Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for violence.
.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey Rosey~ I'm back! Back again!
Just a really good show of Kerani's character, I think. She's bold and doesn't like people telling her what to do and she's fed up with her father, and this does a good job of showing her as determined to do her job right -- and him getting in the way.Let's start off with the good stuff this time! Because there's a lot of it in this part (and the next) and I really love what you're doing with this.
The whole part about the garükh yunu is just plain good writing <3 Obviously it can be difficult to write about things like PTSD, especially if you're coding them PTSD and don't have the modern language to lean on when explaining things to readers. But I think you get it across really well what garükh yunu is as well as how it interacts with the rest of Kerani's world and her life. It also doesn't read like a trauma that's just been slapped on her for the sake of a traumatic backstory -- it has purpose to her life and her character.
I love how you tie in Kerani's clothing choices to her status -- I mean, I love her clothing description in general.
Actually, all the descriptions of the clothing are absolutely wonderful. I love Kerani's clothes and Jalil's and Nitika's and I want like, a book of illustrations of all the clothing in this because I'm sure the everyday clothing is just as impressive as the special-occasion wear -- I want to see all of it (though obviously there's situations where that's not practical lol).
That Kerani was blessed under Sandhin! Obviously we've been informed in the last couple chapters that she leans away from the traditional identity of women in her world, and that she's frustrated being third-gender isn't exactly open to her as an option because of her social status. I'm really digging it honestly, for obvious reasons and just plain because it's so cool to read third-gender protagonists <3
I'll move on now to some of the grammar and style stuff!
This paragraph feels a little sparse to me. I think it could be split into three paragraphs with another sentence or two -- the first, on how Kerani doesn't train her servants; the second, on how the good servants were reserved for the scientists to work as lab expenses; the third, on how Kerani pays her servants well. These are all related ideas but they're not quite the same, and I think that confuses my head when I'm trying to look at this paragraph.
I want to feel more of the tightness in Kerani's chest and how her breath doesn't hit the bottom of her lungs and I'd love to see more of her physical and emotional reactions. Even just a line before she realizes to herself that it's a struggling-to-breathe panic.
This sentence is a little confused. Maybe split it up, again, into separate ideas (I had ignored thoughts... They had been so tied up with my own.)
At first you don't mention the table so I'm slightly confused as to the place-setting when we're walking into the room. Maybe just a quick mention here -- "Father sat on Suraj's side of the table" -- would clear up some of that.
just another simple typo here <3
I'd love to get a little more physical description of Suraj next to Kerani -- since she's feeling the empty, she really should be relying on her closer senses like sight, hearing, etc. (though it would be cool for her to realize that she'd cut those off somewhat in her reliance on sensing magic). But right here, with Kerani feeling the threat of emptiness, even just tossing a line of "Suraj stood at my shoulder" or something could give us a physical sense of bearing here.
I actually love this exchange a lot! It further establishes Kerani's character -- and your follow-up in the next scene helps establish Suraj. I just wish there was more to it, I know I've pointed out a lot of stuff like this but I'd love to experience Kerani's world, not just see it from a distance through a foggy lens. This is something I think could be great with another line or two thrown in to give it space.
And to round out the review, some character and setting stuff!
Yes more of this! I know you're coding everything super well but I would love a mention of whoever did the henna clucking that she should have more, and Kerani being insistent that this was all she wanted, it's her wedding, etc. etc. Or even a description of the henna style -- do the Palahiras have a particular style their henna is done in that's different from surrounding regions, if the other regions have henna too? Does the Empire do henna, and if so, how is Kerani's different? Etc.
I love your worldbuilding so much. I love your characters. I'm so so so excited to see where this story brings us! <3
Keep writing!
Hi there again Lima Bean! This is Nikayla here dropping in for a review. I would've gotten here sooner but I forgot about maintenance and only finished one review before that happened. I enjoy that the summary at the beginning of the chapter is put into use here! That's a first. Nice refresher. Anyway, let's jump right in.
First, wow I forgot how bright this box is and second, both 'had' and 'was' are used twice in this first paragraph, making for a bit of awkward wording. Not only that, Palahiras is repeated as well and there's a teensy bit of a stumble over words. With editing I can see this being a stronger opening paragraph to the chapter.
My hate for the word 'was' is possibly contributing to this, but I found the word to be repeated quite a bit in the first couple paragraphs. I also wanted to point out another paragraph where the same is doing with 'had' and I'll put that below.
Moving on from that, I feel that the paragraph that touches on her family wanting Kerani to be loyal. The point of that Kerani's sisters were all taken away from her anyway and that Ranya is a bit of an outcast to the family now could've been done more effectively. I wanted to bring this up because this is a lovely argument to have. Kerani's told to be loyal when all of her sisters are being taken away from her. The concept can be impactful though the diction and execution is able to be improved.
