Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
i love this i was just going to skim it at first and i read all of it.
Love the story
that sentence confused me. Who's she? Who left who in what place?
Besides that, the story was excellent. Loved the Katie type flashbacks, but it took a very long time for me to realize that Randy was married. Maybe establish that just a little earlier? But besides that i loved your story.
Hi Evi, Lilicia here! I owe you a review (thank you so much for reviewing my murderer thing, it really helped!) - so here it is...
I could only find a few nitpicks:
Firstly, this is amazing, so well written, and simply beautiful. The last line really got to me, it was such a beautiful ending that I felt all warm inside
This bothers me - when sun shines in my eyelids, I see red - not gold. It's a fact... Also, I think if you mention the colour red it would go really well with the way you described the light as 'bleeding' in.
Should be 'Your'
OMG. So beautiful - it finishes the story so well!
Sorry I couldn't be much help as a reviewer, but I honestly couldn't find anything else wrong with this story. I hope this wins the contest!
*gold star*
Keep writing!
Hey Evi ^^ Shina here to do a review
Like usual, reviewing people like you is kind of challenging. Which is why I sit on it for a bit and then review it.
xD It's long overdue, but you know, I promised
I. Nitpicks
Your first sentence is the little girl, the hook. The next sentence should support it, but it abruptly changes to Randy. I think you should switch the second sentence around.
"Once upon a time, there was a beautiful princess named Katie."
The sound of the little girl's voice, high and clear over the rush of the takeoff made me groan."
Or something like that. The sentence you have is A B A. Katie, Randy, Katie. Maybe later in the story, but not in the beginning. It might just be me, but I'll still point it out
Okay, this is one long sentence. And I'll attack it piece by piece.
* The repitition of "me' is bugging me. Perhaps being more specific with one of them, for example "scrambled over my lap" or "stabbing my cheek with Fairytale Barbie's pin-straight plastic legs" that way, it's not general and not repetitive.
-"to get to", can simply be "to reach." Less wordy.
-If his eyes are closed, how can he describe this scene
This sounds like she's outside the plane xD
"elevating herself so that she had a better view of the window"
"elevating herself so that she could see out the window"
Or something like that.
You forgot to add "my"
I'm pretty sure if something nags you, it's uncomfortable.
I'm murdering your word count xD. Ever since I read a book about things that are redundant, anything repetitive is on my radar.
Worried is also a verb, so no need for "was."
xD *cracks up* Randy must feel SO much better now.
*pulls out redundancy tracker* Nothing shall get past me! *cackles*
The problem with 1st person is that you can't see things if you're eyes aren't open. His eyes are closed here. He can't see her shaking her head.
*continues to murder word count*
Mentioned this earlier, no need here.
Typo. Mouth*
You know your airplanes well, Ms. Evileen. ^^ My mom works at the airport xD We fly free, so we go places with thirty minute notices.
"Victoriaa! We're going to California in thirty minutes!"
"Yes, mom." -groans.
The only thing not mentioned are the pillows and blankets they give you and the overhead light and AC. Sometimes, they have radio and movies, too. Might want to mention those if you want.
You used "worried" earlier. Synonym? Also, it's a bit tell-y for me, Katie's expressions and the way they say things.
"Katie asked, the corners of her lips falling" or something that shows more of an image.
Scrap the "her," you mention "she" twice, therefore, no need.
The chocolate chip cookie thing is a new addition, isn't it? It's an odd one out to me. Maybe something with a less positive connotation. Maybe mug Randy got her, or vase of flowers he got her. Otherwise, it seems like she was eating cookies, then she was yelling. It makes her seem bipolar or moody, or something. I think you were going for something that would mean nothing else matter except that she was mad, or to signify her anger.
"I drank it until it was gone *before crumpling the plastic cup and stuffing it in the backpocket of the seat in front of me, exhaling jaggedly."
Just an option, you can also replace "before" with a comma.
This makes it sound like Randy and Katie already made up because you say "the last time we fought" and then she insisted they put it back on the nightstand. Katie and Randy are fighting still, in this part, aren't they? That's why Randy is upset. If she put their picture back on the nightstand in their last fight, I'm sure they'd be together again. Kind of confusing, but get what I mean?
This reminds me of the time I saw a briefcase sitting in the middle of nowhere at the airport. I actually didn't report it because I was creeped out. People notice, they just don't take time to care.
Also, "nobody" should be "no one"
Overall:
Evi, you write some of my favorite stories on YWS ^^ They have morals and the way you step into your characters' POV's is awesome. The main problem I'm seeing here is that your description is good in some areas, but other times, when it comes to describing actions or the way things are said, they're telly.
In other words, too many adverbs.
Jaggedly, worriedly, experimentally,etc. Some are okay, but not too many.
It had meaning to it, a moral, well executed, accurate airport description, and airplane, but like I said, they give you pillows and blankets, there's an overhead light, and there are magazines and a barf bag in the pouch in front of you. Movies, radio, ear-plugs.
And like I said about the suspicious bags and figures, people notice, they just don't take time to care. Which is why the "Maybe nobody had noticed" bugs me.
Hope that helped ^^
-Shina
Bare with me here, this is my first post xD.
I think you should combine those two sentences... they're both pretty small sentences: One peanut after another; they were too salty.
