm almost crying. I stopped believing when I was seven (all my moms fault). She said Santa had got stuck with his SLEIGH in the chimney. So I was like: ''Woa, wait a moment... Doesn't Santa jump down the chimney alone?''
Overall, really nice story. It was very sweet to elaborate on the relationship between the siblings. The song fits really well if you listen to it too. Expand it into a story maybe?
<3fluteluvr77
Thank you pop!
Are you sure your computer is working? I do italasize all those things!
More description at the beginning? Oh boy.
That long sentence at the end it's a run-on, it's just a long list. Maybe I should use semicolons instead.
"Then" and "than" are things I mess up often. Thank you for pointing that out!
I would italicize 'this' to really put emphasis on it. I also think the last line is a bit of a run-on, but I won't say anything. (I'd suggest asking someone who's a major grammar expert.)This opening is definitely more descriptive, but I still think you can expand on it some more. However, you did you job well. As the reader, I can say I agree with Karen and don't really like Calgary's first empression.
Typical teenager here. I love it. I think that her thoughts ("Why bother?") should be italicized, though.
I'm pretty sure this sentence can be rewritten as: "He was somewhere in Afghanistan now." However, that doesn't really have the same effect, so I think the punctuation should be altered.
Pretty sure the "her" after the quotation marks should be capitalized.
Aw.
Quick nit-pick: I'd italicize the thoughts. Or you know what? I'll just go ahead and say that all thoughts should be italicized. That way it won't annoy you so much!
Quotation marks around "thank you".
'Then' should be 'than'.
I love this.
Alright! Much better than the first draft. I like that Karen gets a friend to help boost her spirits.
I enjoyed the conclusion to this version much more, Rosey. It was still sweet, but you managed to give it a more serious, realistic edge. By adding more description and introducing a new character (expanding upon 'when one door closes, another one opens'), you made the storyline better rather than completely altering it.
As far as character development goes, I think you did a good job with Karen. She's very real and easy to relate with. I was the same way when I moved to Seattle!
I liked how you added even smaller details like how she knew she was probably going to be laughed at in school (making her more human), and how manners were "drilled into her" (giving her a better disposition in the story).
That's all, Rosey! I gave the draft a star, so you should automatically know this even better version gets one as well!
~anti-pop
Thank you!
Ah yes, the ending. I have been struggling with that a bit. I think I'll just delete those lines. I don't like them that much myself. (Usually, if I write it down I'll keep it in and see if it works, after reading this again, they don't.)
More stuff to add in. >.< Hmm, now to come up with a way to include it.
Hey Rosey! I didn't know the song until now, so there you go.
Well, I couldn't see much nit-pick wise ><;
I think this would be more effective if she merely said "Yes, I do.", as the way you have it seems like she's almost justifying it. Who cares if it's for kids? She doesn't. So just leave that off.
Hrrmm. It's not really an ending sentence, is it? It kind of leaves me hanging. It's just an action, and while it has some significance, it's still a little weak. For a story with such a strong theme behind it, this line kind of lets it down.
But I agree, this is a sweet little story. I can see some evidence of the song, but it's quite able to stand independently.
But as to improving it, maybe you should highlight how much she wanted to fit in at school- it would make her actions louder and more significant, to give up something she wanted. Maybe you could also show the impact of christmas without Damien on her parents, too. This will make her brother more important as a whole- and make his absense again, more significant. In short stories like this, you don't have the luxery of character development, so it's important you have some strong, simple figures and conflicts which have strong significance. You're trying to make your reader think, after all.
But overall, this is a very sweet little story, which I could find little fault with. Which is good for you, and makes a shorter critique then I would like >.<;
Anyway, well done! PM me if you have any questions. ^_^
-Nutty
A very sweet little story.

I love that song by Josh Groban, and I really like the idea of her brother, a soldier, being the one to give her hope, and encourage her to keep believing in things that everyone says we have to outgrow once we reach a certain age. I found Damien's encouragement particularly meaningful, not only because both I and some of my family are in the military, but because it is such a difficult profession, and it's easy to lose faith and become cynical about life when you deal with destruction and discord on a day-to-day basis; you know that Damien's deployment in Afghanistan would be no walk in the park.
I encourage you, though, to get someone to take a really thorough look at this. You have some misplaced commas, some messed up punctuation, and phrasing issues to work through. I like the message, though, and enjoyed reading it.
Good luck!