Takes awhile for this chapter to delve into the dialogue, which I don't blame you for here. Still, there's this weird sort of narration in a way that throws me off. I'm in a love/dislike (I've never outright hated this element) relationship with the voice of Kerani? Or I've become more fond of when other characters are around to interact with Kerani. That being said, there's another element I wanted to bring up with that. The novel and the rest of the characters almost does seem to circle around her as the center.
At least, I care for Kerani most. I care for the other characters through Kerani and I haven't found a single one who I've thought to be stronger or more important. This isn't to say that the world is based on minimalism and we're only getting a glimpse of her life, because that's not true. There's more out there and there are more important people and events, but in whole, this is her story.
She also...cries a lot? I guess I'm a little confused because I've never been able to do that. Maybe once a week or once every two weeks (this is more likely than the former) at best is the most I'm able to actually cry though to say the truth, I'm probably only weirded out by this because I'm not able to cry that much. Then again, I am also not in her situation and most likely don't know that amount of pressure.
Ahhhh. We get to know more about Suraj in this chapter and his current relationship with both Kerani and her father. I found that to be the most interesting aspect here. He attempts to reassure her and he's the heir to running the city which is a little odd because I've never seen a novel where two are wed in this position. Suraj seems to want to help more passively and is neutral while Kerani wants to be in the action protecting her family.
Especially the end shows that this isn't exactly what he wants and instead he's looking for a more 'traditional' wife in a way. Kerani however, wants the opposite. The ends happens quite swiftly and now I am itching for another chapter, though I don't mind if that doesn't come for awhile. Still, that cliffhanger is a punch in the face where the knuckles break your noise. I agree with Sins that the ending can be clarified, but overall once again I am crushed by your lovely writing!
If you have any questions, don't be afraid to ask! I hope I helped and have a great day.
Well, didn't I just take my merry old time?

Partly because it's been a while, and partly because I'm useless, my memory of where we left off with this is shocking. As such, if this review is a bit all over the place and... well, bad, I sincerely apologise. So yeah, just a heads up
I really loved this chapter/extract, seriously. I think a big reason for that is because it feels like we're properly getting to know Suraj, who thus far has been somewhat of an enigma, but here he's becoming a really fleshed out character. And I like him. Kerani's internal monologue here was pretty awesome too. I could feel how on edge she was towards the end of this, and her altering things to suit her instead of just throwing tantrums about having to marry is so badass. On the whole, this was just a really well written chapter. As this is her engagement party in effect (right? I hope I've not gotten the complete wrong end of the stick here), it's pretty important that this part is well written and exciting and stuff, so you go girl!
With critiques, as always, I don't have an awful lot to say. By which I mean I literally have one thing to mention. And there's a 90% chance that I'm just being dumb and forgetful. So yeah. At the beginning of this, Kerani mentioned her parents, and it kind of occurred to me that I don't remember ever meeting her mother? Or there being any mention of her really? Obviously, I may simply be an absolute idiot and simply can't remember the times we have met her, but if not, that's maybe something to think about. I'm assuming her lack of presence is likely to be to do with the patriarchal society Kerani finds herself in, and so her mother simply isn't super important, but methinks it could still be interesting to know more about her. But yeah, again, please just ignore this if I'm being a forgetful nonce.
Oh, something else I will note before I slither away is that I had to go back over the end of this to properly grasp what happened, and I'm still doubting myself slightly. I won't go on about this one because, again, probably just me being an idiot. Initially, I thought Kerani had attacked Suraj, and there was going to be anarchy. In case it isn't just me being an idiot, it may be worth making the events a little more clear? Just to avoid any further confusion on the part of losers like me.
Apologies again for taking me merry time with this. I would make up an excuse, but there isn't one. I'm literally just really lazy. I'm working on it though, I promise. Anywho, I hope I've been somewhat helpful, or just contributed something of some sort
Keep writing,
xoxo S(k)ins
You haven't met her mom at all, because her mom is currently in the capital of the Empire helping Ranya with the wedding. I have not introduced this concept much if at all (trying to go minimalist with how much information I give which leads to Big Holes as evident lol), so it's something for the next draft to better introduce lol
And... Kerani sort of does attack Suraj? She attacks an assassin, but Suraj tries to pull her away to "protect" her and it breaks her focus, so she shoves everyone back empathetically and it doesn't work on the attacker. I'll have to think of how to do that.
This stuff is helpful for the overall draft planning! Because honestly at this point it's a mad dash of "oh riiiiight that thing I haven't introduced yet" and I'm still figuring out the plot as an overreaching entity xD
Ah, I see! That makes total sense. She doesn't need a massive presence or anything (I'd not expect that), just perhaps a few mentions here and there so no one has that 'oh crap, yeah, where's her mother?' moment. Hardly a big issue though!
Ohhhhh, yeah that makes complete sense now. Action scenes can generally be an ass to write, but I honestly reckon the majority of it is literally just me being dumb, so don't stress over it or anything.
But yus, I'm glad I'm not totally useless anyway!!