But, aside from the one thing I could find xD, that was a cute story. I loved Katie--the younger one--because her heart was just open to Randy. You were amazing at describing how a child exactly acts. One of my favorites :].
Evileen! I have a bad habit now, that whenever I see you have posted something, I have to review it. Even if I owe three other people reviews, I have to immediately review you. Which is bad of me, but... >.>
I have never personally seen someone with cerulean eyes, so I'm kinda not liking this. Also, if many people haven't looked in a pack of crayons, they don't know what cerulean is. XD So, I'm not sure if I like cerulean there.
He put his hand into a fist and pressed the button? So he pressed it with his fist? That's what it sounds like in this context. Which, annoys me. Did he clench one of his hands and press the button with the other hand? That just annoys me here.
This part kinda annoys me. Earlier, you said that he made his chair go back so he could sleep. And somehow, during his sleep, he leaned forward and to the right and was asleep on Katie? It's...confusing how he fell like that. Just pointing that out. ^_^
Did you reword this part or something? I think you did. Personally, I thought it was fine the first time. Like...now it sounds awkward. But what you had before sounded perfectly fine to me. Just saying, darling.
I lovelovelovelovelovelovelovelovelove this line. It's like, so amazing. And it gives us some insight on Randy (speaking of Randys, that's why that name sounded familiar today. There is a new kid in my classes named Randy. Weird). <3 Love it.
That sounds like my mom and me. XD
Personally, I want some more description here. She's in her pajamas, okay -- did she just wake up? was her hair messed up? Give us a reasons why we might not think she looked beautiful and yet, he thought so. More description would be nice here, darling.
I know it's okay to start a sentence with And, but it's annoying me here. It doesn't sound very good. Maybe just reword that sentence so it doesn't have to start with and and it can still be only one sentence.
TAKE OUT THAT COMMA AND PUT A PERIOD. YOU KNOW YOUR DIALOUGE PUNCTUATION, MISSY.
Awesome, awesome, aaawsome. ^_^
Your writing style and my great discovery
Characters!
I love it, Evileen. Another amazing story written by you. I love the twist it had, because for Tiff's contest, I was expecting real fairytales. And this was something totally different. Good job, darling.
*Linx
Hiya, Evi! I saw this on the front page, and I started reading it . . . then it intrigued me so much that I had to read the whole thing.
I'm going to start off by saying that this was absolutely amazing. And, in an attempt to give you a good and proper review, most of my comments are probably going to be about specifically what I found amazing. I did find one or two minor nitpicks, though.
Mid-splits... something about that seems a bit oddly worded in the context of the sentence. Firstly, I can't entirely picture what 'mid-splits' would look like, so maybe that's part of what's throwing it off for me. It's possibly a reader's perspective thing, but I just wanted to point out that it sounded strange to me.
'But I didn't say that' sounds a bit too straightforward amidst the rest of your show-not-tell writing style. You might find a little bit different way to convey that message.
Announced.
So, now, back to the points of amazingness.
First of all, Katie was my favorite part of the story. Not all writers out there can pull off that innocent wisdom of a little kid, but you did it well. You had those parts of childish innocence that reminded us of how little she was, interspersed with those knowledgeable times that showed us how well she could see through Randy. What I really loved about her was that you never knew which side you were going to see her show next. Absolutely adorable.
Another thing I enjoyed about your piece was your extreme attention to detail. You really followed this through the Barbie doll, especially. Every time the focus of either of your characters shifted, the readers knew exactly where the Barbie was, and what she was doing. I really loved that. To further my point, you painted perfectly clear pictures of absolutely every object and every movement, from the cup being placed on the indention in the tray, to Randy's Katie's ring shrinking around her finger. When a lot of writers try to describe things that vividly, it often sounds cluttered and disorganized or overflowing with purple prose. You, however, have a very interesting knack for getting it just right.
And, on a purely fun note, I have to tell you how much I loved the bit about the tie. That was so cute! It melted my heart.
Very nicely done.
~Imin
That was beautiful. So well written. Like Shina, I saw it on the homepage and just had to read the rest. Kiddie Katie is a great character. ^^
Wonderful read.
One oh so insignificant thing: Maybe you could have said why Randy was on the plane? Had he gone on a holiday/break for a bit?
My favourite part:
That was a magnificent end. Lovely.
Yeah, I'm sorry, this isn't really a review. I just wanted to let you know you've done a brilliant job.
~EmmaJane~
Wow, I really loved this story. What's even better is that I flew today, and the way you described it so accurately was honestly amazing! My favorite accurate thing would have to be the suspicious persons or unattended bags part, because you honestly hear that about every five minutes. Also, one of my nicknames is Katie, so it kind of took on a special meaning. Loved it
Evi ^^ Shina here to [s]review[/s] comment on you O_O
It looks I have quite a bit of competition in this contest
I just saw this on the homepage, I think *doesn't remember*, started scanning through it and ended up reading the whole thing.
I can't do a review for you right now =_= I-I'm not in the review mode at the moment.
However, I must say that I like the idea you have here and it was well-written ^^ Very well written. xD Your knowledge of barbie doll movements is awesome.
However, I'm not sure if a Barbie can "erupt into elaborate leaps and twirls." Through my skim-reading, that was the only thing that bothered me.
I'll be back for a full-length review
-Shina