Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey guys I got third place in the contest! Yay!
Hi there! Sorry this took me a couple of days to get to but here I am
Right! First off, I like your title. It's simple but interesting and it fits with the poem nicely so no problems there. However, I think the flow of your poem needs some work. At the moment you have a lot of beautiful imagery but it's too disjointed and there's not enough tone to the piece. Tone is where you find the emotion and the poetic voice and it's lacking a little here. I'll see if I can give some tips as I work through it a line at a time...
Alright. So I like this but there's a lot that feels rough and I think you should do a few exercises to work on tone and try to avoid those 'poetic' phrases. Some good imagery here though and I think it has potential. Let me know if you've got any questions or would like me to take another read,
Heather xx
Absolutely fantastic imagery! Very emotional and a true sentimental poem (Though not in the usual sense). I love the layout you chose (most people, myself included, just keep the poem on the right side of the page without bothering to change the layout) That's why I liked that you centered it. For some reason, this helped me enjoy the poem better (not a clue why).
I guess it just caught my interest.
Well done!
Forever write! It's the best way to get out what you need to say.
-Makayla
Well, it looks like Moon beat me to a full, comprehensive review, so this shouldn't be too long.
This is incredible. Imagery, emotion, rhythm...the list of the traits it possesses goes on forever. Spectacular work! This really was a treat to read.
-Kafka
Good job, very strong imagery. Maybe even a tiny bit too much, since it get a bit muddled in a few of the stanzas. To start, I really like the theme of the poem, since its very obscure, but painted very clearly for the reader in the title and the words of the poem. Yet it still is obscure. Very good, I like it.
If you want advice on improvment on this poem, you can take mine or not, but here it is:
This is the second line of the poem, and early on, you create imagry, that while very powerful, is confused because its difficult to say. This threw me off, and will do the same with most readers. The awekwardness of the line is in "star sprinkled plains," now, while I love the use of the word "sprinkled," I simply don't think it can work there. I'd suggest removing "sprinkled" and simply writing "starry plains,". Maybe I like that because it reminds me of Van Gough's "Starry Night", but that's just me. Anyway, changing this will help with the flow of the poem and make it easier on the reader, meaning that by taking away the description "sprinkled" the rest of your descriptions are mosr powerful and meaningful to the readers.
Another thing that I feel I have to mention is that you shouldn't be using commas at the end of each stanza. Sometimes you can, and I wasn't going to mention it at first, since it wasn't getting in the way at first, but near the end it causes so me conflict in meaning. I'd suggest simply using the proper grammical characters at the end of every line, whether a period, a comma, or nothing.
One line that I'd like to bring your attention to, simply because I love the description
I really like the descriptive words used here, and all the repeated constients make it very attractive and bold ("Mottled splatters"). And "paint strokes" has a good amount of connotations and my eyes as an artist, and will with many readers.
This is a good example as any to use in showing that the commas really get in the way. When I see the comma there, I anticipate a space when saying the phrase out loud in my head.
This is the next line, and I'm not at all anticipating it, so my mind makes the description muddled. I feel that the comma somewhat ruined the description for me, since it wasn't at all powerful for me, and I didn't understand what it was saying.
That's another thing about the commas, they make the descriptions almost frustrating to read, in my opinion, and obscure what your words are saying, which isn't a good thing.
Anyways, I've gone long enough. It needs polishing here and there, but I'll like it a million times more if there aren't commas stopping me from reading the descriptions properly and if you change a few of the more awekward descriptions.
And don't be discouraged or anything, you did a really good job. Thinking back on the poem, its incredibly beautiul, and could bring tears to my eyes if the words you used could see their true potential.
Great writing, your wonderful with vocabulary and descriptive words and imagry! Please keep writing, I'd love to see more from you!
This part is my favourite part of this poem. This is really good. There isn't really much else to say. Well done.