Mirror, Mirror

by Noelle

Published April 27, 2013

E - Everyone

In Shorts

Author note: Based on the song Mirror by BarlowGirl. The lines in bold are lines from the song. I do not own the song or the lyrics.


Mirror, mirror on the wall/Have I go it?
 
            Like the evil queen from the Snow White fairytale, she looks for acceptance in a piece of reflective glass; an inanimate object staring back at her. Its evil plans are worthy of Lucifer himself. It is deceptive and a liar, showing her only her worst fears and none of the truth.
 
‘Cause Mirror you’ve always told me who I am/I’m finding it’s not easy to be perfect
 
            The first thing she notices is the hair between her eyebrows. Leaning close, she picks out each individual one, counting aloud. Somewhere around four she loses track and starts over. When it becomes evident that she won’t be able to count them, she drops it. But they bother her so much that she just wants to reach up and rip them out one by one.
            You’ll be the only girl at your school with a unibrow. The mirror cackles. How embarrassing. Now you really won’t have any friends.
            As she’s raking the rest of her face for facial hair, her gaze lands on the blackheads dotting her cheeks. They have gotten worse over the past few weeks. Her mother had said that it was just stress and that they would disappear soon along with the red dots scattered on her forehead. That had made her feel better, but the mirror has other plans.
            Gross. No one can even look at you without noticing the enormous zits on your face. How can a boy talk to you, much less kiss you, with these monstrosities in the way?
            And her smile. When did her teeth get so yellow?
            There’s no way to fix that. No matter how many times you brush it’ll still be there. You’re gonna spend the rest of your life looking like a pirate.
            Her clothes were the worst part. She would wear dresses, but they were uncomfortable to sit in for eight hours every day at school. And none of the cute shirts at the mall fit her. The mediums were too tight and showed off all her fat and the larges made her look bigger than she was. So she stuck to wearing t-shirts and shopping for athletic shorts in the boys department.
            The short brown hair that always looked nicer down and curled under her chin was pulled back in a ponytail. Since it was so short, pieces fell out and stuck to the side of her cheeks as well as the back of her neck. Could she look any more like a guy?
            You may weigh 130, but you look like you weigh 150. Can’t you buy some clothes that even remotely look good on you?
            It’s the last straw. She stomps away from her trusted advisor and tears apart her closet. Clothes are flung on the bed, over the desk chair, over the floor. She finally finds it; the perfect dress. It’s pink and is covered in a flower pattern. There’s a layered belt wrapping around the waist, kind of like that of a cummerbund. A layered, three-dimensional flower clings to the right side of the belt.
            As she spins around the room, the dress flares out. She feels like a princess or one of those ballerinas that she used to be when she was little. It had been a while since she had put on the dress. She had bought it especially for Easter a few years before.
            “This will catch him off guard,” she mutters, determined to show the mirror that she could look cute. “There’s nothing he can say about this.” She stands in front of her old companion, hands on her hips, striking a pose that she had seen many models do in magazines. She waits for the praise, but it never comes. Instead, the mirror laughs.
            You thought that putting a dress on could make you pretty? Please! Look at the zits along your neckline. And the ones on your back; did you think of that before putting this on? What will people think when they’re walking behind you? And that hair—don’t get me started on the hair. You might as well shave your head and wear wigs the rest of your life. It will never look like the other girls’. You are a hopeless cause.
            Tears well up in her eyes and she buries her head in her hands. It’s official, she’s ugly; there’s no way to fix her. No matter how hard she tries or what outfit she puts on, there will be nothing nice to look at in the mirror.
            She runs from the room and disappears into her parents’ room. They have a full length mirror that she has never used before. Taking a shaky breath, she steps in front of it. Squeezing her eyes shut, she waits for the insults to come.
            But they never do. The mirror is silent. And so are her sobs. She wipes away the tears and gapes at the girl standing in front of her. Sure she might have one too many zits, but that doesn’t matter. Her hair could use a little work, but it isn’t her top priority. The unibrow seems to have magically disappeared.
            The reflection in this mirror is nothing like the one in the other. In this one, she is gorgeous. She doesn’t remember looking this nice on Easter a few years ago. But she looks beautiful here, now. And she wants to stay that way.
            Gathering up the courage, she stomps back into her room to face her mirror.
 
So sorry you won’t define me/Sorry you don’t own me
 
            You’re back. Still in that hideous outfit, huh? I especially like the way it hugs your huge hips.
            For a second, she falters. The mirror almost grabs another victory. But she gathers herself and glares at it.
            “For all these years you’ve been by my side, not once have you told me the truth.”
            Of course I have. You are far from perfect. How much more truth do you want?
 
Who are you to tell me/That I’m less than what I should be? Who are you? Who are you?
 
            “Of course I’m far from perfect. Who on the planet is perfect?”
            Not you.
            “No one,” she snaps. “That’s who. You’ve had me chasing a dream that was never reachable. I was chasing perfection; the perfect outfit, the perfect hair, the perfet body. But this is me and I won’t have you tear me down ever again.”
 
I don’t need to listen/To the list of things I should do/I won’t try, I won’t try.
 
            She reaches up and grabs the mirror from each side.
            Hey, what are you doing? No, wait! I—I can be a good mirror! You’re beautiful in that dress. It flows nicely at the bottom so your scrawny legs are hidden. No! That’s not what I meant. No, I—hey, what are you doing? Seven years of bad luck, remember that! Seven years, seven years, seven years—”
            She had smashes the mirror onto the floor, breaking it into about a million pieces. She gets her victory; she will be controlled no more.
 