Bonjour, Rosendorn.
All criticism and comments on the writing are in the spoiler below.
Spoiler
Also, the spaces between the dashes and text aren't necessary, but I suppose you could leave them like that without doing any harm. I believe that's all as far as criticism goes.
I think I dearly like Kerani, I think her name is. She isn't the stereotypically badass princess in that she's the younger sister of Ranya, but also that she doesn't try to fight off her marriage but cleverly alters it. The whole idea of this story is very likeable, and the description, although there isn't much of it, is good enough that I can clearly see everything that's occurring.
This was all very well done. I liked the dances and how you described them all. It lets the reader into the culture and traditions of the people we're reading and learning about and also relating with.
The only other comment I have is that I enjoyed this, and would like maybe a summary PMed to me so I can follow the story. It would be easier than trying to go back through all the chapters and reading them. Great story.
~Sourire
Thanks for the review! I will PM you a chapter by chapter summary and some responses to this
Hey just stopping by for a quick review! As I haven’t read the previous chapters I may be missing different nuances you are trying to portray, so take everything I say with a grain of salt and apply it as you see fit!
This sentence was a bit confusing for me, especially the end part about them returning and empire pieces. I’m not sure if you are saying that she usually wears traditional clothes, but was using fabric for the Empire from it? Would just love a little more clarity in this?
The part in bold was odd to me and made little sense. It’s totally possible you are making a reference to something in this universe I am unaware of, but since guard isn’t capitalized I’m assuming it’s not a proper noun, and therefore don’t know how it relates? Especially since guards don’t usually leave, they stay to protect, I don’t know I was just confused.
Loved this insight into her mind, and that she is an intelligent person
I think it should be, “I blinked away the unexpected desire to cry
Part of my confusion in this could easily be my lack of understanding for this colorful world you have created. The last sentence did feel disjointed to me however. I’m not sure if it should be, “Most days, most triggers, I could control the garukh yunu”, small distinction but it allows me to understand it is something specific. Not sure, just my opinion.
Should be “laughed, the sound” because it isn’t just “sound” in general but a specific sound that is transitioning.
I enjoyed this paragraph, especially the second sentence. How the worst tears came when they would ruin something. This was a powerful image in my head and communicated such strong emotion, love it.
Think you meant to say “struggling to breath in her panic.” Or something like that, since she isn’t literally breathing panic in.
Okay I am American, so we spell it “Colors”, but I did learn today that Canadians spell it “colours” so just pointing this out incase you did misspell it lol.
Think you meant, “And me being able to stop an assassin was more important than how I looked.’
The word “Independence” just felt odd to me. Maybe Independent sentiments would sound better, but that probably doesn’t convey the fight for independence and freedom which is where I am assuming the sentiments are leading… so not sure on it, just pointing it out because it read weird to me.
Just a very long sentence, I’d chop it up a bit.
I don’t think grip should be plural, I think it should just be grip.
I love how she is constantly analyzing everything and paying attention to what she would fix and change. The constant awareness to detail, and how you show that is very well done, and helps me grasp more who she is as a character.
I very much enjoyed this dance and the whole scene in general. The last sentence on this paragraph was a bit of a run-on again, but the imagery was great and moving.
I loved your imagery and similes throughout this entire chapter, but this one was odd for me. A glass knife and ice just seemed like an odd comparison and I wasn’t sure what you were trying to communicate with these words.
Overall I very much enjoyed it, thanks for posting and allowing me to read! If you have any questions please let me know!
Thanks for reviewing!
So. Clarifying things that I knew I should've put in the summary lol
Kerani has had 7 of her guard friends be taken away from her. She was trained as a guard semi-illegally, because she's a noble and guards are a totally different caste. But she was, and the attention to detail is the result of that. So is her utter dislike of getting betrothed, because the reason her friends were sent away was because she fell in love with one of them.
Her province was taken over by the Empire about 50 years ago, so some people are wanting independence back. Those who act on those desires are tried for treason. Kerani herself would like independence but not so much that she's working towards it/can be put on trial... but she's watched a few She much prefers local traditions, especially when it comes to clothing, and finds the Empire rather backwards in some regards.
Her sister was recently appointed to be Crown Princess and is going to marry the Prince, so her sister was forced to assimilate to Empire's culture instead of staying true to the province's culture. Hence the habit of some fabric choices coming back in Empire styles. However, this isn't something I've raised before so I really should tweak it
I'm Canadian so I use UK spelling, yes.
Garukh yunu is PTSD, so I treat them the same in narration (the rough translation is Kashmiri for "avalanche of memories"). So I won't be adding "the" to it, since the sentence doesn't make sense with "the ptsd." I generally dislike articles, on top of it lol As you noticed
Yes I'm missing a whole bunch of "was"s, thanks for pointing those out!
Glad you enjoyed the piece ^^ I'm always looking for new reviewers, so let me know if you want to be tagged in updates!