Mirror I am seeing a new reflection/I’m looking into the eyes/of He who made me/And to Him I have beauty beyond compare/I know He defines me
 
            From then on, the only mirror she uses is the one in her parents’ room. It never talks to her; ever. But occasionally she gets a warm feeling in her heart when she touches it, like the mirror is trying to comfort her.
            Confidence doesn’t come easy to her and she struggles to find herself after being beaten down by the old mirror. The only thing that comforts her is the site of the new mirror. Every time she looks into it, she wishes that it would speak up. But it never does.
            She waits months to hear it speak. And one day does speak.
            I have made you in my image. And I make no mistakes. Do not think less of yourself. Represent me well and do not forget me. I am there; always.
            And the mirror never speaks to her again.
Comments & reviews · 6
User avatar
Iggy
Review
Iggy wrote a review Review · Jul 28, 2013

Hello darling. Since your Secret Santa never gave you your reviews, Santa's Elf is here to help. :)

First off, what a terribly heartbreaking piece to read. I love it because I can relate to this girl. I even feel as if she is me. I hate looking in the mirror because I hate what I seem sometimes. I'm not confident at all, and I feel the way she feels, when I try on clothes.

The mirror is a common enemy for all of us to hate, whether in real life or in this story. You make its words cruel, taunting, vindictive. You personify it to be a bully, who picks on this girl because of her imperfections. Then you give us a hero to love, the mirror in her parents room. We love it because of its silence, its comfort, the way it helps give the girl strength to see that nobody is perfect.

I really like this song. I shall definitely go listen to it later. I especially like that you gave credit to the originator, so kudos on that. They do have the copyrights and trademarks on it, after all.

This was beautofully written. I found no grammar errors, I was enthralled the entire time. I loved the way you wrote it!

One nitpick is the last sentence. I think it will flow better as - "And the mirror never spoke again."

That's all from me. Good job and just keep writing!

~ Iggy.

User avatar
BlueSquare
Review
BlueSquare wrote a review Review · Jul 18, 2013

I really enjoyed this piece. Obviously, different people get different things out of it. Here is what I got:

The story is about a girl who thinks she is ugly and overweight and no one likes her. She believes all of this because a "mirror" told her this (at first I thought you were using a reference to society, but I guess I was wrong). She constantly tries to "impress" the mirror, putting on extravagant clothes, makeup, and doing everything she can. But what she realizes is that she is beautiful in her own way. Yes, she may not be stick thin or have the prettiest eyes or the longest hair. But in God's eyes she is beautiful.

This is probably one of the best short stories I have ever read. I liked how it made tiny (yet noticeable) references to Snow White with the mirror, how the evil queen always went to the mirror for advice or whatever she had to ask it. I think that it was a very dramatic piece, but was very detailed and easy to read.

If I had to rate it, I'd give it a 5/5.

--BlueSquare--

User avatar
rwgbookwriter
Review
rwgbookwriter wrote a review Review · Apr 28, 2013

Hey Noelle

I really liked this story.I loved the way the mirror has a voice, and how its the mirror that has taught her to see herself as ugly.It was awesome, and it was spot on with everything the mirror said. So great job with understanding the way girls, and some guys, feel about mirrors.

I loved how you brought God into it. The one big piece of advice I have is that you bring what her parents mirror says up to the point where she looks into it for the first time, in the Easter dress. It would make more since that the first time she looks into it, it speaks to her, and then never again because it already told her what she needed to know.I thought the song lyrics were a very interesting touch to the story. I didn't particularly love reading them, because some of them felt disconnected.the ideas that they encompassed I felt stood

Great job, and MESSAGE me it you need anything

User avatar
emmylou1995
Review
emmylou1995 wrote a review Review · Apr 28, 2013

Hey Noelle!

I really liked this story. I thought it was cute and well executed and it has a very interesting theme to it. I loved the way the mirror has a voice, and how its the mirror that has taught her to see herself as ugly. it was clever, and it was spot on with everything the mirror said. It's exactly how those kinds of people feel when they look into a mirror. Trust me, I've been there. I still am. And I'm not 130 pounds, I'm a good deal more. So great job with understanding the way girls, and some guys, feel about mirrors.

I loved how you brought God into it. The one big piece of advice I have is that you bring what her parents mirror says up to the point where she looks into it for the first time, in the Easter dress. It would make more since that the first time she looks into it, it speaks to her, and then never again because it already told her what she needed to know. I thought the song lyrics were a very interesting touch to the story. I didn't particularly love reading them, because some of them felt disconnected. But the ideas that they encompassed I felt stood for a lot of great things, and it definitely fits with the story.

Great job, and message me with any questions.

Emmy

User avatar
rwalgren
Comment
rwalgren commented Comment · Apr 27, 2013

That was very inspirational. I like how you tied in the song too it really made the entire thing something different. I've never seen someone do that. I've seen something like oh this song inspired me to write this, but never actually including the song in the work. I'm guessing the one in her mirror symbolized the devil? or maybe self-criticism, and the one in the parent's bedroom was God or self-confidence?

Random avatar
MissCaroline
Review
MissCaroline wrote a review Review · Apr 27, 2013

I really loved this story! It hit home for me as I struggle, occasionally, with outside appearance. I loved the way you put the mirror's perspective in the story. I just loved the whole idea. I didn't really care for the song lyrics randomly placed in, but I guess it's because I have never heard the son before. :)



Dogs love their friends and bite their enemies, quite unlike people, who are incapable of pure love and always have to mix love and hate.
— Sigmund Freud